Re: Workbench: Step 1
ThomD
>Benches are pretty simple, essentially a slab of wood on two horses, with a few things tacked on. These are my list of things to be on the lookout for:
- Fit of parts together.
It is so easy to do something like build the dog holes only to find there is a great big hole going to be wherever you place the vice because when you set the ideal spacing it is subsequently inevitable that it fouls your vice
Of you make the base first, and it turns out the top when made actually ends up a little narrow, because you had to remove more material than you thought you did to get the parts squared up for glue-up, etc...
The major rule here is to build it backwards. Start with the vises first, then the top, build the base last. This is a classic project issue. People want to spread out the cost and buy the expensive parts last, when success seems clear. So they build a motorcycle frame and when that turns out they then go out and buy the motor... Oops! Of course one can start with a plan, source only identical parts and build to spec, but that isn't always necessary or smart any more than it is to cut all parts of your cabinet to perfect specs and bring them together, the normal approach being to fit parts together.
- Height of Bench. There really is no way of winning here. There are certainly some rules of thumb, but you both have to feel your way to your own body, and fit to your own work. In that regard if you look at the Landis book, which is still the best ATMO, It was written at a certain point when stuff like routers were a bigger part of the average small shop, and the hand tool environment had a different character than now. For instance the average plane was probably a little lower. An adjustable height bench makes sense really, and I probably wouldn't build another bench without it. I have this hydraulic lifting cart I use for moving machinery and just having it in the shop has totally convinced me, even though I love a trestle base.
- Fit of bench to work environment. This is also a toughie, again hard for a beginner (which is what all amateurs like us are) to get this right. We are a mobile society so we probably change shop spaces a few times, buy different tools, and learn different techniques, but one should put a lot of though into how one works, the kind of work one does, the shop size and layout.