Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

how to taper a blind hole

Posts

how to taper a blind hole

#1

how to taper a blind hole

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The local club had a stool making class this weekend (short stool with 3 legs and no stretchers, looks like a milking stool). It was useful in that I learned to properly turn and hollow a large disk (seat). However, the stool design is flawed in my opinion in that the leg tenons are not tapered. I think the legs will get loose with time and fall out. The seat holes are 3/4" blind holes a bit over 1" deep. I didn't finish the leg tenons in the hope that I could find a way to taper the holes in the seat and then I could taper the tenon. Any ideas?

Re: how to taper a blind hole

#2

Re: how to taper a blind hole *LINK*

MikeW

>You could either make blades or start with the replacement blades for LV's Pro Taper Reamer and make the stock to fit the depth of the hole and degree of taper.

Take care, Mike


LV Linky

Re: how to taper a blind hole

#3

Re: how to taper a blind hole

Bill Lowrance

>Bill, Not replying to your question, but suggesting a solution to what I think is your problem. How about just sawing slits in the ends of the tenons, inserting carefully judged hardwood wedges, and then just pounding the tenons in tight against the wedging? (Or maybe the seat it too thin to take this...)

Re: how to taper a blind hole

#4

Which way do you want to taper the hole?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>The first two responses to your post have assumed opposite tapers. Are you trying to taper the hole so the leg tenon is tapered like a pencil, or like a dovetail router bit?

Re: how to taper a blind hole

#5

Re: how to taper a blind hole

Greg B�tit, Vergennes VT

>I'm not sure why you wouldn't want to do a proper through tenon, tapered & wedged from the top like a Windsor chair. A blind hole can be tapered just like a through one, it just would require a little more attention to the start and stop diameters of the taper on the top of the leg.

If I were doing a blind hole I would just fox wedge it. But maybe I'm missing something in your description of what you're trying to accomplish.

greg

Re: how to taper a blind hole

#6

Re: how to taper a blind hole *LINK*

Greg B�tit, Vergennes VT

>I forgot to mention that for a blind tapered hole you'd need to make a custom reamer that would have a minimum diameter that would match the diameter of your drill. They're easy to make.


Making John Alexander's Reamer

Re: how to taper a blind hole

#7

Sounds Painful...

James Watriss

>Just kidding.

One suggestion, if you feel like trying something other than a taper, is to shrink the wood before cutting the tenon, using a heat lamp (a technique Nakashima used to use) or an insulated hot box. (Brian Boggs)

Basic idea... shrink the tenon first by getting it completely bone-dry. Then glue it in place. Tenon will expand in the hole, and create a pretty solid mechanical joint that isn't very likely to fail.

Or... make a mortise reamer out of a tapered dowel and a length of old planer knife (or something else that will hold an edge for long enough to ream out the hole.

Or... get an old spade bit and grind a taper into it, and grind new points. For three holes, I don't think it really needs to be pretty, just enough to dig the sides of the holes out.

Failing THAT, I don't think, for just one stool, that you really need dedicated reaming equipment. If it was just me, and it was just one stool, I'd probably do the reaming with a cabinet rasp and smooth it out with a file and/or sandpaper. You won't get a consistent taper on all three holes, but it should be good enough to get the job done for you.

I like the idea of having a tapered tenon, but to be honest, I think that they work better with a through hole. If the tapered tenon shrinks in a through hole, it just goes farther through. If it's not a through hole, the tenon will simply bottom out in the hole, and then it'll still be loose, unless you're wily enough to accurately calculate shrinkage and how it will affect the tenon so that you can accurately size the tenon that it will shrink just enough that it doesn't bottom out. So, if it's really an un-holy seat you're looking for, I think I'd go with either the incredible shrinking tenon trick, or a through hole, with shouldered tenons, and wedged on top, in a mildly tapered hole cut for that purpose.

Re: how to taper a blind hole

#8

I think

roninkokokomo

>I think there are reamers designed for just this purpose??

I think they are currently being made as well as some old ones available.

Does the hole have to be blind?? Adding a wedge to the split tenon would certainly strengthen the joint. I know, it can be done blind, but it is easier if it doesn't have toi be.

Ron

Re: how to taper a blind hole

#9

Re: how to taper a blind hole

ThomD

>I wouldn't necessarily assume there is no way for the non-tapered holes to work. The whole ladder back chair thing depends on non tapered blind holes.

