Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Lie-Nielsen's new hammers. Hardened or Not?

Posts

Lie-Nielsen's new hammers. Hardened or Not?

#1

Lie-Nielsen's new hammers. Hardened or Not?

Scott in Montana

>Being a lover of cross peen (or pane) style hammers, I am delighted to see Lie-Nielsen come out with a quality hammer of this style. This quality comes at a price, but what I have found on the market until now has been junk.

L-N is offering these Warrington style hammers in three different metal varieties, brass, A2, and hardened A2. We all know the needs and uses for the brass hammer, but what is the difference between the A2 steel and the hardened A2 steel; what are the different benefits and applications?

Thanks,

Scott in Montana

Re: Lie-Nielsen's new hammers. Hardened or Not?

#2

Re: Lie-Nielsen's new hammers. Hardened or Not?

ThomD

>I don't get that. A softer A2 would be grippier on certain tacks and less able to mar a blade if it was being used for plane adjustment. It would probably mark less easily than brass. A hardened A2 would be for wacking harder, or softer things. A long diet of bashing hard things, would be more easily survived by a hardened head, while really soft tacks would grip well anyway.

What I don't get is how an A2 unhardened hammer needs to be made of A2, or needs to cost as much as a hardened A2 hammer. Not really sure why A2 is used at all. Watch this space I guess.

Re: Lie-Nielsen's new hammers. Hardened or Not?

#3

Re: Lie-Nielsen's new hammers. Hardened or Not?

David Cockey

>"What I don't get is how an A2 unhardened hammer needs to be made of A2, or needs to cost as much as a hardened A2 hammer. Not really sure why A2 is used at all."

Complexity reduction. If all the steel hammer heads are A2 then they don't have to keep track which ones are A2 and which are some other, slightly less expensive steel. The raw stock doesn't need to be kept separate, and the machining can be optimized for one steel.

As to why the cost the same I can't answer that.

Re: Lie-Nielsen's new hammers. Hardened or Not?

#4

Re: Lie-Nielsen's new hammers. Hardened or Not?

ThomD

>I accept that but A2 is a lot more expensive than say 1045. It would tend to imply to me, based on your reasoning that they don't expect to sell too many annealed A2!

Re: Lie-Nielsen's new hammers. Hardened or Not?

#5

Re: Lie-Nielsen's new hammers. Hardened or Not?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Yabbut. Seems likely that they will just forge and/or machine them all out of annealed. And then harden the ones they need to harden, along with the next batch o' plane blades and chisels.

Wiley

Re: Lie-Nielsen's new hammers. Hardened or Not?

#6

Re: Lie-Nielsen's new hammers. Hardened or Not?

ThomD

>That would work. Still missing a reason though. Sorta like a way to recycle your seconds, without a reason.

Re: Lie-Nielsen's new hammers. Hardened or Not?

#7

Re: Lie-Nielsen's new hammers. Hardened or Not?

David Cockey

>Is your question why both hardened and un-hardened? Or is it why the same price when heat treatment adds some cost?

I don't see anything being recycled or any seconds. Seems to me that they machine heads from A2, send some to be heat treated. Then they are sold as either hardened or un-hardened. Gives the customer a choice.

Re: Lie-Nielsen's new hammers. Hardened or Not?

#8

Which would you buy?

Scott in Montana

>Would there be different applications for the A2 and the hardened A2? Would the hardened A2 be brittle? Would if be subject to break if dropped? If not, why would you buy the unhardened?

Maybe a call to L-N is in order next week?

Scott in Montana

Re: Lie-Nielsen's new hammers. Hardened or Not?

#9

What I've always heard....

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Scott,

A call to LN would be good. What I've always heard is that you don't want to strike a hardened tool or nail with a hardened hammer. As you suggested, striking hard with hard can cause one of the objects to shatter and eject fragments, so that you can get a steel shard in the eye or in a child's eye. So a hardened hammer--and most every claw hammer for example you will see is hardened--is only used to strike unhardened nails. Like common nails or finishing nails. Or a nail set. Or a Japanese plane blade, where you're hitting an iron or mild steel backing.

If you want to strike a hardened tool or nail, like a cold chisel or a concrete nail, then you would want an unhardened hammer. Same thing for hardened irons in planes, except there the brass hammer is even better IMO.

There's probably more to it than this, but these points I'm pretty sure are right.

Wiley

Re: Lie-Nielsen's new hammers. Hardened or Not?

#10

Mulling it over a little

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>I suspect that the annealed or normalized or however-supplied A2, after it was forged/milled/drilled into one of those hammer heads, would have become work hardened to where it might call for stress relief. So even the 'plain A2' hammers may have had some sort of heat treatment.

Wiley.....speculating

Re: Lie-Nielsen's new hammers. Hardened or Not?

#11

What Wiley said makes a lot of sense!

Stuart Hough

>

Re: Lie-Nielsen's new hammers. Hardened or Not?

#12

Doubt it

David Cockey

>I doubt Lie-Nielsen is forging the hammer heads. A set of forging dies would take a lot of hammer sold to recover the cost from. And the forgins would still need machining and/or grinding for the appearance in the photo. Grinding, machining, drilling, and so forth would cause significant work hardening to require heat treatment.

