Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Help with troubleshooting wooden coffin smoother

Posts

Help with troubleshooting wooden coffin smoother

#1

Help with troubleshooting wooden coffin smoother

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>Hi gang

I just finished cleaning up this Union Warranted Coffin Smoother and have been having some problems getting it to work properly. I took a lot of photos in the hopes that the more knowledgeable of you could offer me some tips.

This Union Warranted Coffin Smoother was purchased at a local flea market for the kingly sum of $5 (and I know that one of you will say I paid way too much for it!) and it came with a very nice Butcher Iron. But at the same place I found a Buck Brothers Iron of the same size. The seller threw that in as an incentive (NOW did I pay too much?). So I can swap out one or the other. Both of these irons had their backs flattened and polished to a mirror finish. The bevels were hollow ground and sharpened to the point where they could cut end grain pine with little effort.

Photobucket

Photobucket

There were some cracks on the body that I repaired with a bit of epoxy and some sawdust. But any that were in non critical areas I left alone. Near the abutments there were some stress fractures. But these were glued and clamped up overnight. In the photos below it LOOKS like there is a crack on one "ear", but it's really filled with epoxy and sawdust. I flattened the sole on some sandpaper as well as flattening the back of the wedge. I also cleaned up the points of the wedge to get rid of areas where chips would snag. Where I sanded, I gave the body a coat of BLO and allowed it to dry before waxing. I made sure that I didn't get any oil or wax in the abutments, bed, or ears.

When I installed the iron/chipbreaker assembly and wedge into the smoother I noticed that the wedge was VERY tight in regards to the sides. I believe that this would account for the cracks near the abutments. I sanded the wedge so that I got a nice even fit. I also took care to assure that there weren't any gaps between the wedge and the cheek. You can see this in the highlighted areas of the photos below.

Photobucket

Photobucket

After all this tuning up, I decided last night to give this little beauty a test drive on some nice straight grained cherry. However, when I went to use it I ran into all sorts of problems.

1.) The original iron just fits the mouth opening. And I had thought that I re-ground the bevel so that it was 90 deg to the sides. But this iron has slightly tapered sides. So it's close, but not dead on. This makes getting an even "reveal" pretty difficult. I ended up swapping out the Butcher Iron and replacing it with the smaller Buck Brothers Iron. You can see the amount or room between the sides of the iron and the sides of the mouth in the last photo.

2.) I can't get the wedge to hold the iron in place. When I hit a particularly knarly or tough patch of grain, it moves. From the photos you can see that I have the wedge as tightly fit as I can get it.

3.) When I tap on the back of the iron, the iron moves and the chip breaker DOESN'T! This is with BOTH the Butcher AND the Buck Brothers Irons! So the amount of iron showing increases each time I tap the back of the iron!

4.) Last but not least; I get chips clogged in one corner. I'm thinking that the points of the wedge need to be shortened so that the are sitting on the flat of the chip breaker. If they are near the end where it curves, then there is a place for a chip to get stuck.

Photobucket

Photobucket

Photobucket

I've been reading through Whelan's "Making Traditional Wooden Handplanes" as well as Finck's "Making & Mastering Wood Planes". These books helped a lot. But I would really appreciate input from members who tune up and use wood hand planes.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Help with troubleshooting wooden coffin smoother

#2

Wish I could help on your problem

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>but my knowledge of woodies is all but non-existent.

I just wanted to be the first to jump in and say that, no, $5 is not too much. In fact, once you get this tuned up, it might even qualify as sucking.

Re: Help with troubleshooting wooden coffin smoother

#3

Re: Help with troubleshooting wooden coffin smooth

James Watriss

>Hey Dom,

I'd check out a few things.

-Rub the entire back of the iron (the part that contacts the bed, not the entirely flat part) with a really soft pencil, and see what happens when you tap the iron to adjust... how much lead is transferring to the bed of the plane.

-Check the placement of the screw for the cap iron. I really doubt it's hitting the end of the groove, but it might explain why it's not moving, if everything is really wedged tightly.

-Here's the thing... if the wedge is holding the cap iron down so tightly that it doesn't move, it's holding it against the blade that tightly, and the blade shouldn't move either. So I'm wondering if the blade is making good contact with the bed, or if the cap iron is being help up in the slot.

-Close up that mouth!

