We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>Can I efficiently teach myself to sharpen, set and use various hand planes, or am I wasting a lot of time by not learning from a qualified teacher. I have taught myself alot from books etc. in other matters. Somebody wrote that you can't teach yoursef to sharpen in general because you don't know what sharp is. Is the analogy appropriate? If I wanted a teacher, where would I look. Should I look for a school or class such as at Woodcraft or seek out a tutor. Jerry gibbs
>You appear to be good with words, so try a little communication here on this forum before you go looking for one-on-one help elsewhere. Here you will get the benefit of many experienced woodworkers' advice. They can tell you about their sharpening techniques and equipment and which works best for which edges. There's no great mystery to sharpening, but it is the single most important condition for good woodworking. IMO
Check our Hand Tools archives for past threads on the subject, too.
>Ditto. Also there is a book by Michael Dunbar on restoring and tuning hand tools - a lot of good advice there. Although I took shop classes in high school, unfortunately I really didn't listen very well (teenager). Thirty years later, I kind of self taught myself on sharpening hand planes. If you're reasonably close to a Woodcraft store, it's a good place to learn some basic skills. Also archived posts here, and in Finewoodworking.com are other good sources. Hands-on is another great teacher, find an old yard sale plane and work with it. I have brought quite a few old "junker" planes back to life just puttering around with them. If you mess them up, you're not out much - a cheap lesson. Hope this helps. If you're in Central Ohio, might be able to help more.
>Also, I forgot to mention, I watched about every "Woodworks" show by David Marks. I was fortunate enough to take some of his classes at my local Woodcraft store, although he did not talk much about sharpening, I was able to look over his personal hand tools such as his chisels - they were razor sharp. I try to model my chisels to what I saw in his tools.
>Have you checked out Lie-Nielsen's instructional DVD's by David Charlesworth or Rob Cosman? I enjoyed them both and learned or relearned bunches from both series. And you may be able to check them out through your local library or inter-library loan. Also they are available for rent at smartflix.com.
>Look in particular for "The Handplane Book" and Peter Korn's "Woodworker's Guide to Hand Tools," but check out any book or DVD that seems to have substantive information on hand tools.
Planes are seen as the most mysterious of the hand tools - but there's a lot you can do with the common chisel, too, so don't focus just on planes. I'm talking below about planes, but you should spend time on learning chisel skills, layout skills, etc.
Tools in general - hand or powered - require certain physical skills (more on that in a bit), but power tools will permit a wider range of less competent skills and still generate results (although the consequences of doing something incompetently risky with a power tool are greater). While you can do something with marginal physical competence with a hand tool and get the job done, it won't be efficient or fun.
So: you have to recognize that, in learning to use hand tools, you're teaching both your brain and your body. The reading will foster your brain, but nothing but practice will nourish your muscle skills. In other words, practice practice practice. As Jack Wortz suggested, buy a plane from the flea market or a garage sale (read the books first, so you have some idea what to look for). A jack or smooth plane - 9" to 14" long - is a good place to start. Buy some pine or poplar from your local lumberyard or home center. Clean up the plane and sharpen the cutting iron (more on this in a bit). If you've already got a workbench, clamp it on edge on the bench and try it out, then clamp it flat and try surface planing. Mess around, in other words; try to make a toothpick (just kidding). Once you're feeling like you've got a sense of it, make a simple project, like a footstool. Build on your skills from there.
THE most important element of a usable tool, assuming it's not a total wreck, is a sharp cutting iron, so, before you touch the tool to wood, work on the sharpening (the books you've read or DVDs you've watched will have introduced you to sharpening practices). This is kind of like playing a musical instrument: you can go from zero to beginner pretty quickly. Beginner to intermediate takes a little longer. From there, you spend the rest of your life refining toward expert, but that's not a bad thing; what looks impressive one year reminds you that you've gotten even better the next.
