Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

What is the best smelling wood you have worked?

Posts

Re: What is the best smelling wood you have worked?

#26

Re: What is the best smelling wood you have worked

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Hmmmm,

I love turning Amboyna..... the scent is amazing to me, for hand work I love the chardonay of white oak......

Take care,

Jim

Re: What is the best smelling wood you have worked?

#27

Re: Boxwood

C.R. Miller

>Actually, now you mention it boxwood does smell a bit like vanilla wafers...

Re: What is the best smelling wood you have worked?

#28

Re: What is the best smelling wood you have worked

C.R. Miller

>I second the Brazilian rosewood -- along with lignum vitae.

Re: What is the best smelling wood you have worked?

#29

What an incredibly diverse set of responses!

Alan DuBoff

>Wow, this has really got to be one of the most diverse set an answers that everyone tossed in...

Made me wonder what would happen if I get a piece of Olive now that doesn't smell very good. Let's say the next piece has a horrible smell to it??? :-/

I thought of this as I have some walnut in my garage I traded some maple from. This walnut was air dried, and has a gorgeous look to it, but had a most unusual odor to it while working it. Normally walnut is one of my favorite to work, it is one of the most forgiving woods, IMO. For that matter, I often put walnut, maple, and cherry at the top of my workability list, the way they work, shave, cut, etc...I have always liked those.

There are a few different woods that I will need to try now. Imbuya being one since it gets both Mike and Konrad's recommendation, Boxwood sound interesting also, would like to try that, and Camphor Laurel, that box that Derek posted smells beautiful from here! Snakewood, Dogwood, and Sassafras will also need to be tried...

So many different woods, so little time...*sigh*

Regards,

Alan

Re: What is the best smelling wood you have worked?

#30

Re: Camphor Laurel .. especially ..

Alan DuBoff

>Derek,

I had to reply to your post separately, this box smells beautiful all the way from over here! *g*

In fact, I would go out on a limb (a wood pun for 'ya there;-) and say that this box stinks like beauty, in a good way, doncha know! :-)

I do love the smell of Eucalyptus, and would have one at my house if they weren't so darn messy...they shed an incredible amount of leaves...and little acorn type things...Russian style steam baths use Eucalyptus in them for a cleansing technique called a Plaitza, which wraps the leaves in a broom. In America that was popular at one time, when you could find a place to Shvitz. There is only a couple places left now, the old Jewish steam baths are just about gone...they often use oak leaves also (10th Street Baths in NY), but in L.A. where I'm from there's a Shvitz that uses Eucalyptus (now called City Spa, was Pico-Burnside Baths when I grew up). Great stuff...Oak and Eucalyptus are the 2 main leaves used for a plaitza broom, AFAIK. This is a tradition from Russia that was brought to America years ago...

Regards,

Alan

Re: What is the best smelling wood you have worked?

#31

Emotion and scent

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Dominic commented on the pleasure of working pine partly because it reminds him of working with his dad - I have the same feeling about Douglas fir, both because of my dad (a 20-year house remodel, bracketing my growing up years) and my grand-dad (loved being in his shop). Some woods have an emotional value triggered by the scent.

Re: What is the best smelling wood you have worked?

#32

Walnut

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>but my experience is clearly way more limited than many of those who have posted.

Re: What is the best smelling wood you have worked?

#33

Re: Emotion and scent

Alan DuBoff

>Bill wrote:

"Some woods have an emotional value triggered by the scent."

Bill,

That's a good thing! Always good to remember you Dad! :-)

Regards,

Alan (didn't get to work much wood with his Dad)

Re: What is the best smelling wood you have worked?

#34

Wandering OT - radio sportscasts

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>My dad didn't watch/listen to sports much until I was in high school, though he was then a charter Oakland Raiders fan - he watched them when they were playing on a high school or community college field, with a high school band at halftime. Partly because I lacked that family influence, and partly because my interests lay elsewhere, I heard radio sportscasts only when we went to the hardware store on the weekend, and on the rare occasions when a teacher would cheat during the World Series and put a pivotal game on during English, math, or whatever class (thrilling most of the boys, and boring most of the girls).

It is my opinion that, regardless of who the sportscaster is, there is something about the two major American sports, football and baseball, that creates a distinctive rhythm and syntax to the sportscasting. I can instantly tell whether a radio game is one or the other, just by that difference. Every time I hear a baseball sportscast, it takes me back to Foothill Hardware (still in business in Oakland, CA, parts of it not much changed) on the weekend, following my father around as we sought out some part for a project.

All kinds of other memories, like Ben Gay commercials, then come welling up.

I still think of things I'd like to tell him, four and a half years after his death.

Re: What is the best smelling wood you have worked?

#35

even more OT, I still think of things I'd like to

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>tell my dad 37 years after his death. Like "thanks."

Bruce

Re: What is the best smelling wood you have worked?

#36

Re: What is the best smelling wood you have worked

Robby Wright

>Birch. It reminds me of the smell of tinker toys at my Grandmother's house when I was a kid.