Re: Lie-Nielsen's new hammers. Hardened or Not?

#13

Just went to Lie-Nielsen site...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Al I have to say is Chah-Ching! The only one I'd use is the brass one, and I could make one for a lot less.

In regards to your question Scott, Don't strike hardened to hardened tools they tend to explode. So use a non hardened hammer to strike hardened things and the other way around.

Re: Lie-Nielsen's new hammers. Hardened or Not?

#14

Re: Doubt it

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi David,

My point was about the work hardening which you also comment on--I wanted to correct my previous post. Whoever made the hammer heads would have to stress relieve. Hammers could have been outsourced, or LN could have picked up the dies cheap at auction or abandoned at the diemaker or ...... who knows?

Wiley

Re: Lie-Nielsen's new hammers. Hardened or Not?

#15

Re: Lie-Nielsen's new hammers. Hardened or Not?

Alan DuBoff

>I saw this hammer yesterday at the LN Hand Tool Event in Oakland, CA.

It is a LOT smaller than I had envisioned from the pic I had seen of it online. This is a tiny little hammer, the head is less than 1/2" in diameter, from what I could tell without a ruler.

Deneb Puchalski had a steel model that he was using, but the model I saw being sold was brass.

You really need to see this to understand how small it is, it is tiny. I don't have any hammers that small.

Re: Lie-Nielsen's new hammers. Hardened or Not?

#16

I am very satisfied with my Stanley version

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I can't imagine why one would need/want to make a hammer from tool steel. Driving brads and tacks doesn't put much of a strain on a hammer.

Re: Lie-Nielsen's new hammers. Hardened or Not?

#17

Re: I am very satisfied with my Stanley version

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>True, but tapping out a Japanese blade or setting saw teeth do "put a strain on a hammer," at least in terms of performance. This is a general comment, I don't know anything much about this particular hammer nor about A2 in hammers.

High quality Japanese hammers are forged with soft steel wrapped in hard steel, analogous to the blades.

Pam

Re: Lie-Nielsen's new hammers. Hardened or Not?

#18

Re: I am very satisfied with my Stanley version

Joel

>classic top quality western hammers were/are also either laminated like a Japanese hammer or differentially hardened for the same reason.

Re: Lie-Nielsen's new hammers. Hardened or Not?

#19

Exactly Why?

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Does size matter? One must think so...

Re: Lie-Nielsen's new hammers. Hardened or Not?

#20

The last Stanley Warrington I ordered was junk

Scott in Montana

>Last year I gave away my original Stanley Warrington hammer to a young fledgling woodworker thinking I would order a new clean one. So I ordered a couple sizes of English Stanleys from Lee Valley. I was astonished at what junk they were. The heads were poorly manufactured and heavily dipped in whatever clearcoat they use. On one there was three metal wedges holding the head on and it was still very loose. I would have sent them back to Lee Valley but those people have always been so good to me I hated to bother them. Besides, the shipping would have just about equalled the price of the hammers.

I've had a whole year to discover how much I miss that old hammer. So, while I hate to spend so much on a hammer... obviously it's one I use more than I had ever thought. And I have to say that I've never been disappointed with any Lie-Nielsen product I have.

Scott in Montana

Re: Lie-Nielsen's new hammers. Hardened or Not?

#21

You can overpower small nails

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>with a big hammer. Also, I've heard it said that the cross peen on a Warrington hammer allows for starting a small nail held between the fingers without crushing the fingers. I guess; I've done it once or twice and lived to tell the tale, but, for starting small nails, prefer a magnetic tack hammer (and have a very nice brass-headed upholsterer's with a magnet in one end and a steel striking face in the other).

I do have, and occasionally use, a Warrington made by someone or other in England, a good tool, for which I paid about 6% of the LN price.

Re: Lie-Nielsen's new hammers. Hardened or Not?

#22

Thanks, Joel, I didn't know that.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Lie-Nielsen's new hammers. Hardened or Not?

#23

I get ya Bill...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Driving tacks or brads to me is nothing. I don't use them 8^)

Partly because the brads I see today are such S&^it I can't see using them, let again trying to put them in place.

Pretty much how I feel about the subject.

Thanks, Scott

Re: Lie-Nielsen's new hammers. Hardened or Not?

#24

Hard to go wrong with LN, Scott

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I love all their tools. Only knowing my fun with them I totally agree with you. Not knowing all that much about Warrington's. Sorry you gave yours away. Hope these will work out for you.

Re: Lie-Nielsen's new hammers. Hardened or Not?

#25

Lie-Nielsen's explanation of A2 versus hardened A2

Scott in Montana

>Well, not knowing whether to order the hardened A2 or non-hardened A2 hammer from Lie-Nielsen, I called them. The woman who answered the phone was extremely professional an able to answer my question without hessitation.

The hardened A2 hammer is made for general purpose applications such pounding brads, nail sets, and the like. The none hardened version initially has a prettier finish but the face will mar from metal to metal contact such as driving nails. Hmmmm.... an oramental hammer obviously.

Scott in Montana