Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

OCD much... update

Posts

OCD much... update

#1

OCD much... update

James Watriss

>A few weeks ago, I posted pictures of old stanley planes that I'd drilled and tapped for blade alignment set screws. I'm writing to conform that the experiment has succeeded way better than I'd hoped.

This afternoon I was working on parts for a couple of work tables being made of ash. They're just work tables, but in the absence of more pressing things today, I figured I'd clean them up right, so I took 3 or 4 passes on each side of all of the parts involved, varying from 1" edges to 2.75" faces on the legs.

I bought this 4 1/2C a few years ago, and I liked it well enough, but it just wasn't my favorite, and so it languished on the shelf. It was hard to get it set up just so, and even then, it was a lot of work to use. Now, after drilling and installing the blade alignment pins, setting it up is a breeze. It's a dedicated finishing plane, so the mouth clearance is very tight, which helps, I'm sure. But I did notice that the lateral adjustment has gotten a LOT more predictable, and it's been a lot easier to get very fine, full width, full length shavings with this plane.

Who wants to sand, anyway?


img

Re: OCD much... update

#2

More OCD

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>James,

Great report! In case someone wants to do the same, could you tell us the hardware details. Like what did you use for set screws? Are these slotted set screws that can screw in pretty much flush with the sides of the plane?

Also, I'd like to know more about drilling and tapping. Is it better to drill and tap in separate operations, or did you use tooling where the drill and tap are on the same stem?

I'm asking because am sure there will be people who will want to follow your example.

Wiley

Re: OCD much... update

#3

Re: More OCD

James Watriss

>8-32 threaded hex cap screws. Drilled first, then tapped. I think I ended up using 3/16" screws, but in some cases, the screws went pretty far in, and in others, they were pretty close to the surface.

Re: OCD much... update

#4

Ummm James...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Any explanation of why it did so much better after the modification?

I had a type 17 4-1/2C that sounds a lot like your victim. I sold mine in the end...

Re: OCD much... update

#5

Can't speak for James

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>but I've been thinking about doing this to a 60.5 block plane. I acquired the new LV block plane and it has those blade alignment set screws (as does the shoulder plane) and it really makes a huge difference in holding the blade in a precise position. In particular, the stanley block plane blade has a tendency to move seemingly on its own, especially since the "cap iron" thingie is what you push on and any change in position can change the position of the blade.

Bruce in less snowy MN after a few days of light rain.

Re: OCD much... update

#6

Re: Ummm James...

James Watriss

>I chalk it up to simple geometry.

When you move the lateral adjustment lever, the blade has to pivot somewhere for one corner to go up, and the other one to go down. My guess is that the pivot point was an inch or so up the frog, right around where the lever cap pinches. If you swing the blade around that point, the corners are going to move much more quickly. On something with a narrower blade, it's less pronounced, but once you get out to 2 3/8" it's a bit of a problem, and a little movement on the lateral adjust can translate into a lot (well, comparatively speaking, we're still dealing in hundredths or thousandths of an inch here...) or movement at the corners.

The set screws basically change the pivot point, and the end result is that a little movement on the lateral adjustment lever is a lot more controllable now.

Re: OCD much... update

#7

I concur with James re drilling and tapping

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Should always be two steps, especially in cast iron, which, being granular, wants the tap started properly and slowly.

Re: OCD much... update

#8

Re: I concur with James re drilling and tapping

ThomD

>What about just gluing in a shim? Is it something one actually needs to adjust on an ongoing basis? I don't find that with my LVs. Future collectors will thank you and it will retain more strength/stiffness in the plane if no holes are cut. A couple of blobs of epoxy and you should be good to go.

For drilling and tapping, the best bet is to get a center drill. This is a drill where the short point is married to a stout shank, it won't wobble on you, or break. Use that to open up the hole in the right place, then move on to the right size drill for your tap. You can find a drill/tap guide online, or in those little shop info books everyone sells. LV has one. Use oil for drilling and tapping.

