Re: Thick Maple Bench top
ThomD
>Just to be clear I did not say there would be instability problems, I said:
a) the form of lamination does not contribute to stability, as it would if if were made up of, say, 1/16" 0 oriented veneers. Lamination could be used to improve the stability of bench tops, but I can't remember ever having seen this done in any of the many books or articles on the subject.
b) I also pointed out that the use of multiple pieces of wood is not helpful to stability in this case. The fact your pieces didn't plane shows the random risk involved that one piece of wood with a bad tendency will be in the top.
I also didn't say this piece would have to be secured on all sides, I am just describing the design use. If one applies the component to another situation it is well to understand the design use.
My over all point is something like this: If I want a chicken, I buy a chicken. The discusion of laminated tops is like listening in on people who need a chicken and are discussing the various options in chicken meat product. Is a luncheon meat with thicker slices less work to reconstitute a chicken out of, or should they buy canned chicken meat or burgers, etc... Maybe mechanically deboned chicken in a drywall gun and sprayed over a wire frame?
They make full sized pieces of wood suitable for bench tops, ranging from trees, rough sawn, reclaimed, etc... Price ranges from free, to very expensive. I am merely pointing out that laminated parts are not necesarily less labour or cheaper. There is no need to glue anything up. Traditional bench design is scaled off full size piecs.
If a person particularly wants to work on a wide table top, some folks prefer 48" wide tables, then the situation changes. But the tops on many benches are narrow and do not need to be glued up at all. Just an alternative.
The issue of wood quality is mostly related to price. These laminated tops are made of lower cost pieces, lots of little pieces. This is the usual strategy of making larger parts out of small pieces, nothing wrong with that, but it isn't worth paying the high processing cost if the material does not fit the use. The ideal piece would be absolutely straight grain wood, that plained like butter from either end. I would pay for that.