-Re: the sides, one of the things I was taught to do with japanese planes... grind away the corners, so that the exposed part of the blade will feed directly into the throat. Obviously, you're feeding chips directly intot he wedge, or under it, or between the blade and the cap iron, or something else. Grind away those corners so that whatever chips are being produced are fed directly intot he open part in the middle of the throat. Normally, when they're new (as far as I know... hopefully Larry Williams will chime in at some point) the wedge will seat all the way down, and come out to the corners, in such a way that there's no way for the shavings to get jammed into the corner like that. But, given the shape it's in, I'd say grinding away the corners might work pretty well for you. It might help with that over-sized iron, too.

-It might be silly, or not... but might be worth laminating a new full sole to the plane. I have a small coffin smoother I'm getting ready to do this to, I'll post pictures when it's done. I'll mention tomorrow night one way or another how the scheduling is working out.

Re: Help with troubleshooting wooden coffin smoother

#4

Dominic in Bucks County PA

Thanks James

Dominic in Bucks County PA

>

James,

You wrote:

"Rub the entire back of the iron (the part that contacts the bed, not the entirely flat part) with a really soft pencil, and see what happens when you tap the iron to adjust... how much lead is transferring to the bed of the plane."

I have a feeling that there may be some residue left on teh iron from me giving it a coat of 3-in-1 oil. That's the first thing I'll check. Then I'll use your pencil trick

"-Check the placement of the screw for the cap iron. I really doubt it's hitting the end of the groove, but it might explain why it's not moving, if everything is really wedged tightly."

I did that already and it looks like it has enough room. So I wasn't bottoming out.

"-Here's the thing... if the wedge is holding the cap iron down so tightly that it doesn't move, it's holding it against the blade that tightly, and the blade shouldn't move either. So I'm wondering if the blade is making good contact with the bed, or if the cap iron is being help up in the slot."

I'm thinking it's a combination of poor mating with the bed.

"-Close up that mouth!"

Yeah, I'm thinking that now this is a good excuse to try inlaying a nice dry piece of pear wood in the mouth area. What's the worse that can happen? Bare minimum I practice my parring and working with my LV lg router plane. If I screw up, THEN I can think about just adding a new sole.

"-Re: the sides, one of the things I was taught to do with japanese planes... grind away the corners, so that the exposed part of the blade will feed directly into the throat. Obviously, you're feeding chips directly into the wedge, or under it, or between the blade and the cap iron, or something else. Grind away those corners so that whatever chips are being produced are fed directly into the open part in the middle of the throat. Normally, when they're new (as far as I know... hopefully Larry Williams will chime in at some point) the wedge will seat all the way down, and come out to the corners, in such a way that there's no way for the shavings to get jammed into the corner like that. But, given the shape it's in, I'd say grinding away the corners might work pretty well for you. It might help with that over-sized iron, too.

-It might be silly, or not... but might be worth laminating a new full sole to the plane. I have a small coffin smoother I'm getting ready to do this to, I'll post pictures when it's done. I'll mention tomorrow night one way or another how the scheduling is working out."

Not sure what you mean. Do you mean to grind away the corners on the wedge? I've parred them down to a point and angled them so that chips SHOULD be fed up the throat. But obviously, that didn't quite work out as planned. :>)

Thanks again for all the help,

Dominic

Re: Help with troubleshooting wooden coffin smoother

#6

Re: Thanks James

ThomD

>The difference with the Japanese and wedged planes is that the Japanese planes don't have a wedge, and the compound blade taper is in the opposite direction. Japanese blades thin towards the edge in both dimensions while western blades run from parallel to thinning in both directions away from the edge. The Japanese plane uses the margin of the blade edges to retain the blade, so if the plane was 60mm wide it might have a cutting edge of only 54 mm. The wedge style you have is specifically designed to use full blade width by the cutaway wedge that tapers to nothing. It is just a mater of cleaning up the wedge function.

You could deploy some of the features of a Japanese plane with a western plane since really wedge or no wedge is much the same idea, but it would require creating something of a hybrid to say the least. I make my Krenov style planes with a lot of Japanese features, since I have been making both since the late 70s or early 80s. But the style of plane you have has it's own logic and there isn't any real reason to change it.

Sometimes the wedges and blades are all mix and matched to make up a plane for sale at the flea market, so don't be too surprised if you have to do some tuning or even make some new parts.

