Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Which weighs more?

Posts

Which weighs more?

#1

Which weighs more?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>A pound of wrought iron or a pound of cast steel?

Just kidding, what weighs more a cubic foot of wrought iron or a cubic foot of cast steel?

Stephen

Re: Which weighs more?

#2

Re: Which weighs more?

wilbur

>Density of cast steel: 7.85 g/cm3.

http://www.matbase.com/material/ferrous-metals/cast-steel/gs-38.3/properties

Density of wrought iron: 7.75 g/cm3.

http://hypertextbook.com/facts/2004/KarenSutherland.shtml

So cast steel is a little more dense than wrought iron.

Re: Which weighs more?

#3

Re: Which weighs more?

KenI

>Hmm. My brief search for density of wrought iron (7.75 g/cm3) seems to say that it is less dense than cast steel (7.8 g/cm3). Although, the site I found seems to have a long list of cast steels. A couple of them were about the same as the wrought iron number I found. The exact properties are going to depend on the exact composition of the material. Wrought iron and cast steel seem to be too broad of terms. I'm sure someone with a metallurgical background will have something better to say.

Re: Which weighs more?

#4

Exactly!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Not enough info to truly make up a answer...;^)

Really, what type of each material? Oh yea, stop making do math on teh weekends!

Re: Which weighs more?

#5

Re: Which weighs more?

Andrew F in Australia

>Iron has a density of 7.85 t per cubic metre, slag (molten limestone,) has a density of 1.2 tonnes per cubic metre.

As the wrought iron contains a portion of slag, it's going to be lighter. The numbers you specify seem reasonable.

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: Which weighs more?

#6

Re: Which weighs more?

Todd Hughes

>Steel is heavier then wrought iron, the lower the grade of iron the less it weighs too.

I used to always be on the look out for wrought iron scrap and got to so I could many times get a good feel if it was wrought iron just by lifting it...felt lighter then it should.

Why do you ask which one is heavier?...just wondering....Todd

Re: Which weighs more?

#7

Thank You

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Thank you all for responding, I got the information I was looking for. I am continuing to examine the use of wrought iron and cast steel in nineteenth century tools.

When analyzing the amount of steel used to laminate blades, the weight of each material must be considered. Although the difference in density doesn't seem to be a lot, statisticians like numbers.

Thanks again.

Stephen

Re: Which weighs more?

#8

Dad says . . .

steve mackay

>Sorry but, ask Dad The Tool & Die Maker a question and you get the WHOLE smash !

MATERIAL DENSITY MATERIAL DENSITY

Aluminum 1100 0.098 Magnesium, Cast, AZ91A 0.066

Aluminum 3003 0.099 Manganese 0.267

Aluminum 5052 0.097 Molybdenum 0.369

Aluminum 6061 0.098 Nickel, Pure 0.309

Aluminum 7075 0.101 Phosphor Bronze 0.32

Aluminum, Cast, 356 0.097 Platinum, (99.9) 0.775

Aluminum, Cast, 384 0.102 Silver, Fine 0.379

Beryllium 0.0675 Stainless Steel 301 0.285

Beryllium Copper 0.298 Stainless Steel 302 0.284

Brass, Cartridge 0.308 Stainless Steel 316 0.284

Brass, Free Cutting 0.307 Stainless Steel 420 0.278

Brass, Naval 0.304 Stainless Steel 430 0.283

Brass, Red 0.316 Stainless Steel 440 0.279

Cast Iron, Grey, CL35 0.252 Steel, Mild 0.284

Chromium 0.26 Steel, Carbon Alloy 0.284

Copper OFHC 0.323 Tin 0.264

Gold, (99.95) 0.682 Titanium 0.163

Iron, Pure 0.284 Tungsten 0.697

Kovar 0.302 Zinc 0.258

Lead 0.41 Zinc, Cast 0.24

Magnesium 0.063 Zirconium 0.23

Re: Which weighs more?

#9

Smart Arse!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Let dad do you homework...8^)

Re: Which weighs more?

#10

ROFL ! . . .

steve mackay

>Now that hes got e-mail I send my math up to him also ! I'm very math challenged and the Man does trig in his head !