Clifton 2 piece chipbreaker for Stanley planes?
wilbur
>Has anyone tried one of these? And maybe someone could weigh in on how it works compared to the Hock chipbreaker?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Clifton 2 piece chipbreaker for Stanley planes?
wilbur
>Has anyone tried one of these? And maybe someone could weigh in on how it works compared to the Hock chipbreaker?
Re: Clifton 2 piece chipbreaker for Stanley planes
David Miller from Iowa
>I have one of these, actually the whole assembly (iron and chip breaker). This set up was too thick for a standard stanley bench plane so I tried it on a bedrock. Got it to work, after a fashion, but the blade thickness introduces some serious backlash in the blade advance. Net result of the assembly - not too hot on a Stanley plane.
However, I put the chipbreaker on a standard stanley iron and it worked OK, after monkeying around with the lever cap screw, but I still had some small, but annoying backlash (the hole is a bit larger than the chipbreaker on that particular plane). I guess it would reduce chatter as it probably adds some stiffness, but a better iron with a standard chip breaker runs circles around this set up in difficult wood.
The notion that the 2 piece design saves time because you can hone and reinstall without removing the main part of the chipbreaker is, IMHO, a gimmick, as it takes about 15 seconds to pull a chipbreaker - less if the screwdriver is handy. Also, the lever cap holds the end of the chipbreaker on and that end falls off and bounces under the workbench almost every time because I forget it is loose when I pull the assembly out (this one is operator error, but definitely negates any convenience argument).
Three thoughts -
1 - Go ahead and get it, it is fun to play with and every experiment helps your technique.
2 - If You are looking for the most bang for the buck, start with a hock iron and the Stanley lever cap (note, I never tried the Clifton on the Hock)
3 - My shortcomings in technique and sharpenening are, by far, more limiting than a Hock cutter and standard chipbreaker.
Re: Clifton 2 piece chipbreaker for Stanley planes
Jerry Nicholson
>I have a couple and they work fine but I prefer the Hock chip breaker along with Veritas irons.
Jerry
I like the hock better...
John in NM
>comes with a screw, clifton doesn't IIRC, and I can buy the hock at my local woodcraft. the clifton I've got works fine though. I like their blades too, though they're a bit thick for using with a standard chipbreaker - the stanley screw is too short to easily attach to the blade.
Re: Clifton 2 piece chipbreaker for Stanley planes
ThomD
>One of the emerging conscensus issues seems to be that chipbreakers are not useful in many situations, and they do create a host of problems of their own. Many of us who used planes where they are separate, like Japanes planes, drop them for many uses. A japanese CB is a step up in many ways, because it can be adjusted on the fly separately from the blade which allows certian things to be done you can't with an attached one, even so they get dropped. Another example is the bevel up frenzy which is CB free, or the stuff on the Clack and Williams site as to why they don't use CBs. One could even argue the rather poor design on the Stanley/Bailey planes is an earlier example of this trend. They are often just set far enough back from the edge to do no good, yet be in the way. Whithout getting OT on why this is, you can see the trend.
So one option I would like to try is just getting some cheap CB and cutting off the parts that don't have to do with the blade adjuster.The cap might need some work also. Then you wouldn't have the issues we do with the often useless CB, and you wouldn't have to remove it for sharpening.
Re: Clifton 2 piece chipbreaker for Stanley planes
ThomD
>Another example of the CB free trend I didn't mention is the curved blade. The tiny amount of curve on finishing blades (where CBs can still be useful at times) isn't a problem but the deeper curves also in use would be dificult to set-up with provided Stanley CBs. Also curved blades reduce tear-put problems themselves.
Re: Clifton 2 piece chipbreaker for Stanley planes
peter kolb
>I tried the Clifton two piece chip breaker on a Stanley No, 4 with a Hock iron and I could not set the iron properly, I gave up and installed the Hock iron with the Stanley chip breaker and I believe it is set up properly. I am very inexperienced so I may be all wet.
The Clifton chip breaker is for sale $13 plus postage. Peter
Re: Clifton 2 piece chipbreaker for Stanley planes
Christopher Fitch @ Memphis
>I have a Clifton chipbreaker with a Hock blade in a Record 05 plane I bought new a few years ago. I tuned up the plane in a number of ways including swapping out the blade and chipbreaker.