If you want to make your own reamer, the one that John Alexander promotes is actually more effective in certain regards than the all metal high tech ones. I built one with nothing more than spoke shaves and a drawknife when I was away from my lathes. If you have a lathe it is a few minutes work. Like most reamers it is designed to pass through a through-hole, but I don't see any reason why it couldn't be engineered short. The only problem I had when making mine was that all the available blades had been converted to Japanese style blades, even at the Big Box stores, but they may work also, and finding the western type key-hole saw is not impossible. Check Alexander's woodworking site. This is the kind of tool you could have working by later tonight.

Another option would be to find an appropriate short tapered chucking reamer. There are lots of options particularly if you were able to bob off the end of a longer one. A keystone reamer looks like it might work, ebay often has "used" reamer, the provenance of which is open to question, I have always worried. My only concern with this approach is that you need enough depth in the seat to house your tapered part and room for it to move up in, and a solid top over it. That is a lot of stuff happening in the normal seat thickness, which is why so many ar designed for full penetratio, which may be a more workmanlike option. I would probably turn the underside with a raised ring to give extra meat, then remove the excess in a sculptural way.

You often prefer a high tech solution, Bill. One that works extremely well with tenons, goes like this.

- You drill your blind holes to a max diameter that will be the same size as a shoulder cut on your leg, using a forstner bit. You drill to near max dept, but you do the last 1/4" at a smaller tenon depth, by 1/8 to 1/4" in diameter, smaller diameter is better so long as the tenon doesn't get fragile. This can be thinner than one imagines because the shoulder is doing a lot of work in the final joint.

- You use a second Forstner bit for the smaller diameter to full depth, and it's point will center in the point hole of the other drill. You turn your tenon so that the shoulder is a precise fit for the larger diameter, and you give that a little bearing, then your reduce the rest of the tenon to the minor diameter.

- What you end up with is parts that perfectly index on the shoulder and tenon parts, can have a tight fit without splitting, but leave a precise cylinder or space around the tenon for most of it's penetration. Or you could look at it as a tapered design, except you only controlled for the end and the shoulder of the tenon.

- You mask the exposed surfaces and glue up with boatbuilding epoxy, flooding the hole. Done right it is super strong, very clean looking, and as impervious to racking or moisture issues as any joint imaginable.

Re: how to taper a blind hole

#10

Re: Another take on the stepped drilling approach

Dave Mount

>I while back I built a couple wooden rabbet planes with the conical escapement, and did not own a reamer that would cut the appropriate shape. I made the escapement by drilling a series of holes with graduated sizes of Forstner bits, with the depths and diameters selected to define the profile I wanted. I then used gouges to smooth the steps between the sizes. This is pretty much what Thom describes, except rather than leaving the steps in the mortise and stepping the tenon, you just smooth out the steps.

In the case of the plane, the taper is "leaning" with one side straight down and the opposite side at an extreme angle; to accomplish this I drilled keeping a single tangent point for all holes (rather than the same center point). For the stool application, all the holes can have the same centerpoint. Using gouges to finish shaping the sides allows you to work a blind hole, if that's what your design calls for. In cannel gouges are a little easier to maintain the line with, but out cannel would be OK. . .even a narrow chisel would probably suffice. Since all you're doing is shaving off the steps, it's not hard to keep things round, you just shave the steps until they disappear.

Best,

Dave

Re: how to taper a blind hole

#11

Re: square peg in a square hole

ThomD

>Gee, everyone came up with the same answer pretty quick.

I personally wouldn't fox wedge it, only because it would be pretty tough cutting a reverse blind taper, and predicting the exact shape etc... Unlike the square tenon option the expansion of the round one is going to be a pretty weird shape.

I agree the tapered tenon is harder to do in a blind hole. The way the taper was explained/demoed to me was that it will never loosen if the leg isn't twisted. Take the tapered leg, push and twist it in, then try to pull it out without twisting. Very tough to do. The wedge's main function is to lock the tapered tenon against rotation by being driven through the walls of the tapered hole. That is a tough trick to pull off with a fox wedge.

Another option for the caring hand tool guy is square mortice and tenons. Better glue bond, no twisting, easy to cut, undercut, taper, whatever. All around better joint. Only problem is slightly higher difficulty in the making (if you like a challenge, call that a plus). The round tenon guys go to so much trouble, and use so much expensive tooling these days (Alexander reamer aside), that it would hardly be any worse to just do it right.

Re: how to taper a blind hole

#12

Re: Another take on the stepped drilling approach

ThomD

>"This is pretty much what Thom describes, except rather than leaving the steps in the mortise and stepping the tenon, you just smooth out the steps."

