Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Finally, some movement on the workbench!

Posts

Finally, some movement on the workbench!

#1

Finally, some movement on the workbench!

Stuart Hough

>Today I finally had time to go to the Orange box store and get the raw materials for my FIRST REAL WORKBENCH (heretofore to be known as the FRW). I am using SYP as suggested by Sir Chris Schwarz in his article on the $175 Workbench. I spent almost two hours sorting through the stacks 2-by-8's, 2-by-10's and 2-by-12's. I only found two that would serve me well enough, with very few tight knots and grain that would have the right orientation after sawing (quartered or very near). I had noticed earlier that the BORG now carries 5/4 SYP in 4" by 12' lengths. So I started looking through that pile, and was able to get all I needed to build the top. My plan is to use the 5/4-by-4's for the bulk of the top, and use a 2-by for the strip where the dog holes will go. Also I will use a 2-by for the front and back laminations. Overall thickness will end up between 3 and 3.25 inches. Now for the questions that need answering...I will be letting the lumber acclimate to the shop for approx 2 weeks before starting to mill the "stuff". I have it stickered and stacked, but am not sure of the spacing required between the stickers. I currently have them at about 18" apart. Is that too close, or about right? Also, I am using plywood for the stickers, set on the face. Is 3/4 " enough of a gap between the boards to allow for airflow? I appreciate any and all bits of advice on my FRW. Let me know what any of you think about what I am planning, and any changes you would make. Thanx to the collective!

Re: Finally, some movement on the workbench!

#2

I'm not familiar with southern yellow pine

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>being a Left Coastie, where Douglas fir serves the same sort of purpose, but:

1. I would think 18" would be fine. Make sure you keep the stickers aligned with each other vertically (that is, each sticker directly above the ones below it).

2. The first, critical issue is getting a good, level base. This should be generous - 4x4s or similar not too much, or you can put 2x4s on edge with plywood "feet" to make them wider at the base - to provide oodles of air below the stack. Make sure they're straight. Use your longest level and your straightest boards to check that it's level in all four directions - length, width, and diagonally both ways. A bundle of those carpenter's shim shingles can be your friend big time here.

3. I've used plywood stickers, and they worked just fine.

4. If you're stacking more than one board per layer, leave room between the boards, too, so there's airflow on each surface of the board, except,

5. If the boards are really wet, slop something on the ends. If you've got a can of paint left over from some project, that's fine; you'll be cutting the ends off anyway, so it doesn't matter if the ends of the boards are covered with the chartreuse paint that looked so right on the paint sample but just didn't work on the family room wall. If not, about anything will work, or, if you've got a really really pure shop without anything appropriate and no neighbors who hold onto that kind of thing, you can often pick up returned paint at paint stores cheap.

Re: Finally, some movement on the workbench!

#3

Thanx, Bill

Stuart Hough

>I'll have to re-do the stack with the 2-by-4 idea. Right now I have the 3/4' stickers on the garage floor. Makes sense (now that I've already done the work) that I might need more space below the stack. As far as level, the floor checks out as all in one plane, except for about a 2% grade, toward the rollup door, I guess to insure drainage in case of water intrusion. I didn't see it in the store, but one 2-by-10 has some twist to it. If I weight the ends done opposite the twist, will it lessen the twist, or is this just wishful thinking? Thanx again.

Re: Finally, some movement on the workbench!

#4

Re: Finally, some movement on the workbench!

chuckbeck in cent il

>I built a schwarz french bench this summer and my advice to someone with a pile of lumber and a dream is get three things:

1- A solid week that you can give the bench at least 6 hours a day. SYP really moves quite a bit on me, even the stuff I bought really dry, and left stickered for a year. Machine it and glue it up the same day whenever possible.

2- Get a whole gallon of titebond II or III. You really don't want to run out in the middle of a glue-up.

3- Count your clamps, your buddies clamps, your uncle, your aunt and beg to use them, and promise you won't get glue all over them (you will). If you glue up legs with integral tenons and all the layers of the bench it really takes a lot of good clamps to put the squeeze on it.

I spent all day today at my bench and I love it. It is the best thing i have ever built. Plan ahead on the pine and it'll be just fine. Good luck

chuckbeck

Re: Finally, some movement on the workbench!

#5

Thanx Chuck. Wise advice

Stuart Hough

>on the clamps. I was planning on getting quite a few more for the build. I'll double that to "way more than I could possibly ever need at one time"!

