Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Making wooden planes -- beech vs. other species?

Posts

Making wooden planes -- beech vs. other species?

#1

Making wooden planes -- beech vs. other species?

wilbur

>What were the factors that led to beech being the primary wood for making wooden planes?

The reason I ask is that I've been thinking about trying to make one of my own, but beech isn't readily available here. Cherry and maple are much more abundant, and at least on paper according to the USDA Forest Service they seem to have similar characteristics and physical properties as beech does.

Re: Making wooden planes -- beech vs. other species?

#2

Re: Making wooden planes -- beech vs. other specie

ThomD

>There is a claim that it looses moisture in a manner that allows it to be more stable. It is also possible that it wasn't desirable for a lot of other things. It isn't a premium rot resistant wood, cabinet wood, strong things wood etc... It is used for chairs and furniture a fair bit in euro.

Of the two woods you mention, maple makes excellent planes. To my taste, cherry is otherwise valuable (as is maple), but is not hard enough strong enough, heavy enough, and tends to crumble a little. Still I don't doubt it would do.

Re: Making wooden planes -- beech vs. other species?

#3

Most hardwoods will work...

John in NM

>I suspect, as Thom pointed out, that beech was a bit of a waste wood when wood planes were the industry standard, and its a nice hard, dense wood that makes a good plane.

The first shop I worked in had a request for a beech topped table to match some awful designer chairs that had beech dowels. None of the local lumber yards were willing to order it for us, due to some seasoning or acclimatization problem or another.

I've been saving a lot of 8/4 and 12/4 cherry scraps for just this purpose, though I never seem to get around to making one. Perhaps once I've done the three or four rifle stocks I have in mind, cranking out a molding plane will seem easy.

Re: Making wooden planes -- beech vs. other species?

#4

Here's a very good reply to your question  *LINK*

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>


http://www.planemaker.com/articles_beech.html

Re: Making wooden planes -- beech vs. other species?

#5

How about Hickory?

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>Wilbur,

What about hickory? It's a nice dense hardwood and relatively easy to come by here in PA/NJ. I imagine that would make a nice wooden plane.

That sawyer near me used to have 16/4 hickory stickered in his barn. I'm almost sure he still has some there. You just have to know where to look and be willing to dig around a bit.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Making wooden planes -- beech vs. other species?

#6

Re: Making wooden planes -- beech vs. other specie

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>wilbur,

I have seen shop built planes out of every kind of wood, I have even seen a router plane made of pine.

As for the reason beech was used is because beech was the common wood in Europe, wears smooth with use and was readily available. Other factory woods used in planes are rosewood, ebony and boxwood as well as ivory.

If you aren't going to use beech consider rosewood as I assume you will be making Oriental style planes. You should also consider Japanese Oak but Maple would be just fine.

Stephen

Re: Making wooden planes -- beech vs. other species?

#7

For Japanese planes

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>When I asked this question for Japanese planes, I was told: Japanese white oak; Hon red oak; or Live Oak.

Re: Making wooden planes -- beech vs. other species?

#8

Re: Making wooden planes -- beech vs. other specie

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Wilbur, I have made planes of the woods you mention, cherry, hard maple and soft maple, but I much prefer beech. With hand tools, beech cuts cleanly and crisply so it is good for technical work. But the reason beech is outstanding for planes is that the wedging action is so good. I think it is the easiest to adjust and to adjust to a fine degree. And the wedge stays put. You can find woods that are more stable or harder or more flashy, but in day to day performance, beech excels.

Beech is native to all but one county in New Jersey and all but one in Pennsylvania.

Re: Making wooden planes -- beech vs. other species?

#9

Hi Dom...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Ever try to work it with hand tools? Nasty stuff IMHO. Stringy evil wood... It would probably make a great plane with the grain orientated the right way.

Re: Making wooden planes -- beech vs. other species?

#10

maple

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I have been satisfied with the maple planes I have made. David Fink (the plane book guy) has planes made from all sorts of wood. It would seem that for Krenov style planes the wood is not important so long as it is hard.

Re: Making wooden planes -- beech vs. other species?

#11

same thing

paul womack

>As far as I know, the functional requirments of the timber are the same for Japanese and Western plane design.

Wear resistance and stability seem to be about it, with workability helping the maker (not the user).

Traditional Japanese plane makers would be ignorant of which non-Japanese timbers would work well.

BugBear

Re: Making wooden planes -- beech vs. other species?

#12

Re: same thing? Probably not.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>All sounds logical, but often the real world doesn't conform to logic. I suspect that the weight and geometry of a Japanese blade is very different, perhaps much more demanding of the supporting dai. Also the different ways Japanese planes are used, such as pulling with a low center of gravity, would make a difference.

Also, the Japanese have many more wood species than the two oaks (the Live Oak is an American wood) that they're highly likely to have experimented with.

