Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Oh Mr. Lang you out there?

Posts

Oh Mr. Lang you out there?

#1

Oh Mr. Lang you out there?

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I received your book, signed and everything. Fab reading and your plans are great for the most part. Have I missed or did I overlook just how to make the drawer pulls?

It's been a bit crazy for me lately, but I re-read most of it this afternoon, and I couldn't find anything. Am I missing something?

Seems simple to me on one level, but a lot of them look parabolic.

I get most of it but, I most perplexed by back side of the handle.

Also, did the Hall's ever use plywood as drawer bottoms?

Thanks!

. Thanks you very much for answering my question adout the Greens and Halls.

Re: Oh Mr. Lang you out there?

#2

Re: Oh Mr. Lang you out there?

Bob Lang

>With Greene & Greene furniture you hit a point where you just have to start whittling something out. Every house had a different style of pull, usually with a substyle for each room. Trying to describe typical details when things aren't typical is a challenge to say the least.

Most of the handles I've seen up close curve in two or more directions, subtle curves to be sure, but not straight lines. Most are also undercut on the back with a cove that may or may not be a regular curve. If you start with a rough blank, a rectangle that will contain everything, you can easily cut the cove on the back side. If this weren't the hand tool forum I'd suggest a router table, my best guess is that the originals were done (at least roughly) on a shaper. These can be refined or altered with gouges or the curved side of a rasp, but it makes sense to remove most of what you won't need quickly.

The curves on the front profile can be shaped in a number of ways. To do it all by hand, you could use a spokeshave or a block plane, taking rank cuts at first to get the basic shape and then resetting the tool to refine things. The alternative would be to rough out the shape on a band saw and then form the curves with a plane, spokeshave or rasp.

At first glance, the edges on the corners of Greene & Greene furniture appear to be simple radii, but they vary along the length. This isn't a variation due to careless work, it is a very refined detail from highly skilled hands, and adds a tremendous amount of character to this work.

If you get a chance to see a real piece up close, this will make more sense. It's hard to describe in words, and nearly impossible to draw.

Darrell Peart's book shows techniques for this, it's good stuff and a great book, but it's mostly power tool. If you go to the Popular Woodworking editor's blog and search on Greene and Greene, you can find a lot of stuff, particularly some slide shows of details.

Bob Lang

Re: Oh Mr. Lang you out there?

#3

What about the plywood bottoms?

Alan DuBoff

>Bob,

I was also curious about the plywood drawer bottoms, but would be REALLY surprised to find out that any of the Hall Bros. stuff had ply, seemed that solid wood was used exclusively throughout the Ultimate Bungalows.

There were a few of the Greene & Greene clients that were into lumber, such as Pratt and/or Thorsen. Seems that Pratt was also into trade with China, and I've heard that could be where some of the Chinese tiles that were used around the outer parameter of the foundations could have come from there.

But I was also curious of Scott's question on plywood, and if you have ever seen ANY, which would surprise me as I mentioned.

Regards,

Alan

Re: Oh Mr. Lang you out there?

#4

Re: What about the plywood bottoms? *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Alan and all,

Linked below is what is known as the 'Beckerdite article' on Greene & Greene construction details, and other Greene-and-Greeniana.

Beckerdite, several paragraphs down, discusses the Gamble House chiffonier, which was one of the major G&G pieces. He says that plywood was floated in grooves routed in the drawer sides and front. Here is the paragraph, in full:

"The drawer construction of the chiffonier (fig. 11) is particularly noteworthy. The front corners are joined with finger joints that the Halls cut with a table saw or multiple dado cutters. After cutting the fingers the craftsman smoothed the edges and end grain and then screwed the parts together with countersunk screws that were concealed by modeled ebony plugs. The backs of these drawers were simply butted against the inside surface of the drawer sides and screwed in place. An ebony cover strip with a dovetailed joint at the corner was screwed to the top of the drawer linings, and even this detail was produced with machinery. One large ebony board had a dovetail key cut with a shaper, whereas another had a dovetail pin cut with a matching shaper blade. The craftsman then used a table saw to saw off several different thin strips. For the bottoms of these drawers, plywood was floated in machine-cut grooves along the inside of the drawer front and sides. These boards were screwed to the underside of the drawer back. An oak center strip was screwed to the underside of the drawer and slid within a matching rabbeted strip along the upper surface of the fulldepth dust panels. This center guide ensured the proper action of the drawer even if the opening was oversize or the drawer out of square."

Wiley


Beckerdite article re G&G construction details

Re: Oh Mr. Lang you out there?

#5

Re: What about the plywood bottoms?

Bob Lang

>Thanks Wiley,

I wrote so much about the handle question that I put myself to sleep and forgot about the drawer bottoms. The linked article is very good, although there are some assumptions I don't agree with. I'm sure there are some plywood bottoms (and likely other plywood case parts)but I wouldn't be able to say which ones are ply and which are solid.

We tend to romanticize craftsmen like the Halls, and then assume they have the same attitudes we have today. Those guys were amazingly efficient, and new how to work expeditiously.

Bob

Re: Oh Mr. Lang you out there?

#6

Re: What about the plywood bottoms?