Re: Finally, some movement on the workbench!

#6

Re: Finally, some movement on the workbench!

wilbur

>Hi Stuart,

Is there any place indoors that you can sticker this pile? If you have a basement or a spare room, the humidity swings will be less than your garage.

Some benchtop glue-up tips I learned recently first-hand:

1. Try to resist the temptation to hurry the process, and glue up your strips one at a time.

2. Figure out which of your boards will make up the back of the benchtop, and glue those up first. That way, when you screw up, it will be on a less noticeable and critical part of the bench.

3. When milling the boards for the benchtop, I only planed the sides that were to be glued at first, and just made sure that they were roughly perpendicular to the top. Then, when aligning the boards for the glue up, I referenced off of the unplaned top surface. You'll have to flatten the top anyway, so there isn't a great reason to waste that material up front. Referencing the glue up off the top surface means that most of the unevenness will be on the bottom side, where it won't matter so much.

4. Make sure you take the time to ensure that the boards are touching at the ends before gluing. This will help a lot in the long run with the stability of the benchtop. Essentially, what you're making is a really long sprung joint.

5. Sharp plane blades are a must! And a jack plane with a cambered blade will be your best friend.

Re: Finally, some movement on the workbench!

#7

lumber drying and other ramblings

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I have dried thousands of feet of hardwood lumber so this advice is from experience and spent time around commercial kilns. However, I have avoided drying SYP because I never used it for anything. 18" spacing is typical for hardwood lumber in long lengths, however when straightness is critical 12" is preferred. 3/4" stickers are ok. But none of these factors will be important if the base of the pile is not in one plane and you don't have LOTS of weight on the top of the stack. Specifications on framing lumber are typically 18% moisture content, way too high for what you are doing. Unless the lumber is where it is hot it may not be sufficiently dry in 2 weeks. Coating the ends is a waste of time in your case, and in most cases in general. Because this lumber was never exposed to high KD temperatures the sap will not be "set" (hardened). I don't know what issues this will cause in your case but there is risk of stickiness for years anywhere there is sap accumulated (knots for example). .

In addition to all the other criteria that were used to select lumber, I would have added to pick lumber that had tight growth rings (slow growing).

Considering all the effort to build a bench I would have worried more about the properties of the lumber and less about the cost. While KD SYP from slow growth trees would be heavy, hard and durable and fairly stable, framing lumber from rapid growth plantation trees may not be ideal for the application.

Everywhere has a lumber supplier that supplies to cabinet shops and other large users of hardwood lumber. Being nice to someone at one of these places could yield access to hardwood lumber costing not much more than yellow pine framing. Anyone selling large quantities of hardwood winds up with "bits and pieces" that could be usable for a bench. My bench came from some 12/4 poplar special ordered for a customer that didn't take all of it, for example. A top 32" x 6' x 3" will cost less than $150 in poplar if one spends some time finding a high volume supplier.

Re: Finally, some movement on the workbench!

#8

Re: lumber drying and other ramblings

Chris Friesen

>Southern yellow pine is about 40% heavier and 33% stiffer than poplar. Both of these are desirable in a workbench.

Re: Finally, some movement on the workbench!

#9

Re: Good news on the bench!

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>And what you've done so far, with the comments from the others, sounds fine.

When I built mine, waaaay back in 2002, (;-)), the plan had, in the version I used, a laminated plywood top. Has that changed? It certainly made my life easier, and has not made the bench less usable than any other, well made, $175 bench.

Enjoy the ride!

Re: Finally, some movement on the workbench!

#10

Re: lumber drying and other ramblings

wilbur

>"Considering all the effort to build a bench I would have worried more about the properties of the lumber and less about the cost. While KD SYP from slow growth trees would be heavy, hard and durable and fairly stable, framing lumber from rapid growth plantation trees may not be ideal for the application."

Christopher Schwarz has built a bunch of workbenches from this material. After a few weeks of shop acclimation time, he's had no issues with moisture or movement outside of what would normally be expected from seasonal movement.

Re: Finally, some movement on the workbench!

#11

Re: Finally, some movement on the workbench!

ThomD

>The weird thing about drying wood is that you can at times get away with anything and you can also get slapped down hard for nothing. So all the advice so far is probably correct, but...

