Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Frame and panel + dovetails?

Posts

Frame and panel + dovetails?

#1

Frame and panel + dovetails?

wilbur

>I know that we all know that frame and panel construction is a good way to deal with wood movement for a door, or the side of a large piece of casework or furniture, and that dovetail joints are an excellent way of joining two boards at right angles.

So why are they never used together? I will say that imagining such a piece looks butt-ugly in my mind, but I was wondering if there was a more technical reason not to do this.

Re: Frame and panel + dovetails?

#2

Re: Frame and panel + dovetails?

MikeW

>Hi Wilbur.

Other than certain aesthetics (you already mentioned), I would simply say that together they would be an unnecessary construction complication that yielded little/no benefit.

Take care, Mike

Re: Frame and panel + dovetails?

#3

Re: Frame and panel + dovetails?

Christopher Schwarz

>Wilbur,

I believe George Ellis shows such an animal in Modern Practical Joinery. I don't have my copy with me today. Someone might be able to look it up. If I remember it right, the rails attach to the stiles using a sliding dovetail.

It looks like a dovetailed haunch.

Or maybe someone slipped something into my coffee this a.m.

Chris

Re: Frame and panel + dovetails?

#4

Re: Frame and panel + dovetails?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Wilbur,

I presume you mean rail and style panel construction and that would be a bad choice for a dovetail joint. The reason is that the dovetail tail tenon would be on the end of each rail and the pin would be on each end of the style and too near the end for strength.

The dovetail that Chris describes is fairly common, has a different joint geometry and is never seen.

We today are much more impressed with joints like dovetails, in the past the furniture was what was important not the joinery.

Stephen

Re: Frame and panel + dovetails?

#5

Re: Frame and panel + dovetails?

wilbur

>Duh! *slaps head*

I was thinking about the situation where you are joining two frame and panels at right angles and whether to use dovetails. Of course, that's going to be a long grain to long grain joint, where you wouldn't need dovetails. And also of course, joining two boards with dovetails is an end grain to end grain situation. Not entirely, but you get my drift.

Re: Frame and panel + dovetails?

#6

Re: Frame and panel + dovetails?

ThomD

>What I have done is have the stiles joined by dovetails, you can let one end project and then join them to a panel where they don't project, with a gap, or you can mitre the long grain. This is kinda a varient on a mitered dovetail.

Another option is to have a panel where the top like a table has the short stile across the end like a breadboard joint, and the engrain of the longer frame piece butts/joins into it. Then the leg or cabinet side below, can dovetail into that piece. This provides an overhang to the top which is pleasing. It is a tough joint to do because the receiving sockets are entirely encased, like mortises. A realy good fretsaw makes quick work of the roughing. A simpler way of doing it which is very strong but sorta cheating is to biscuit the breadboard on. I prefer a dovetail slip joint.

Re: Frame and panel + dovetails?

#7

Re: Frame and panel + dovetails? *LINK*

StephenFS

>There is an illustration of using dovetail joints to join framed panels in Fritz Spannagel's classic German book on cabinetmaking (it's on page 98 of the Sch�fer reprint). Google books has a preview, hopefully the link works properly. He shows a wardrobe with frame-and-panel sides constructed with a frame-and-panel top.


Der M�belbau

Re: Frame and panel + dovetails?

#8

because the M&T is a superior joint

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>That said, some modern woodworker is going to do it just to be different, something that seems to be of prime importance in the studio furniture arena.

Re: Frame and panel + dovetails?

#9

Re: because the M&T is a superior joint

ThomD

>I thought the OP's question was clear, I took it to be about joining adjascent panels. If it is the joints between the stiles and the rails, and you are probably right, that would be a problem except with a dovetailled slip joint, or a frame where the stiles and rails are set at 90 degrees to their usual arrangement.

Re: Frame and panel + dovetails?

#10

Re: Frame and panel + dovetails?

ThomD

>That is one of the options I was refering to, breadboard ends, though I had never seen it done before, nothign new under the sun.

Re: Frame and panel + dovetails?

#11

Re: because the M&T is a superior joint

ThomD

>I should have given examples:

Dovetail slip joints as in the FWW Curtis Erpelding video he did on radial arm saw joinery.

The other joint is comon on the top of any chest like a cigar box or a blanket box. The sides are dovetailed together and the panels is set into a groove in them.

Basically the geometry of the two parts is similar, it is just a mater of the proportions of the elements. Whether the main axis of the frame is co-planer with, or perp to, the panel.

Re: Frame and panel + dovetails?

#12

Re: Frame and panel + dovetails?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>More to the point, dovetails will easily split out the face grain. You only make dovetails in end grain.

Re: Frame and panel + dovetails?

#13

Re: Frame and panel + dovetails?

Thomas S Stockton

>If your talking about something like a frame and panel door were the dovetail is a visable design element another problem comes up. The problem is that if you want the panel housed in a groove there is no easy way to assemble the joint. The work around is to use a rabbet and have some molding hold in the panel.But I think the main reason is that mortise and tenons are fairly fast and time proven way to do the joint

Tom