Alan DuBoff

>Wiley, thanks so much for posting that link, I have seen that page before, but these things escape us as there is so much information online...more and more just keeps popping up on Greene & Greene, not long ago it was fairly hard to find anything on the Hall Bros.

Bob Lang wrote:

"We tend to romanticize craftsmen like the Halls, and then assume they have the same attitudes we have today. Those guys were amazingly efficient, and new how to work expeditiously."

Agreed. As an example, I was a bit let down when I first found out that most of the plugs had brass screws under them, it just seemed like cheating in a way...but then I realized that the brass screws work well for that application, and secure things together well. Not only were the Hall Bros. building expeditiously, but were building to last, as best they could.

Of course the massive amount of exotic woods like teak that were used in the homes is daunting.

The Chiffon, isn't that the piece that is located between the kitchen and the living room, in the walk through room? What a gorgeous piece of work. Curious they used ply in that...that almost looked as if it was meant to match with the kitchen wall cabinets that were built in.

I'm not sure I could ever get tired of going through the Gamble house, I learn something new each time I go there, not to mention I always find a way to "cop a feel" of the woodwork...*lol*

Regards,

Alan

Re: Oh Mr. Lang you out there?

#7

Re: Oh Mr. Lang you out there?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Scott,

What project are you making? Sounds very interesting.

Wiley

Re: Oh Mr. Lang you out there?

#8

Re: What about the plywood bottoms?

Alan DuBoff

>Thanks for that link, the dining room table is very similar in the living room where they used brass screws under the plugs.

I always learn something about the furniture, use of ply is one today.

While most of it was done with tailed apprentices, it is without a doubt some of the tastiest work of the 20th century. At least for my tastes. :-)

I have bookmarked that link so I don't loose it, but do remember reading that page before, just didn't remember the part about the ply...like I said, I always learn something about their furniture.

Regards,

Alan

Re: Oh Mr. Lang you out there?

#9

Re: What about the plywood bottoms?

ThomD

>At times teak has been one of the few woods that has been sustainably grown on plantations. It can be daunting in a number of ways from it's cost to the effect on tools, so I am not quibbling with your statement. Just wish there was more teak like species that grew so well.

Re: Oh Mr. Lang you out there?

#10

Hi Alan, Don't believe everything you hear...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Or read for that matter. I've been a fan of G&G for a very long time. I studied and stared at their pieces for years now. I've read most of the books that I couldn't buy (not saying I didn't read those).

Robert's is the first book I could really sink my knowledge and tools into. Mr. Pearts (sp) will be my next purchase.

Just so you know...

There is not a screw under every pin or inlay!

just half of them...

The pieces on their breadboard ends. The mortices were pined as well as a lot of other joints.

That said I need to get some pics off the camera because Hank wants to see'em

OH YEA, YOU DOG...

"I'm not sure I could ever get tired of going through the Gamble house, I learn something new each time I go there, not to mention I always find a way to "cop a feel" of the woodwork...*lol*

YOU GET A BIG YOU SUCK!

Re: Oh Mr. Lang you out there?

#11

Hi, Hank these are for you (mostly)...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Everyone please have a gander. I'm making a what would be called a short sideboard that will be used as a entertainment center. G&G influences my screwed up style. I've killed some 'lectrons for and, I'll do it again on this project. Anyway here;s a side of the little beast. Still need to pin the "branches".


img

Re: Oh Mr. Lang you out there?

#12

A big thanks Mr. Lang! I loved all your help!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I started on the pulls tonight. Keeping my fingers crossed. Heres a pic of the door for the subwoofer.


img

Re: Oh Mr. Lang you out there?

#13

I cound be wrong...

Alan DuBoff

>Scott,

I'm probably wrong, but thought the Docent on the last tour I was on said that there was a brass screw under each of the end plugs in the breadboard on the table in the living room.

Scott wrote:

"YOU GET A BIG YOU SUCK!"

Sing this mantra...stay at the back of the tour pack...stay at the back of the tour pack...stay at the back of the tour pack...:-/

I was just talking to a company about a contract about 30 minutes from the Gamble house, I was automatically thinking that I could go there on lunch to cop a feel, so to speak...*lol*

Seriously though, that place is well taken care of, they even ask you don't touch the banisters when walking up the stairs...:-/

The garage had an area for working on the cars, as well as a gas pump, so the Gambles could have bought gas and stored it and had it at their house. The mechanic could lift engines out of the car with a hoist also...that's quite amazing in itself when you think that the house was built in 1908, I'm sure that stuff might have been added on, but gee...Henry Ford didn't start producing the model T until 1908. That house was state of the art back then. It pre-dated gas stoves and had been converted at some point. They certainly spared no expense restoring it...to tune of about $10M-$12M if I recall correctly. If nothing else, Cali get claim to some of the most wonderful style for my eyes.

BTW, that panel looks KILLER! I like how you incorporated the connectors with the m&t, nicely done! :-)

Re: Oh Mr. Lang you out there?

#14

LOL!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Oh Alan where to brighten, errr, begin...

Well first off your mantras, are better than my poems... nuff said.

Garage tour!?! You like to rub it in dontca!

Thanks for you comments8^)