Re: OCD much... update

#9

Re: I concur with James re drilling and tapping

James Watriss

>Well, I think epoxy would be almost as much of a turn off for collectors as holes would be.

I think you do have a point though. That said, many of my planes are in pretty decent shape, but they're not nice enough to attract collectors. Most of em I picked up on ebay for less than $50. The 4.5c is a type 11, and still only went for $65. The type of collector who would be after my plane probably doesn't know much about collecting, and is simply hoarding.

I think there are plenty of planes out there that will work for me, but not attract too many collectors. This isn't a 602, it'a a 4 1/2. And really, I'd bet even money that now that y'all know why I did what I did, it would fetch more as a good user than it would as a collectible. And I'd rather sell a good tool to an educated user than a half-serious hoarding collector.

Re: OCD much... update

#10

The geometry simplified...

James Watriss

>I was thinking about this today, trying to find a clearer way to explain. I think I have it.

Picture a simple angle.

>

Now picture dragging the point to the right. The ends of the lines connected to that angle will remain fixed in place at the left margin of the post, and the distance between them will remain fixed, but the defined angle will keep getting smaller.

That's what I've done by fixing the business end of the plane iron... I've moved the vertex of the angle (defined by the limits of hte lateral adjustment lever, and the pivot point of the plane iron) further away. As a result, the full range of the lateral adjustment lever will result in less movement of the blade. That means that the adjuster will have been made more sensitive as a result. AND, it means that, due to the smaller angle, it will actually keep the iron from pivoting so far that the corners will swing way out.

Re: OCD much... update

#11

Re: More OCD

Alan DuBoff

>James,

10-32 is almost the same diameter as 3/16". I think it's .1875" vs. .190".

Regards,

Alan

Re: OCD much... update

#12

Re: I concur with James re drilling and tapping

ThomD

>James I wasn't really questioning your actions. I would do the same thing you are doing if I needed to. Tools are tools. On the other hand, fads are fads, and if this kind of modification gained velocity it could affect collectors in the future (though I am a user's partisan so why I care...) If it isn't necesarry to do the change, it would be just as well not to. Less work for those who don't have a drill press or taps. The thing with epoxy is that it would be easily reversible. Tapped holes are another story.

I'm the kind of guy who would strip the patina off an old tool cause I like them clean, not preaching.

Re: OCD much... update

#13

Ya mean like Norris?

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Trust me I'm a bit mad at all my Norris planes. The adjusters SUCK on them IMHO.

I understand the concept when the screws are applied around the lever cap easy nuff.

LV's seem to be at the lower end of things, so where the blade protrudes the body of the plane The bottom where the blade exits, (Ya like that will make seance). So, That's what I have a problem with. Seems to me that the blade would never square up when the screws are that low to the blade exit.

Re: OCD much... update

#14

Re: Ya mean like Norris?

James Watriss

>Well, since the limits of the lateral adjustment would be tighter, and you'd get less movement at the mouth of the plane for the same amount of lateral lever movement, my take on it is that if the screws are actually used (set so that they're just touching the blade, and then backed out a fraction of a turn) then it will actually be easier to square everything up. Slower movement= More controllable movement.

That said, I did this on a Stanley plane, and I don't know if Lee Valley added the feature as a bonus, or if they really had to to compensate for wild variances encountered with the Norris adjuster. I'll take another look at the 6 this weekend, before I box it up to send it to whoever wins the auction tomorrow.

Re: OCD much... update

#15

Re: Ya mean like Norris?

James Watriss

>Not around the lever cap... that just holds the iron down.

On the 4 1/2, the set screws were actually very close to the sole of the plane. Farther away the set screws are from the adjuster, the more precise the adjustment will be... and the more limited the range of hte blade movement will be.

I just remembered earlier tonight that I still have an old shepherd tools heavy smoother kit kicking around with, I think, a 2 1/2" wide blade. Of course, I need to make a new cap iron for it, since the one they sent wasn't drilled very well. But I imagine that, at the end there, they were going as fast as they could, before everything imploded.