Re: Page 56
ThomD
>Rich,
"Is this the issue with the draped clock on page 56? Some of the stuff in that gallery is a bit bizarre, to say the least."
One thing is that this was an article on a gallery. They are choosing the work for inclusion in the magazine through a filter of an article on a national institution covering studio furniture. Different mater than presenting the material as a piece they have chosen to feature for their own reasons.
If you know the maker, he has a long tradition in our community including a book on his stacked furniture method (personal yuck on that style) that was influential with other makers, and showed all his techniques. A guy who has been a shop teacher if I recall, but got out there and sold stuff also. He then proceeded to very fancy Ruhlman based furniture, and I guess this is some more recent stuff. I have lost touch.
So the basic issues are:
- Should a woodworking mag ever cover a gallery: A lot do.
- Should they choose a range of representative work, including irritatingly pretentious stuff, which certainly was, and probably still is part of the scene?
- Should they feature a maker with a strong following among clients, who is also well known to woodworkers?
I have to say that pic was a groan for me too, but I was interested because I have followed the maker. I am not against this kind of thing, but I does have problems for me.
- One is it is often exceedingly trite.
- Apparently it sells, which is good. Any piece that has a chance of being marketed may have to curtsey to the market somewhat. When one gets into this kind of thing the bowing appears to be lower than usual.
Just my random thoughts.