Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Stanley 151 spokeshave blade made by LV *LINK*

Posts

Stanley 151 spokeshave blade made by LV *LINK*

#1

JL

Stanley 151 spokeshave blade made by LV *LINK*

JL

>I was given a Lee Valley A2 spokeshave blade for Xmas. Trouble is, it is designed to fit the Stanley #151 - and I have a set of the Lee Valley spokeshaves.

I do happen to have an old #151 that I picked up for $1.00 at a yard sale. The blade is just a bit thick for the mouth of the #151. The mouth opening is on the order of 3/16" and the blade is a fat 3/32". As it is sitting at a diagonal, it pretty much fills the entire mouth.

The spokeshave in question is NOT a collectible. The japaning is pretty much worn and gone over 30% of the surface (handles mostly). The existing old blade is serviceable, but worn.

Should I:

A) File the mouth open just a bit to allow for chip clearance.

B) Work on the bed just a bit to let the blade down.

C) Send the blade back to Lee Valley and get an A2 blade for my LV spokeshaves.

Thanks in advance.


Blade in question

Re: Stanley 151 spokeshave blade made by LV *LINK*

#2

Re: Stanley 151 spokeshave blade made by LV

Rob Lee

>Hi JL -

I vote A or C.... wouldn't do B!

Cheers -

Rob

(there's no problem swapping blades)

Re: Stanley 151 spokeshave blade made by LV *LINK*

#3

Re: One vote A

Dave Mount

>You definitely don't want to try to lower the bed -- not only would it be a lot of metal to remove, but it would be difficult to keep it flat.

Between A and C, it depends on what you want -- I would opt for A. I have the LV shaves as well as a couple 151s and some other vintage shaves. I tend to use the vintage shaves when working green material, and use the LV shaves on dry stock. The reason is that the LV shaves have a nice tight mouth, but as such they are not well suited for hogging off stock like you often are with green wood. For heavy cuts, I use vintage shaves which generally already have gaping mouths. Only down side of a vintage shave is that the irons are thin and they sometimes chatter. Enter your LV iron, which should make a 151 much less chatter prone.

If having an A2 iron for your LV shave trips your trigger, then go for it. For me, I don't see the point.

Best,

Dave

Re: Stanley 151 spokeshave blade made by LV *LINK*

#4

Re: Stanley 151 spokeshave blade made by LV

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I'm working on my first Windsor chair. Previously, I worked with dry wood. This is white ash that was a tree in late October.

My three LV shaves are great on dry wood, but clog badly on this dampish stock. So I built a couple with Hock blades that I could open up to take almost drawknife sized bites.

What I'm saying is that you'll want MORE shaves, not fewer, and a #151 that has a more open mouth is certainly not a bad thing. And it's cheaper even than a kit from a number of vendors, including LV.

Re: Stanley 151 spokeshave blade made by LV *LINK*

#5

I got a couple of those irons when they came out

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>and had to file the mouth of the two shaves I put them in - interestingly, more in the center than at the edges. I don't know if the casting warped or if it gets slowly bashed backwards.

Took me maybe ten minutes of filing and trying. I was aiming for a tight mouth, and got it - it might have taken a little longer for a more open mouth.

I concur: don't file the bed, unless you need to do so to make it flat, in which case, do that first, then file away at the mouth to enlarge it. My uncle taught me, years ago, when given a choice, always to take the approach that removes the least metal.

As to returning the iron vs. modifying your Stanley - you, and you alone, can make that choice.

Re: Stanley 151 spokeshave blade made by LV *LINK*

#6

JL

A it is, far be it from me to argue with..

JL

>the boss of Lee Valley and ya'lls collected wisdom.

I've never really had much trouble using the Lee Valley shaves (primarily concave and the round) on green wood though. Now I'll agree you can't use a chair devil on green wood.


img

Re: Stanley 151 spokeshave blade made by LV *LINK*

#7

Nice shavings!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Personally I'm wondering why it took you to the end of February to start playing with the blade. I can see why now... You've been busy!