The thing about workbenches is that they really need to be considered as something other than furniture. Think of them as a tool. I have normally built mine out of top notch wood, and put a decent finish on them, so I could be proud of them, which can lead to problems. The last euro style one I made I used oil finish on them that had rusted in the can and accidentally created a nice stain effect, so now I don't even want to refinish the top since any plane cuts will take away the stain and make it look bad. Far better to have something less prim to work with.

Based on harvesting trees for benches, and also on the work of John Alexander on the idea that cabinetmakers may also have worked from wet wood is that you don't really need to even dry this stack of wood out. Anything being used to frame tresles, obviously doesn't need drying out, and even a huge top probably doesn't. There are certain boatbuilding glues and poly glues that will glue up wet wood. When the wood is glued up it wil dry rapidly on the surface and be fine as a workbench. My huge wet oak bench doesn't rust tools left on it, though I wouldn't risk it as a rule.

I would core out any of your 2xs that have a pith running up them and glue them back together. Otherwise I would start right awaw. The bench format is perfect for holding the pieces level. You will probably have to make corrections, but at least you know that going into the process. It is a good habit to get into.

As far as conventional drying is concerned, place a plastic on the floor, some 2x4 stickers, then use 3/4" stickers. The longi spacing can be whatever you want as long as the boards don't sag, and the stickers are aligned vertically. For 2" boards they are stiff enough to not even worry much about sticker alignment in the average pile.

In most area, if a person wants quality hardwood, they can find it at 50 cents + a board foot undried. Buying lumberstore wood and then having to dry it kinda defeats the purpose.

Re: Finally, some movement on the workbench!

#12

Re: Finally, some movement on the workbench!

Chris Friesen

>"In most area, if a person wants quality hardwood, they can find it at 50 cents + a board foot undried."

I live in the Canadian prairies. There is no decent hardwood available locally. I basically can't get anything for less than $4/bft, and most of it is much more than that.

It sucks....

Re: Finally, some movement on the workbench!

#13

Re: Finally, some movement on the workbench!

Bob Demers

>I have lived mostly in Eastern �canada, Maritimes to Ontario, I cant rememebr the last time i saw lumber at 0.50 cents a Bft.

Im happy with $4 Bdf anyday, and yes I have gotten lumber from small sawyers operators (Woodmizers) for a few buck cheapers, one or two bucks a Bdft but never cheaper.

All considered, there is a lot of work and equipments cost involved in getting lumber from the forest to our shops.

Bob, who like to support local sawyers. Good service, good price, good value all around

Re: Finally, some movement on the workbench!

#14

Or you can get paint for free...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>At your local landfill/transfer station. Here on the west coast any way.

Re: Finally, some movement on the workbench!

#15

Some further info...

Stuart Hough

>The boards for the top are 5/4 S4S SYP. The edges all have the growth rings coming out at or very near quarter-sawn style. All the boards hae very tight ring-spacing. At the top's finished thickness of 3.25" I should have a VERY stiff and sturdy workbench top. The bench I envison will be a combination of the Holtzapffel and the $175 Workbench, sort of a Holtzapffel on a 2 week diet, with the legs not quite as big, and the top not quite as thick. I'll probably do a leg-vise, as the wooden-screw twin vise is a bit out of the budget right now, but I should be able to add it later (if I hit the lottery!!). I have an old 1920's Columbian vise to go in the tail position. Thanx for all the posts!

Re: Finally, some movement on the workbench!

#16

Call me crazy, but

Roy Anderson

>I just can't feature kiln dried SYP needing all that much effort to get it acclimated to your basement as some of the writers here suggest.

I would (and did) just jump in and build the thing. This is a work bench, not fine furniture. I will give my second to the notion of gluing it up board by board and starting with the rearmost boards. I also will give my second to the idea of indexing the top when you glue up and taking most of the variability on the bottom. But try not to have too much variability or it's a b!^ch to plane off. Ask me how I know this. I ripped a bunch of 2 by 8's to 2x4 to make my top and my hand ripping was a bit crude, hence, variability.

Personally, I didn't give a flip about grain and knots etc. I just grabbed a bunch of construction grade lumber and put it together. Now, I have absolutely no concern about banging, sawing, chiseling, gluing, overspraying, spilling or what the heck else might happen, because it's just a bench. It's solid, level and holds the work in place. If it gets too rough (not likely for several years), I'll just throw it away and build another one.

Sorry about my attitude. You can read all about it in Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance, a great read even after all these years. See the discussion on making shims for handlebar clamping. That's exactly what we're talking about here.

