Re: Trufe!
James Watriss
>You got it Wiley...
At some point I wrapped my index finger around the iron of a #3, and eureka, realized that this is a comfortable plane to use. It's not that much smaller than a 4, it's not appreciably shorter, so in my head, it's just as good. But having that narrower iron helped it fit my hand better. In general, I use it for just about everything, and the #3 has become one of my general go-to planes for most things, from spring joints to smoothing of most parts. (I'm also a big fan of the 50 degree L-N #4, and a Low-angle jack with a few extra blades ground to different angles, and the three of those planes did most of my work while I was in school.)
To be honest, I'm starting to appreciate the bigger smoothers now that I have the blade centering grub screw thing worked out. I think that it helps make the lateral adjustment more sensitive. But that's another point in the narrower planes' favor... it's easier to get the lateral adjustment set up. The wider the blade is, the farther the corners come out when the blade swings around. So, especially for a beginner, I think the 3 is just easier to use, because it's easier to set the blade up properly.
I think there's something to be said for getting used to certain tools, and think that in the long run, I could really get used to a 4.5, or a 5.5. I'm sure that the big plane, big tool, big man crowd would grunt and do some self-congratulatory chest thumping over that. But I think it's more important to get used to working more than fettling or adjusting. Because I was spending so much time trying to figure out the tools, I got in the habit early on of getting too used to things being "in process," and it took some of the steam out of the engine, so to speak. It's too easy to get complacent, and rely on the status quo of "still working on it... I'll get there eventually," to help you forget that you've been working on that thing for... how long now?
I realize that this flies in the face of all manly bravado about competence, and what a real man, or a real woodworker could do. I used to hear that at school once in a while... that a real woodworker would, or could, do things a certain way, using just a one inch chisel, and not need such and such a tool, or need to crutch along using whatever jig was being discussed. And maybe that's true at a certain level. But I think that flogging yourself along the way to getting there is self-defeating. Woodworking is about working wood. Part of that involves learning about the tools. But I am aware, from previous discussions, that there's a pretty well established contingent of people who do this for a hobby, and they'd rather work the wood than work on the tools... which is where the boutique vendors come in. (And I love 'em, don't get me wrong.) The hand-eye coordination development will catch up eventually, but in the meantime... how long have you been working on that thing?
Once my tools were settled and fettled, and I was able to get up a good head of steam over the course of the average day, I found it was a lot nicer to be able to just get to work. I could worry about the work, and not the tools, and get things done. I started to get used to things wrapping up, and I was better able to view whole projects, and get out of the piece-meal, kinda-sorta, it'll get there eventually doldrums. I started getting more excited about things like finishing, because I got to do it more often. Whatever makes that happen for you has to be a good thing.
It's all a learning curve, really. And the biggest lesson to learn is how to get over or around it. But I like what you said about using this plane as a user and having the extra blade for reference... because sometimes it's easy to get so wrapped up in the tools that you really get lost in the woods over it, and the actual wood working goes by the wayside somehow. It can be a lot more useful sometimes to use the crutch to get out of the woods, accept it for what it is, maybe not success, but certainly not defeat, lick your wounded pride, and gear up for whatever the next learning curve will be. A good, practical attitude is still a much more useful tool than anything made out of steel.
I realize this all sounds kinda chest-thumping, puffed up, and self-congratulatory in its own way. And after reading all of what I just wrote, I think it makes me sound more competent than I feel sometimes. Every day is a learning experience, and chances are, there's something that's going to need to be tinkered. The latest challenge for me has been the band saw, and trying to get it to behave in a more predictable fashion. Just as I can recognize when Dom's wooden plane is getting shavings jammed under the wedge or the cap iron, I want to be able to look at the bandsaw, and know just what isn't running right, and adjust accordingly. But I still have those days when a big piece of 12/4 wanders away from the fence, and I lose half an inch of usable thickness in a resawing job. Resawing on my 18" Laguna band saw is one of those things that I feel like I almost have it down... but I've been stuck in the limbo of "almost" for a while now. So the other day I ponied up and ordered some Laguna guides and their resaw king blade. We'll see what happens with that. And once I have the Laguna under control, I'll worry about the 36" Yates.
----------------
Uh, so that's why I like using the #3... : )
It's comfortable in use, not appreciably smaller than the #4, and easier to get set up.
I think I need to go find my hot air valve....