Yes, lurk and post here; questions are always welcome. If you'll include your city and state in your name line, you may find there's a Centralian near you who'd be willing to spend an afternoon with you doing show and tell, but be fair to her/him and to yourself: do your reading and DVD watching first, so your questions will be smarter.
I suspect most of the members of this forum got started like me, fumbling and learning alone. You can do it too.
Oh, one warning: you'll see references to the slippery slope. You can do a lot with a very basic kit, but many people get, um, interested in all the various kinds of hand tools out there, and find themselves haunting garage sales, or drooling over mail order catalogs. If you've got the money and time and space, fine, but do be aware that acquiring tools is a separate thing from working wood. You can't work wood without acquiring some tools, but you can acquire many tools and never touch a piece of wood with them. If what you want is to make things from wood, resist the siren call of owning one example of every model of something or other made by a particular company, etc., etc., etc. I say this as someone who has to fight that tendency (and lose sometimes).
>The first charlesworth book has a great article on setting up a hand plane. It's as close to obsessive compulsive as you can get without being obsessive compulsive.
I think it's possible to teach yourself sharpening, to a point. (no pun intended.) I did, and I was pretty good at it, though exposure to other methods from qualified instructors really helped a lot.
2 things that I think are worth mentioning.
-If you can get a blade sharp enough to shave the hair on your arm using stones, you're off to a good start.
-(from that qualified instructor) The edge is defined by two intersecting planes. That means, if you're seeing light reflected from that edge, then they're not intersecting cleanly. You should see nothing reflected back at you from the edge.
Eventually I got to the point where I started feeling for a burr, instead of feeling for sharp.
>I taught myself to sharpen from books. It is actually pretty easy since plane blades are a co-operatively shaped. Back then we didn't have video, or Youtube. I'm sure it's faster if you can find a teacher, but for me the figuring out is part of the fun. I think that's the kind of attitude that was necessary at the time, but it makes more sense to get where you want to go whatever way works best.
I do a lot of sharpening freehand, and recommend learning how, but to start with a good jig lets you work on the various parts of the task in isolation. The most common hiccups are not keeping the right angles, which a jig solves. The other piece of that is a flat stone.
The next hiccup is not having a series of stones that work efficiently together. Not so many grits you are wasting time, or so few that the jumps between grit are too large. If you get the angle, and the grits right, that's most of it. There are lots of other things that can go wrong, like clogging a stone, but it shouldn't be all that difficult to spot those things coming.
The process is to work each stone until you feel a wire on the back of the edge, remove that wire on the next finest stone, and carry on until you are through all the grits. At that point you need to test the edge. You want an edge that does not reflect light; That cuts paper enthusiastically; that works when you plane; It should shave very efficiently (if you are comfortable with that). But each arm only has so much hair. The sooner one learns how to test the edge like a barber the better. I came to this test after 30 years of shaving my arm hair and other tests. A barber needs to test the edge with every customer, and he needs a sanitary repeatable method. The sharpening is specific to the razor but the test works well with any woodworking edge:
>1. Figure out your objectives in wanting to learn hand tools.
2. If you can find someone with similar objectives to take some lessons from it will rocket you up the learning curve. If you have the money and time look for some class, but choose the instructor carefully to match your objectives. I have wasted lots of time and money trying to learn things on my own. But if you have lots of time, money, and patience, slow learning could be enjoyable.
3. The bottom line is as you suspected-sharpening. You won't make the first successful step in hand tools until you get a sufficiently sharp edge. That said there are as many opinions on sharpening as there are folks on this forum. And there are lots of vendors willing to relieve you of any amount of money for sharpening materials and equipment. Reading the Archives on sharpening may leave you confused, if not discouraged. The sheet abrasive approach with a jig is cheap to implement and easy to learn. There is an Article in the Articles section that describes the process.
>If it as at all possible see if you can go old skool and rent the Jim Kingshotts video's regarding planing. Not only will you be learning for a great Bit. master but you will have a bit 'o fun doing it!
