Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Scrapers from Scrap steel?

Posts

Scrapers from Scrap steel?

#1

Dominic in Bucks County PA

Scrapers from Scrap steel?

Dominic in Bucks County PA

>Hi gang,

I posted this on another site and wanted to get some feedback from teh resident machints and tool makers who frequent QC.



I recently accepted an Engineering position at a mfg company that uses rolls and rolls of steel to make their product. They use 1095 Blue polished steel (Rockwell C48-52 hardness), 1095 Brite (polished) with the same specs as prev. mentioned, and 301 Hi Yields SS (Rockwell C48-52 hardness). All the steel mentioned come in thicknesses from 0.010" all the way up to 0.0625".

I took a look through the scrap bin and was amazed at the amount of usable (to me) steel that was heading out to the recycler. With their permission, I took a couple pieces home. One was a 0.025" thick piece of 1095 Blue polished. The other a piece of 0.010" thk 301SS Hi Yield. Little fact-oid here: The 301 SS Hi Yield the only SS I've come across that is magnetic! The cold forming process used to obtain the thickness we want aligns the molecules and enables this. Cool eh?

Anyway, I cut the pieces to size and polished them up. After that I sharpened as I would with any scraper. The 1095 Blue Polished stuff was a PITA to raise a burr on. But eventually I got it to work. But it was like trying to raise a burr on my No12's Hock Scraper Blade. The 0.010" thk 301 Hi Yield was a joy to use and was giving me BEAUTIFUL shavings in short order. Plus I liked that fact that it was SS and wouldn't rust.

The burnisher I used should have been sufficient. It's a Hock Burnisher. From the TFWW web site it reports, "This 3/8 of an inch by 6 inch burnisher is hardened to RC 64 and polished to a mirror finish". So this is not just a screwdriver that I'm using to burnish!

I should mention that all the scrap pieces have a No1 rounded edge on them. This means that the edges have been ground to a radius. I had to file that away before I was able to use them as a scraper. Rather than file all that, I LIGHTLY touched the edges up at my disc sander. After that they were filed flat.

I looked at LV's website and noticed that the Bahco (formerly Sandvik) scrapers are listed as Rc48-52. Now, I was wondering WHY I was having such a hard time with filing, and stoning the edge on that hunk of 0.025" thk 1095 Blue Polished Steel. The hardness is right in line with the published hardness of the Bahco Scrapers. Could it have been the bluing? One thing, the term "Blue Polished [b]is[/b] referring to a corrision resistant finish (bluing) that has been applied. I know this since I can somewhat easily scratch it off.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Scrapers from Scrap steel?

#2

Re: Scrapers from Scrap steel?

Ted

>I'm not sure why you are having such a hard time with the 1095 steel. This should just be spring-tempered steel, of the same sort used in scrapers and saw blades. I've used this same steel to reblade some old pitted backsaws and for small special-purpose scrapers. Has the edge that you are using to turn a burr been work hardened by chance?

I think it is great that you have found this supply of scrap steel and just wish that I had the same access.

Re: Scrapers from Scrap steel?

#3

Re: Scrapers from Scrap steel?

ThomD

>You could just be a few points either side of cold forming.

One issue could be your grinding. It is unlikely, but you could have hardened the steel. More likely grinding will soften it, and you can use that to your advantage. If you have a belt sander which is somewhat safer to grind on than a disc, and more predictable since all the grit is moving past the edge at the same speed, you could try some very hard grinding that blues the edge (clean off existing blue first. You can try that. If that doesn't work you can try grinding and then stuffing it into some vermiculite or ash, to slow cooling. Or you could use a torch to draw the temper. Since this stock is free to you, you can fool around with it at your leasure until you get the results you want.

All this is based on the idea of the hardness being the source of the problem. A good test for hardness is filing. Get a fresh file and try filing your commercial scraper, and the ones you are making out of 1095. If you experience that the file skates more on the 1095, cuts slowly, then hardness is the likely problem.

Re: Scrapers from Scrap steel?

#4

Re: Scrapers from Scrap steel?

Dean J in MN

>I'll second (or third) what others have said regarding 1095: It makes great scrapers, and I don't find the burr difficult to raise. Try the file as mentioned, it should file fine. Perhaps feel a little harder than the run-of-the-mill scrapers, but a file cuts 1095.

The best scrapers I have are drops of 1095 from a saw project.

-Dean

Re: Scrapers from Scrap steel?

#5

Re: Scrapers from Scrap steel?

Dean J in MN

>...and if you want to remove that blueing -- drop the scraper into a tub of vinegar. Presto -- gone.

Re: Scrapers from Scrap steel?

#6

Re: Scrapers from Scrap steel?

wilbur

>I have nothing useful to add, but couldn't resist this:

"I posted this on another site and wanted to get some feedback from teh resident machints and tool makers who frequent QC."

Bringing your work home with you now, Dominic? :@)

Re: Scrapers from Scrap steel?

#7

Dominic in Bucks County PA

Hi Qilbur

Dominic in Bucks County PA

>Wilbur,

That's what I get for being to quick to press the "SUBMIT" button!!

And my fat fingers have a problem with hitting the right letter. Sometimes they hit the letter NEXT to the one I want!

Re: Scrapers from Scrap steel?

#8

Re: Scrapers from Scrap steel?

Alan DuBoff

>Dominick,

1095 spring steel is tempered also, similar to the Bahco scrapers your comparing to.

It will stay tempered while filing and cutting, sans being annealed.

Regards,

Alan

Re: Scrapers from Scrap steel?

#9

Re: Scrapers from Scrap steel?

jimbo58

>It may be the hardness of the scrap you were having difficult with is why it was in the scrap bin.

Re: Scrapers from Scrap steel?

#10

Don't think so.....

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>You wrote:

"It may be the hardness of the scrap you were having difficult with is why it was in the scrap bin. "

Then I guess the other 400 lbs of steel that was also there must have also been bad!

The scraps are part that is cut from the roll each time it is loaded into the forming machine. With this piece [b]I[/b] was the operator and know for a fact that the rest of the roll was as hard. That stuff was so hard I had to use power shears to cut it, THEN follow up with sharp sheet metal shears to clean up the cut.

Re: Scrapers from Scrap steel?

#11

Re: Don't think so.....

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Dom,

Was your scrap cut from the roll before or after the forming/rolling operation? Certain kinds of cold forming or cold rolling will work-harden the feed stock. Depends on the amount of compression. But then, maybe your scraps were cut before the forming operation. You can get an idea of the actual hardness by seeing what your scrapers will scratch, and what will scratch them. Try an ~Rc60 blade and see what happens--what scratches what?

Wiley

Re: Scrapers from Scrap steel?

#12

You ain't lying Dom...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Qilbur... LOL!