Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Stickley Table Tenon....help, please...

Posts

Stickley Table Tenon....help, please...

#1

Stickley Table Tenon....help, please...

Frank Mutchler

>I'm making a reproduction of the Stickley #516 "Table With Open Bookcase" as represented in "Shop Drawings for Craftsman Furniture" by Robert Lang.

His dimension for the rails leaves room for a tenon length of 5/8" going into a leg that is 2" square. Is 5/8" long enough to provide adequate structural integrity? I don't know if anyone has seen one of these tables in pieces but I suspect they cut a tenon longer than 5/8". Could be wrong....


img

Re: Stickley Table Tenon....help, please...

#2

Re: Stickley Table Tenon....help, please...

James Watriss

>Given the amount of structure inside hte table itself, I would think that 5/8" ought to be more than enough. The mid-shelf dividers will act like enormous stretchers, and keep the table from racking.

I do remember a friend building one of these. He said the glue up was hairier than the floor of a gorilla shearing rodeo. Whatever that means.

That aside, it's just a table... you're not parking a car on it. As long as your joinery is tight, there's no reason 5/8" shouldn't be more than plenty.

Re: Stickley Table Tenon....help, please...

#3

Re: Stickley Table Tenon....help, please...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>5/8" No worries. That's phaty as far as I see. most stuff I make like this has 1/2" long tenons. Yes I peg all of mine.

Re: Stickley Table Tenon....help, please...

#4

made me look it up

Bob Lang

>It's a good question, and it's one of the places in my book where the reader needs to think and make a choice. At the size listed in the book, the tenons will just miss each other at the top of the leg, as seen on the left in the picture. If you look real close in your photo, it looks to me that there is a peg that would fit within a 5/8 long tenon. If you make the tenon longer, then the two mortises start to interfere with each other. This is a common occurrence and you can make the tenons longer, and miter back the ends. The trade off is a longer/stronger tenon at the expense of the strength of the leg. The leg is a bit weaker because more material is removed. In reality I think either way would be just about as strong as the other.

Hope this helps,

Bob Lang


img

Re: Stickley Table Tenon....help, please...

#5

O.K........5/8" it is

Frank Mutchler

>Thanks for the responses. If the weather will just warm up a bit I'll get this project on the road.

Re: Stickley Table Tenon....help, please...

#6

How are you finishing it Frank?

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>I've bought some strong ammonia for fuming and was debating about a shellac and German lacquer mix as Stickley stipulated. This is for a taboret I've yet to finish. What is German lacquer anyway?

Re: Stickley Table Tenon....help, please...

#7

Re: How are you finishing it Frank?

Frank Mutchler

>I intend to fume it. Never have fumed anything but it seems to be a pretty straight forward process. I'm not sure if I should put some oil finish on it following the fuming or not. I don't know how durable the fuming finish is??

I'm using quarter sawn white oak for the entire table. I've decided not to make the legs with qs on all four sides. The tenons into the legs will be pinned.

The wood has responded very well to finish planing with a Clifton 5 1/2 and a Veritas scraper plane. My low angle smoothers didn't work very well on the qs wo.

I'm trying to make as faithful copy of the original as I can. I understand that there are variations even among the existing originals so I don't suppose there is only one way to do this.

Re: Stickley Table Tenon....help, please...

#8

Re: How are you finishing it Frank?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I think fuming is a "dye," done by chemical reaction with the tannins in the oak, rather than a finish. It's my understanding that it needs a finish to bring out the full color.

Re: Stickley Table Tenon....help, please...

#9

Re: How are you finishing it Frank?

Frank Mutchler

>Thanks, Bill. I think you're correct. Would tung oil or a WATCO oil be close to original? Maybe a wipe on satin poly?

Re: Stickley Table Tenon....help, please...

#10

Re: How are you finishing it Frank?

Frank Mutchler

>Patrick, I just realized I read you subject line and didn't read your message. I don't have any idea what German Lacquer is nor how to mix it with shellac.

Re: Stickley Table Tenon....help, please...

#11

Possible answer for Patrick *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Patrick,

I got curious about German lacquer, and did the lowest form of research--a google lookup. Down below is a link I found, fairly scholarly paper, where the author says in passing that German lacquer is amyl acetate. I believe amyl acetate is mainly a shellac solvent, as is denatured alcohol.

Perhaps resident chemist Bill Tindall could weigh in on this.

Wiley


Paper on Arts and Crafts Finishes

Re: Stickley Table Tenon....help, please...

#12

Correction

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Amyl acetate is a solvent for nitrocellulose lacquer. So now I'm wondering if my first reference is incorrect. I'm curious and will look further into this.

Wiley

Re: Stickley Table Tenon....help, please...

#13

Made in china German Lacquer *LINK*

Frank Mutchler

>Evidently it's a finish currently being used:

Category: Solid Bamboo Flooring. Dimensions: 960 x 96 x 15mm Planks, 24 planks per pack, 2.21m� per pack. Species :Bamboo. Finish: Pre-finished matt with 6 coats of German lacquer, Inc UV protection. Origin:Tongue and groove with a micro bevelle... [China]


Bamboo Flooring with German Lacquer Finish

Re: Stickley Table Tenon....help, please...

#14

Re: How are you finishing it Frank?

Bob Lang

>The references Gus Stickley made are confusing in this day and age. The best answer I've found is that German lacquer or Banana lacquer were early forms of nitrocellulose lacquer. Amyl acetate as a solvent apparently smells like bananas, hence the term.

From what I've been able to discover, the Craftsman Workshops (Gus Stickley's factory) fumed and used shellac until around 1904-1906, then switched to aniline dye stains and early versions of lacquer. At the time finishing chemistry was in transition between old and current. We know a lot about the old and current, but information on what was used during the transition is hazy.

Fuming is a means of coloring, and leaves white oak a rather ugly gray until a top coat is applied. Some tint in the top coat, like the yellow in oil finishes or amber in shellac will warm things up and give a more authentic look. My personal favorite for fumed white oak is amber shellac, and after the shellac is good and dry a coat of dark wax. Aniline dye followed by lacquer also comes close as does the glazing process on Jeff Jewitt's website.

The article I wrote for Popular Woodworking on the Stickley 700 Bookcase shows the 3 stages: fumed, shellaced, then waxed. I'll see if I can put the article online when I get back to work on Tuesday, If not, I'll at least put the pictures up on the PopWood blog.

Bob Lang

Re: Stickley Table Tenon....help, please...

#15

Re: Stickley Table Tenon....help, please...

Scott in Montana

>I cleaned up and repaired one of these or a model very similar for a client maybe five years ago. The tenon was square, not bevelled, and only 1/2 to 5/8 long.

Scott in Montana

Re: Stickley Table Tenon....help, please...

#16

Re: How are you finishing it Frank?

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>Thanks for the info on German lacquer. I'm going to show my ignorance here and ask the question, "Is nitrocellulose lacquer still easily available and what is a good brand?". If not, it sounds like I would be just as authentic using shellac after fuming the oak.

Re: Stickley Table Tenon....help, please...

#17

jaigermister?

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Seems like lacquer to me...

Re: Stickley Table Tenon....help, please...

#18

Re: jaigermister?

kees------WebKitFormBoundary2v945VoJNv+YtMLQ

>google: j�germeister