Re: Finally, some movement on the workbench!

#17

Sound like a good plan Stuard

Bob Demers

>Sound very much like my typical project, I never quite built anything according to the 'original' plans. I take a little bit of this, leave out a little bit of that, adapt my construction to my styles, tools, and material at hand, and if i really goofed it, well.. it then becomes designer kindling. Burn just the same, but it erase your mistakes :-)

About your twin wooden screws dreams. I wouldnt wait for hitting the jackpot, i'll improvise using metal screws found in still commonly found (?) leg vises. Or i'll try my hand at carving my own ( See how in one of St-Roy books) i'll look it up in my library later and let you know which one.

There are also wooden threads kit avail up to 1 in and a half (the tap and the thread box). I have both a 3/4 in and a 1 and a 1/4 in kit, works great, althought 1 and a 1/2 is probably the limit for these type of thread box.

There is also Beal thread cutters using a router, but i have no experience with these, nor do I know which size they go to.

Bob, the pertutual dreamer. One day soon, i'll retire and...

Re: Finally, some movement on the workbench!

#18

Re: Call me crazy, but

Bob Entwisle in NJ

>Roy, thanks for the breath of sanity in these discussions, and now I'm gonna have to dig up a copy of Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance, if my memory is not totaly shot, a slice or two of beer can makes excellent handlebar shim stock! (though probably not part of a BMW tool kit).

Bob in NJ still riding (not often enough) a more or less stock 1977 SuperGlide.....

Re: Finally, some movement on the workbench!

#19

Re: Finally, some movement on the workbench!

ThomD

>"I live in the Canadian prairies."

Not where most people live though is it? I've been all through that area, though it has been a while. I seem to recall there are trees in the cities. Rumour has it there is a ghost town in Sask. where all the houses are stacked with wood. Some woodworker's club or other, though it can't have been cheap to get it there.

The fact remains that if we are talking wet wood it is perfectly possible to hit that number. Wet wood is basically garbage you have to pay to have someone haul it away. 2x4s are an engineered wood product, sawn and planed and finished 4 sides, stamped for grade, etc... Essentially nothing in that package has anything to do with making a bench. If in addition to that you have to dry it out, one wonders why one would bother, except for the fact that it saves the trouble of working wood... But then again if one doesn't enjoy woodwork.... Just kidding.

Re: Finally, some movement on the workbench!

#20

Re: Finally, some movement on the workbench!

ThomD

>Hey Bob every year I woodwork from Ontario to New Brunswick. You may have to look for cheap wood, if you want it. Last fall the neighbour paid to have his maple nocked over right here in downtown Pickering. Could have got several benches out of that one alone. All I had room for was a choping block and a piece of crotch.

Woodmizers make whatever you want, but mostly beams and planks. A bench just requires a piece of wood the size of a benchtop. That is reasonably easily released from a log with a few crosscuts and an axe. An assessment I may have to revisit when I enter my fifties this spring. Sure if you want to covert a log into venner it might take some doing but I get the feeling we are loosing contact with our inner bench here.

Lets say you have a really big log, 24 ft. long with enough section to make a bench. Let's say one makes some of those fiddly little benches that are six ft. long. That with take 3 saw cuts and some splitting out. Now lets say one makes some master craftsmen type benches of 8 ft. length. That will take 2 saw cuts to cut to length. Now lets say you glue that 8 footer up out of 2xs, not even counting all the work to get there, you are still left cutting that thing to length, 2 cuts. The bigger you make it the less work you do when you start from solid wood.

Of course that is free wood. You get some of that 50 cent wood it costs more, and you will do more work than the solid log bench less work than the 2x bench. That's pretty much the truth all joking aside, and realizing that there are a lot of different ways this actually plays out. But I have done it myself the various ways involved.

Re: Finally, some movement on the workbench!

#21

Thanks. I couldn't have said it better

Victor P

>if it's thick enough the top can be ground flat again avery few years with very little effort. Why throw out an otherwise good work bench.

Victor

Re: Finally, some movement on the workbench!

#22

Opportunity here, Chris

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>You can be the leader in developing the sod workbench, for those who live in prairie country. I bet you could get published in Popular Wood, even!

Re: Finally, some movement on the workbench!

#23

Sweeeeeeeeeeeeeeet

James Watriss

>Finally, a breath of fresh air.

You mean tools are just tools? I thought they had to be shiny?