>After seeing the Charlesworth video filmed at LN I went and hugged my 8" jointer, stroked my thickness planer and told them how much I appreciated them. It was some months before I reconsidered using hand tools. This was not the most encouraging video for someone remote from "close to obsessive compulsive".
>We all learn in different ways. reading, visualizing, doing, discussing, interacting, reading again, etc. Do all of the above. There are a lot of good DVD's out there. There are a lot of web sites. There are a lot of good books on the subject. This site has a lot of archived discussions. Read, visualize, do, discuss, interact, read, do again.
We don't have the luxury of apprenticing ourselves out like the old masters. We have to grab our knowledge wherever we can.
True, the most important thing is learning to sharpen, and no, it does not have to involved any body parts to test your edges, be it your hair or nails or whatever.
The only test that matter, regardless of how you got there is the cutting edge action on the wood. Take a piece of soft pine, and take some slicing cuts on the edge grain. The result should be a glassy smooth finish, burnish like, not dull hazy, no scratches etc.
There are many ways to get that edge, but probably the cheapest is by using sand papers. Disclaimer, by the time you went thought umpteen sheets of quality wet/dry sandpapers (automotive), suddenly, those fancy waterstones don't look that expensive. Nonetheless, anyone can got out and buy a few sheets of SP, right away, not everyone can go out and buy the best waterstones in an appropriate range of grits.
Regardless of method used, I always finish my edges on a 8000 waterstone used with a nagura stone, and I always strop on leather with LV green compound.
Important note: Always wipe your tool in between grits, you do not want to contaminate your sharpening medium and gives yourself more work.
As for the age old arguments Jig or free hand: I use both.
My carving tools have always been done free hand, and I mostly use jig to ensure repeatable edges on my chisels and plane irons.
I say mostly, cause I always strop (often) free hand during a working session.
A good place to learn sharpening is to look up a carving club. Carvers have to be fanatical about their edges, our work is judged by other carvers first and foremost on the cut quality left on the wood.
Bob, who probably has accumulated one of every sharpening set up known to mankind in the pursuit of the perfect edge.
>Had the person(s) that claimed invention of "Scary Sharp" method (I found reference to using sand paper in a Fine Woodworking letter years earlier) bothered to learn anything about abrading hardened tool steel they would have learned that silicon carbide is an especially poor choice in the coarser grits. In spite of it being harder than aluminum oxide, it is brittle and crushes readily when challenged by a hardened steel, thereby leading to the short abrasive life people complain about.
I agree that abrasive sheets and a jig are a reasonable starting place to learn sharpening. It is cheap and easy to learn. However, one's satisfaction will be greater with proper choice of abrasive.
Any sheet abrasive can be made PSA with a high quality spray-on adhesive. The less aggressive products designed for remounting things (for example 3M 75) are more convenient than the often recommended 3M 77 which is too aggressive for my taste.
I have not tried the 3M 3X paper but it may be a best choice considering its composition and structure.
>The guy who invented the term "scary sharp" acknowledged that he had not invented the method. This was back in the early days of rec.woodworking and he described the method as he had learned in his patternmaking apprenticeship. Those guys go back a long way, and I suspect the method does, too.
>Good point, not all videos are encouraging to folks at every stage. The Charlesworth video is probably best for someone who has the fundaments, but wants to answer the question of how to use the baseline accuracy of the plane. So if the plane is set up for 1 thou/22", how do you get that accuracy level on your workpiece. This is the same process for a jointer. Some work needs that kind of acccuracy, other work doesn't. Every tool is a "mold" for a certain outcome - a gouge is a mold for it's sweep. Most tools also have a freehand component. So a jointer is a mold for longi and transverse shaping, but not on a convex surface, that would need freehand work with a jointer, which is why there are compass planes, etc...
So for people who hadn't already figured this stuff out, say from the Krenov planemaking video decades earlier, The Charlesworth video is a revelation, but it could put a person learning basic set-up off. Though I believe a beginer with the right outlook could get it.