I have had no issues with it and it works great.
In fact, I'd say that's my go-to jack plane over some others I have.
Re: Clifton 2 piece chipbreaker for Stanley planes
Bob Demers
>I do not have the Clifton copy, I have the originals: the Record Stay Set (SS).
As you can see in the pic, its quite thick as compared to the thin Record (or Stanley) regular plane irons. We can argue a lot about the effectiveness of the chip breaker, or its optimum position, but one thing is sure: it does stiffen considerably the thin cutter assy.
A stiff cutter is a good thing, it resist chatter.
Now, if you try to use that thick CB (Clifton, or SS) with a thick replacement iron, Hock, LV etc, like the others said, all kind of problems are encountered because the assy is now too thick to fit correctly, and besides, it does not add much to the stiffness of the already thicker cutter.
Conclusion, if you want to try it, do it with a regular thin Stanley cutter to get the most benifit and end up with a more manageable thickness assy.
Want to try it on the cheap? Go get yourself the originals: Record SS,
Even if you dont get sold on the concept, you will end up with a complete, good user's plane for your efforts.
One last thing, i'm not sold on the advertised benefits, and it is annoying to look for the damn end piece every time you remove the lever cap. I suppose you could get use to it, but I have way too many planes, to get used with all their quirks :-)
Bob, the 'plane' and simple guy
Re: Clifton 2 piece chipbreaker for Stanley planes
Bob Demers
>I do not have the Clifton copy, I have the originals: the Record Stay Set (SS).
As you can see in the pic, its quite thick as compared to the thin Record (or Stanley) regular plane irons. We can argue a lot about the effectiveness of the chip breaker, or its optimum position, but one thing is sure: it does stiffen considerably the thin cutter assy.
A stiff cutter is a good thing, it resist chatter.
Now, if you try to use that thick CB (Clifton, or SS) with a thick replacement iron, Hock, LV etc, like the others said, all kind of problems are encountered because the assy is now too thick to fit correctly, and besides, it does not add much to the stiffness of the already thicker cutter.
Conclusion, if you want to try it, do it with a regular thin Stanley cutter to get the most benifit and end up with a more manageable thickness assy.
Want to try it on the cheap? Go get yourself the originals: Record SS,
Even if you dont get sold on the concept, you will end up with a complete, good user's plane for your efforts.
One last thing, i'm not sold on the advertised benefits, and it is annoying to look for the damn end piece every time you remove the lever cap. I suppose you could get use to it, but I have way too many planes, to get used with all their quirks :-)
Bob, the 'plane' and simple guy
Love-Hate
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>I bought the Clifton 2 3/8" iron and stay-set combo several years ago for a Stanley #4 1/2. At the time I did not realize that the iron was a full 1/8" thick, as was the stay-set. Amazingly the combination actually worked on the #4 1/2 without any modification. The #4 1/2 was a NOS thick English casting (circa 1950), and this became my go-to smoother for a few years.
I loved the extra heft the combo gave the #4 1/2. I loved the blade which, after the back was flattened, took and held a great edge. But the cap iron ... gggrrrrrr!!!
I lost count of the number of times the blasted end piece would drop off .. and land safely on my toes. It hurt even with shoes on. The machining of the two pieces was not that good, and I could never get them to mate securely. The end piece rocked around the pin/catch.
Eventually I was seduced by a Type 11 #4 1/2 and sold the English plane. I planned to transfer the Clifton combo, and tried, but it did not fit. I eventually opted for the Clifton iron plus original cap iron in this plane. The iron was also a good fit for a LN #4 1/2.
About two years ago I was looking around for a iron/cap iron combination for a Stanley #51 I had restored. The problem was that this plane could not take an iron thicker than the original, and so I decided to use a Japanese Smoothcut. To beef up its mass I returned to the Clifton stayset. This time I epoxied the two cap iron pieces together. And you know what - it works! This is a great combination. The stayset is a fine fit, and there is no compromise to the adjusters.
The first investigative review I wrote was on the then newly released LN cap iron. It was poorly written article, but I was left with the conclusion that a massy cap iron and thin blade will perform as well as a thin cap iron and thick blade.
If I had to do it again, I'd get the LN cap iron. The one's I have are excellent.
Regards from Perth
Derek