Robby Wright

San Marcos, CA

Re: What is the best smelling wood you have worked?

#37

Japanese Lilac (Syringa Reticulata) *LINK*

Bob Demers

>True, its mostly an ornemental bush, and rarely much of tree size around here, but I had score of 8 in piece from one that grew tree size in the Annapolis Valley NS.

I never had such strong smelling wood to work with before, it was amazing, every fresh cut, released a Lilac perfume smell.

I was using it for carving projects, but incidently, it doesnt glue well, and does not finish well either. That strong fragrence comes from its natural oil which interfere with both.

Nonetheless, a very strong fragrence wood, makes your shop smell perfumy :-)

Bob


Japanese Lilac

Re: What is the best smelling wood you have worked?

#38

Re: Still just walnut for me...

Bob Demers

>Walnut is slightly toxic to some (have reaction to).

A ww friend of mine at work always develop a pimple on the middle of his chin when he works walnut.

Everytime he shows up at work on monday with a plaster on his chin, we know he was working walnut in the WW :-)

Bob

Re: What is the best smelling wood you have worked?

#39

Different strokes for differnt folks

Bill Leffingwell Richwood wv

>My favorite is sassafras.I can understand your point it is somewhat over powering.I was planing an old piece of barn wood last week,all I knew was it was a light wood.With in 1 foot into the planer the fragrance(stink??)told the story.I don't use exotics but as for strength of odor it comes out on top.Eastern red cedar is up there too.

Bill

Re: What is the best smelling wood you have worked?

#40

cut some yesterday...

John in NM

>and I have to say its always been a favorite too.

I'm even starting to like the smell of mesquite again, after years of working for a mesquite oriented shop I couldn't stand it! Now its a bit nostalgic.

Re: What is the best smelling wood you have worked?

#41

What is the unusual scent?

John in NM

>I've had 1 piece of walnut and more mesquite than I can remember that had a certain manure-ish overtone to the smell. Javelina like to bed down in dense mesquite stands, I guess the walnut was a tree from a farm (it was not lumber yard wood).

Re: What is the best smelling wood you have worked?

#42

Re: Wandering OT - radio sportscasts

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>The family that runs Foothill also runs a great hardware store in Pleasant Hill, about 4 blocks from my house. And, though it is only less than 10 years old, it has the character than runs back to when Grandpa started the old one.

For me, it was Fred Kelleway's hardware store in Walnut Creek with Dad, since the mid 50's. Some of my tools still have Fred's price stickers on the boxes and packages, although not so many any longer.

If things go right, I'll see my dad today for a while. He's 83 in May. Thanks for the reminders.

Re: What is the best smelling wood you have worked?

#43

Re: What is the unusual scent?

Alan DuBoff

>John,

Yes! that is exactly the description of this walnut, not sure why...

I was thinking that maybe it had something to do with how the tree fell down, I believe someone must have had it fall down and milled it into slabs. The only thing I could think of is that maybe the tree itself was diseased or something...but the wood itself looks wonderful when it's cleaned up...

When I traded the maple for it, the guy mentioned the odor with it also...and I have had other wood like that as well...so this is certainly not the only...and as you point out you have had walnut like that also...

If anyone knows why wood would have an odor like that, I would like to know.

I hope my next piece of Olive doesn't spoil me being smitten by it!:-)

Re: What is the best smelling wood you have worked?

#44

Show off...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Still nice.

Re: What is the best smelling wood you have worked?

#45

Re: Camphor Laurel .. especially ..

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Derek,

Thanks for posting. A warm and handsome little box, and I like the smell.

We have one of those trees in our backyard, matter of fact I have broken branches to pick up every year. They just fall from the weight of water and loads of berries. We've had a few flocks of cedar waxwings come through in the past couple of weeks, and devour a whole bunch of camphor berries.

Very nice box!

Wiley

Re: What is the best smelling wood you have worked?

#46

Well in order...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Walnut

Mesquite

Cherry

Koa

Sorry, I don't have a lot of experience in jungle wood.

Re: What is the best smelling wood you have worked?

#47

I'd be willing to bet...

John in NM

>That the reason is exactly what it smells like (at the risk of starting another scatalogical discussion). Your walnut was probably a shade tree for a cow.

The odor of the mesquite was so strong that it was un-mistakable, but of course pigs and javelina are like that.

Re: What is the best smelling wood you have worked?

#48

Re: Sassafras

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Scott,

Does it smell like Root Beer? I think that's where they get extract for root beer?

Marv

Re: What is the best smelling wood you have worked?

#49

Re: Red Cedar

Paul M.

>Agreed on Red Cedar.

I'm making a guitar and the front is Red Cedar. It smells so nice.

The kerfed lining that is used to glue the front to the sides is also Red Cedar. I steamed it in my kitchen over the tea kettle to make it more pliable so it could bend to the shape of the sides. The kitchen smelled so wonderful from the smell of steamed cedar.