Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Vietnam - mahine content

Posts

Vietnam - mahine content

#1

Vietnam - mahine content

ThomD

>I don't think I give a moment's thought to the fact that hand tool woodworking is so completely out of date and primitive. Sure it's just a hobby so who cares. Also wood works fast enough that there are times where money and time are saved versus running around and finding anything even close in a furniture store.

I got a little shock, though, the other day. There was a show I caught a few minutes of on the History Channel, that consisted of a series of reminiscences from a journalist who covered the Vietnam war. One story he filed, the one I saw, was a report on the dispersal of industry into fragmented bush workshops, under canopies of natural roofing material, to avoid the bombing of Hanoi.

The film showed young women manning lathes in bush workshops. As a machine tool guy I got pretty excited at the opportunity to see these old machines, presumably acquired prior to the war, maybe French. What really struck me was that they were all more advanced than the lathes in my shop! Not really a surprise since I have mostly circa WWII lathes. But somehow I feel current, part of the brotherhood of old iron users. It really drove home how hopelessly low tech it all is to have a big collection of tools that would have been out of date in bomb blasted Vietnamese jungle workshops. Those folks with the hours they were putting in were infinitely more productive than I am. Kinda stung, and the whole woodworking hand tool thing is from another planet!

Rant off!

Re: Vietnam - mahine content

#2

The sisterhood of the traveling lathes?

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Sorry, couldn't help myself.

Re: Vietnam - mahine content

#3

Re: Vietnam - mahine content

Alex Grigoriev

>Thanks for bombing them into stone age, under the guise of "liberation". Special thanks for napalm and Agent Orange.

Re: Vietnam - mahine content

#4

Political issues

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Alex,

Some folks here would agree with you; some would disagree. This could rapidly get into a political conversation for which this forum's not the right place.

Bill

Re: Vietnam - mahine content

#5

Re: Political issues

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Thanks Bill,

Also, I don't believe Thom bombed Vietnam. Just so we get that straightened out.

Wiley

Re: Vietnam - mahine content

#6

Re: Political issues

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Even if he did, it's highly unlikely it was his decision to do so.

Re: Vietnam - mahine content

#7

Keeping technology current

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Remember that the shops weren't in the jungle to start with - the businesses involved would probably have been trying to keep current in terms of tooling.

Hard to picture a CNC operation under a tree, though...I can imagine all the electronic components turning up their little silicon toes during the first rainy season.

Digressing...my younger son inherited his great-uncle's mid-1930's metal lathe. He signed up for a lathe class at the local community college, but dropped it. The instructors (all considerably younger than the lathe) were unable to tell him how to operate it. It's understandable - their orientation is training workers for industry, and industry is using newer equipment than 1930 something. Sad, though, that they were then condescending toward a tool that served my uncle well, and is serving my son just as well, after he found an old book on lathe operation.

Re: Vietnam - mahine content

#8

Re: Keeping technology current

ThomD

>The 30s lathes are perfectly functional as manual lathes, or even bases for CNC lathes today. One thing that I learned from a friend who has been in the trade his whole life is that relatively small changes would make a lathe obsolete. For instance some lathes had chucks that screwed on while later they developed cam chuck that sorta snap on. The mounting plates for the cam chucks are extremely expensive, and the screw on chucks are familiar to me from woodturning. But on has to accept that these small differences were decisive to maintaining production efficiency in a competitive setting. For the home shop guy, the cheaper back plates is potentially decisive.

Another example is quick change gear boxes vs manual gears, where to get into gear one has to change several gear sets, loosen and tighten bolts. The gear boxes are better all around, but for the modern guy the manual gears can be a good deal because they are easily and cheaply replaced, and more likely to be found in a low mileage lathe. If you find a good gear box lathe, all the better, but the likelihood of finding a good manual one is possibly higher.

This does have something to do with handtools also. It is worth keeping in mind how the uses and preferences changed from different periods and the reasons why we like something today may have nothing to do with the tool's original place in it's time.

Re: Vietnam - mahine content

#9

Re: Vietnam - machine content

ThomD

>Without prejudice one could at a minimum claim from the short piece I saw that some of these targets had military value.