All you should really need to do to get the shavings moving by narrowing the blade width is possibly curve the blade edge slightly, as is good practice to avoid tracks in the wood. That will run out towards the edge of the plane, and deal with shaving width issues. It's impractical to try to get the full width of the blade in the cut with a curved edge so there will be some slight narrowing in the cut width. The rest of it should be dealt with by working the points and contours of the wedge. A wedge can distort over the centuries, so you may want to tweak it a little to get the points better seated, and also blueprint it. Clamp it across the body so you can't split it and wedge the points apart a little and leave it overnight, would be one option.

Be sure your iron is actually flat before you graphite it all up. No point in carefully fitting it if you don't have a clean surface. Also work on getting the bearing better towards the sides of the ramp, that is where the main wedging force is

I would only work on the mouth when you get the rest of it working first. Sure a tight mouth is important for super performance, but get basic performance with the open mouth, then work on getting the tight mouth and the finest shavings. Solving one functional issue at a time is a better way of sorting out the problems. Also, there is a lot of hotrod plane use out there. But it isn't always practical depending on what you want. Planes that take micro shavings are only relevant for certain kinds of finishing approach (or the fun of it), which aren't really the kind of finishing most people seem to prefer. So it can pay off if the plane is actually a little less that all it can be. If the routine is something like plane, scrape, finish sand, then max finishing plane performance is not really required. Of course a lot of fleamarket planes come with a 1/4" mouth opening and have to be dealt with. Seems as though most fine planes from long ago went through a stewardship phase where they were used by incompetent people and ended up getting opened up a lot.

Re: Help with troubleshooting wooden coffin smoother

#7

Gaping maws

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I don't think the mouth is all that important relative to the other issues either. I once had to plane some bocote, and the only plane that would handle it was a coffin smoother with a gaping maw for a mouth. I mean huge, like almost 1/2".

Re: Help with troubleshooting wooden coffin smoother

#8

Re: Help with troubleshooting wooden coffin smooth

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Dom,

After reading all this, I would suggest you tackle the first issue you mentioned first. That is, the problem of the blade not being held tight by the wedge. Fix that, and then get to the shavings packing in.

Regarding the blade backing out on you, it seems to me the wedge is not fully seated. This is just a hunch, since I'm not looking at the plane. But it seems like the wedge is still either too tight to the sides, or else is hanging up in the abutments.

There is no need to make a gapless (tight) fit between the wedge sides and the cheeks. Judging from several C&W planes, I would suggest you give the wedge some slight clearance, like about 1/64" each side. Then check whether the wedge and wedge horns are hanging in the abutments. If you can't check this visually or with a feeler gauge, pencil the roof of the abutments with soft pencil, and then see how the horns of the wedge are picking up the pencil--you're looking for pencil all along the upper edge of the horns.

Wedge fit and blade holding first; then shavings second.

Wiley

Re: Help with troubleshooting wooden coffin smoother

#9

Dominic in Bucks County PA

Thanks Wiley!

Dominic in Bucks County PA

>Wiley,

Thanks for the input. I wanted to go out in the shop last night and see if I could put your suggestions to work. But the weather report said it was 6 deg F and I just couldn't bear to be out there! I know, I'm a whimp.

Anyway, I will work on actually getting the wedge working properly before I concentrate on the mouth.

I wish I could use a new version of this plane, properly tuned and all so that I could see how they are SUPPOSED to operate. I think the experience that really "turned on the lightbulb" for me in regards to hand planes was using a new LN smoother. It made me realize how a plane SHOULD work! Sort of gave me a mark to shoot for. Know what I mean?

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Help with troubleshooting wooden coffin smoother

#10

Re: Thanks Wiley!

Dan Donaldson

>Find someone that has a Clark and Williams that lives near you. That will show you how one should work.

Re: Help with troubleshooting wooden coffin smoother

#11

6 deg F!! Heatwave woohooo 8-)

Bob Demers

>

Re: Help with troubleshooting wooden coffin smoother

#12

At 6 deg my woodie would refuse to too.

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>

Re: Help with troubleshooting wooden coffin smoother

#13

Re: At 6 deg my woodie would refuse to too.

James Watriss

>At 6 degrees, I think I'd keep mine put away and not work on it at all.

Re: Help with troubleshooting wooden coffin smoother

#14

Ahh James, your a wise man...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>