Actually that isn't what I am describing, though I can well understand where you would get that idea.

What I am describing is sticking a 3/4" tenon in a 1" parallel sided hole, and filling in the difference with epoxy. Only problems with that approach is it would look very sloppy, and provide no control surfaces for decent alignment of the parts. So to solve those problems, I have some 3/4" hole in the bottom of the mortise to align the tip of the tenon, and I leave the 1" shoulder long enough to engage the 1" top of the hole. There is a whole lot of 3/4" tenon in 1" hole between the ends, and everything gets filled up with epoxy. Pretty much the strongest joint of the kind in woodworking... If you call that woodworking.

I don't have a picture of the parts, only the end result.


img

Re: how to taper a blind hole

#13

Re: how to taper a blind hole

john lucas

>Bill I think a blind hole is wrong anyway. If the tenon ever shrinks it will wobble, tapered or straight. The advantage of a tapered hole is if the tapered tenon shrinks is just seats further in the hole and stays solid. Now if you were to make a blind hole deeper than the tapered tenon you might have the best of both worlds.

Re: how to taper a blind hole

#14

Re: Which way do you want to taper the hole?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The tenon will taper like a pencil end. I don't know any other way to arrange a taper in a blind hole.

Re: how to taper a blind hole

#15

There is

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Don't know if it's used anymore but there's a such a thing as a fox-wedge tenon. Using a special bit the hole is reamed from the inside (like a dovetail), the tenon is kerfed and a wedge is inserted partly. Driving the leg in the hole tighten things up.

Never done it or even seen it done, but I would assume this is a fussy joint to make, which probably explains why it is not common.

DC

Re: how to taper a blind hole

#16

Also very hard to repair

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>In order to repair a fox-wedged tenon, you'd have to destroy something - the spindle, the seat.

Re: how to taper a blind hole

#17

Re: square peg in a square hole

Greg B�tit, Crown Point, NY.

>A fox wedge doesn't require the taper feature mentioned here and above. You use a very short, and relatively thin wedge, and the top of the leg gets mashed into the sides of the hole. Fibers get compressed, and it makes a very tight joint.

greg -who prefers a through tenon, tapered and wedged from the top.

Re: how to taper a blind hole

#18

Re: square peg in a square hole

ThomD

>I does under ideal cicumstances, but under ideal circumstances the regular joint is tight also. I suppose you are right about the captured wedge, though I would regard that a bit like cutting dovetails without any taper, where is the upside without the taper. I'm not sure there is upside even with the taper, unless the seat is thicker than I would want it to be so I guess we are on the same page on through tenons.

Re: how to taper a blind hole

#19

thanks to all

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Some of you missed the fact that the holes were drilled and blind, thereby precluding some of the suggested fixes. When one is in a class it is best to go with the flow and not raise issues that complicate the task of the teacher. That said, I could see that this stool was going to fail in use and I wanted to try to rescue it after the fact.

The holes in the seat are plenty deep and I left the unfitted tenons plenty large. The description of the home made reamer was just what is needed. I will ream the holes to some arbitrary taper and fit the leg tenons so they stop short of bottoming out in the seat hole. I will do the drying of the tenons as was suggested.

Re: how to taper a blind hole

#20

Re: thanks to all

ThomD

>No harm in drying the tenons, though i'm not sure it will help that much since it is really a technique for parallel sided joints. John Alexander has a technique where he puts flats on the side of the tenons, and dries them, then puts them in a hole. The end result is that they expand so violently that without the flats there might have been trouble. So it would be possible to get too much expansion with this method. Everything has to be just right with the Alexander method, the final shaping of the tenons has to be done by hand with lots of trial fittings etc...

While the method is an amazing acheivement, it does make one wonder if it was really done this way in the old days. Rediscovery of old methods being one of his interests. Of course there is a gentler option where one is really just insuring that at the very least the tenons aren't wetter than the mortises...

With the tapers they set under the weight of the user which is fine so long as the seat is up to it. Of course the tenons need to be dry, but nothing too crazy.

Re: how to taper a blind hole

#21

I think I'll skip overdrying the tenons

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>good points

Re: how to taper a blind hole

#22

Re: thanks to all

MikeW

>Hi Bill,

And one more thought you probably thought of...

Make sure the tenon seats well before bottoming out. I tried for about 1/8" or a skosh over when I had to repair some chairs that were made with tapered mortises/leg tenons.

Take care, Mike