And then there's the experience of those much more experienced than I in making Japanese planes. They say there are only three suitable species. But this is second hand. It's not that some other wood might work for the initial build, it's that they don't last long in use.

Pam

Re: Making wooden planes -- beech vs. other species?

#13

Re: same thing? Probably not.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>That last sentence should be: It's not that some other wood might not work for the initial build, it's that they don't last long in use.

Pam

Re: Making wooden planes -- beech vs. other species?

#14

restricted choice

paul womack

>I think you're missing my point.

Let me try an anology.

For many years in Europe, if you'd asked a craftsman which timber made the best hammer handle he'd have said ash, without hesitation.

It had been used for centuries, and proven by time and tradition.

Nothing was better.

They didn't know about, and had never tried hickory...

BugBear

Re: Making wooden planes -- beech vs. other species?

#15

restricted choice

paul womack

>What were the factors that led to beech being the primary wood for making wooden planes?

One might argue that it isn't, at least universally.

Hornbeam, Cormier, Pear and Japanese Oak are also used, even where beech is available.

BugBear

Re: Making wooden planes -- beech vs. other species?

#16

Re: Making wooden planes -- beech vs. other specie

wilbur

>Thanks for the input! I have some 8/4 cherry and maple on hand, which is why I was thinking about those woods in particular.

Re: Making wooden planes -- beech vs. other species?

#17

my French is pretty rusty

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>and I'm not sure that Mlle. Dunphy, back in high school, ever introduced us to the phrase, "foire aux puces," which the online translation program saw as "fairs in fleas." At least L'Academie was successful in avoiding "le flea market."

Re: Making wooden planes -- beech vs. other species?

#18

Should have mentioned

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>The French phrase appears way down toward the end of the Clark and Williams article to which Patrick linked, in a discussion of French planemaking practices.

Re: Making wooden planes -- beech vs. other species?

#19

I didn't miss your point.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>If you say there is possibly another species in the world that no one interested in making Japanese planes has ever come across before, I suppose I'd have to admit that possibility. Perhaps somewhere hidden in the Himalayas, grown in the Lost World....

Pam

Re: Making wooden planes -- beech vs. other species?

#20

From Josef Greber.....

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Josef M. Greber, 'History of the Woodworking Plane', p. 99 (EAIA Edition), where he is speaking about the flowering of the wooden plane in 16-18th century Europe,

"Not much has been written about the woods used for plane stocks. According to Roubo, cornelian cherry was preferred in France for the best planes*. It is very hard, dense, and tough, but shrinks badly. Johann Samuel Halle writes, "They cut the wood for all planes, as well as for all joiners' tools, from white beech in a single piece." Many of the Dresden planes [NB: an important collection of 16-18th century planes] were made of boxwood, the heaviest and hardest of our native woods. A 1597 Dutch smoothing plane and others are made of beech. We also find maple, birch, pear, and plum, all quite hard woods, which do not split easily. Walnut, of which plane stocks are sometimes made, is probably the least suitable because it shrinks too much and is easily split."

*My note: 'Cornelian cherry' is the popular name for Cornus mas, which is in the dogwood family, rather than in the cherry family (typically Prunus spp.)

Wiley

Re: Making wooden planes -- beech vs. other species?

#21

But then...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>they'd be Shangri-Laian (Shangri-Laotian?) planes, right?

Bill, who couldn't resist the straight line (thanks, Pam!).

Re: Making wooden planes -- beech vs. other species?

#22

Anytime, Bill. :)

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Making wooden planes -- beech vs. other species?

#23

Re: From Josef Greber.....

Wolfgang Jordan

>Wiley,

is this a translation from the EAIA edition of Greber's book? I don't have my copy at hand, but I reckon that "white beech" is a literal translation of "Weissbuche", which is in fact hornbeam (Carpinus betulus). German planes where traditionally made of hornbeam. Beech (Fagus sylvatica) was only used in newer times (>1920) when hornbeam became scarce.

Wolfgang

Re: Making wooden planes -- beech vs. other species?

#24

Re: From Josef Greber.....

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hello Wolfgang,

Thank you very much for checking the accuracy of the English translation. Yes, I was quoting from the EAIA edition, p. 99.

Through a friend's amazing generosity, I also have a German edition by Th. Schafer, Hannover, 1987. On p. 194, I have found the word which was translated as 'white beech'. The German word in the text is "Weissbuchenholze".

And you are saying that "weissbuchenholze" refers to Carpinus betulus, or European hornbeam. Well, this is wonderful information!

Here is what we should do--find some European hornbeam and make some planes of it!

Thank you very much!

Wiley

Re: Making wooden planes -- beech vs. other species?

#25

In America...

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>they would and did use hop hornbeam (Ostyra spp.) for planes, loom shuttles, spinning bobbins and gear cogs, etc.

Stephen