My jointer is pretty good, but I have to say no planer I ever owned was completely snipe free, possibly my fault, and if I can't trim the ends off, I do rely on the plane to get the last bit of perfection in there. I have an odd pathology where I am always seeming to work with boards that only barely have the dimensions I require and stuggling to get everything I can out of boards, which is very time consuming.
One of the ironies of ultimate accuracy is that it is one of those situations where sanding can actually come to the rescue. When it comes to getting a very accurate surface one is down to minimal removals of material, and sandpaper on a level surface is surprisingly efficient.
And as said earlier I then finish on Japanese water stone (8000 + Nagura) then strop
Yes, I seems to go thru lots of paper, but I like the convenience, and I do not go thru the whole sequence all the time. That would be only for old rusty implement beeing resurrected.
I tend to keep tatered worn out pieces for starting off rusty steel before moving on to fresher papers.
You are right in the fact that it tend to wear quickly, but im not finding that a negative, I like the resulting edge and i get there quickly, and to me thats the only thing that count.
A highly polished edge in good steel last a long time.
I also tend to put off major sharpenning sessions until, I have to.
Not a biggie, I have lots of spare edges to uses, and I keep mine stropped often, which let me stretch that period.
Hummm, maybe if I had less edges to sharpen, i wont have to hold sharpenning marathon every so often..but then again, nah! :-)
Yes, you can teach yourself, especially with all the learning aids available, which folks have called out in this thread. However, you can get much further along the curve, and faster, with hands-on instruction. If taking courses fits into your life and situation, I really encourage it, speaking as one who learned from trial and error only. Of course, you end up doing trial and error anyway, because you can't take a course in everything. However, watching someone who knows how tune a plane or sharpen a blade speeds everything along. Because it eliminates so many uncertainties from your mind--once you see something done and work, and are shown what sharp is, then you're not guessing anymore.
What do you have now? The toughest problem is if you have a number of vintage planes, in varying states of repair, and you have to figure out by yourself how to sharpen blades, prepare subblades, condition soles, verify the mechanical condition of the plane, etc. When you're teaching yourself, you go through these procedures full of uncertainty 'Is this how it's supposed to be?' 'Is this sharp'? 'Is the blade back flat enough?' 'Is this what they mean by a flat sole?' 'Is this blade relieved properly at the edges? If so, why did I make a track a little while ago--was the lateral adjust out of whack, or is my blade wrong?' A couple of 3 hour sessions, or just one even, will put many of these questions to bed, and allow you to make real progress from that basis in demonstrated technique that you know works.
One thing that helped me working by myself, was getting one good plane early. I bought an incredible beater of a Bedrock. But I also bought a new LN No. 4. So I had the LN plane as a reference. Since it came out of the box nearly sharp, I wasn't too far from getting the blade what I thought was really sharp at that time. This was very helpful in working through my Bedrock 605, which turned out to be a great plane, but was in such disrepair it couldn't even have been parted out--there weren't any really good parts on it! So you can do a lot through reading, if you have a reference plane which is in good repair--like a new LV or LN--and better yet some hands on sharpening instruction.
>This is Jerry again who started this thread. I live near Grand Rapids, MI May-December and Sarasota, Fl Jan-April. I am retired and can afford a day or two of class or tutoring. I can travel 200+ miles and spend a night in a motel if necessay. If there is a class or person available, I am interested. email gwgibbs2001@yahoo.com
>There are several from WC here in Michigan. If you don't find anyone in Florida, I am sure that you can get with someone in MI to visit for a day. It really would not take too long to at least get you started.
>John Wilson in Charlotte. His primary business is shaker boxes and supplies for shaker boxes. He does several classes on other topics each year. I recently took one on making a wooden jack plane with laminated construction and a wood cap to hold the iron in place.
A band saw was used for the cuts, then the wood was shaped and smoothed with a stationary belt sander. Only use of "hand tools" were chisels for cleaning up a mortise for the tote.