Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Ol' Draw Knife....

Posts

Ol' Draw Knife....

#1

Ol' Draw Knife....

John L. Blue

>rewindin' a past post, I told the feller I wanted the best of the

bunch, he handed me one without the handles, he was right, that

knife has Dogwood handles nowadays, used it on a Mike Fink Pole

today. 10 bucks, a great deal, how 'bout it! Blue

Re: Ol' Draw Knife....

#2

Re: Ol' Draw Knife....

Todd Hughes

>If the best of a bunch was one with out handles I sure would hate to have seen the rest of them !

Never thought of trying to sell drawknives with no handles...maybe I should stop throwing them out on the scrap pile

But you sound like you are happy with your buy and that is what counts.....Todd

Re: Ol' Draw Knife....

#3

Todd's reality check.

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The purpose of this note is not to criticize Todd , but to provide perspective to the rest of the readers who may find his comments bewildering. From the many comments Todd has made along these lines it seems that he lives in an area exceptionally rich in old tools. While I don't do garage sales and flea markets every Saturday I do frequent our local flea markets maybe once a month and when we vacation around the country I won't pass one by without stopping. Additionally, I usually go to the huge event at Hillsboro, VA in the fall and occasionally I check out what is going on on Ebay. This experience gives me some perspective on the availability and quality of old tools in the places I frequent. And that is.....old tools-planes, chisels, spoke shaves, saws, etc- not covered in and pitted by rust are rare. Yes, very rare.

To quote a specific example, I have been looking to assemble a modest collection of paring chisels. I have come to learn that smoothing pitted backs is a waste of my time. In several years I have found two lightly pitted chisels. There weren't any chisels at the flea market at Winchester VA and nothing in the Ocala, FL area when I visited, and nothing usable at Hillsboro or anywhere else I have been. Someone asked me to find them a nice No. 4 plane and in two years I haven't seen one of these either that was not encrusted in rust.

If you need tools and don't live where Todd lives, where ever that is, get used to buying new tools or dealing with pits on old tools. Collectors/dealers can afford to be patient, but people that need stuff to make stuff can't

Re: Ol' Draw Knife....

#4

Simply Amazing

Todd Hughes

>I went down to the big flea market in Hilsboro Va. a few years ago..is a whole day drive but I went with a friend and we got a room with some of her friends. I have to be honest I really find it hard to believe that you couldn't find a common tool like a paring chisel there! This thing is huge and I saw...and bought LOTS of tools. Matter of fact one of the things I hated about the place was that we had to park so far away I had to carry everything I bought. I had a burlap bag I filled up mostly with tools that I carried around till I found a dealer I knew where I could leave it.

..Actually bought a rather no nothing no.3 Stanley that had a nice Bed Rock lever cap which was the only thing I wanted so took it and the blade off and tossed the rest in a trash can so I didn't have to carry it around. Dealer I bought it from [for $10] went over to the can and fished it back out and looked at me like I was crazy

Most of what I was buying I was buying to resell so you got to know I got the stuff for a good price if I hope to resell it, same as to condition...I wasn't buying any rusted rough tools. If the place wasn't such a long drive I would love to go again as I did very well buying

Year or so ago I drove cross country from Denver Co. helping a friend move. We took our time and stopped in a bunch of Antique shops along the way...man I saw LOTS of good tools.In many ways more then I see around any of the Antique shops where I live [Md. eastern shore] I couldn't buy as much as I would have liked because I had to take the train back from NYC and was limited as to what would fit in my back pack...was hard leaving that nice Disston 112 saw back in Denver

...All this reminds me of the time I was at a show down in Tenn. set up selling some old tools. Guy comes up with a Draw Knife he is buying and tells me he has been looking for one for years but where he lives they don't have any tools and how lucky I am to be someplace where I can find all these ones. I sell it to him and ask him where he is from...tells me Annapolis Md....which was like 20 miles from my back door

I think I live in a general area [I have to drive 50 or 60 miles really to find anything because I live out in the country] that might be better to find tools in then others...but not as near as good as others either at least judging from my travils. But to say somthing like ... "..old tools-planes, chisels, spoke shaves, saws, etc- not covered in and pitted by rust are rare. Yes, very rare. " ... Come on now , are you really telling me a tool like a draw knife or stanley spoke shave that isn't rusted or pitted is a "Very Rare" tool?...P l e a s e !

...Sure some tools are rare but lots are common even in to find in excellent condition. I sell on the ebay and I do very well but I got to think if these rust free excellent condition tools were really "Very Rare" I would do lots better with the ones I sell! I just did a quick look at completed ebay auctions for Draw knives and over 250 of these very rare and hard to find tools came up. Sure lots might be rusty but in my experance selling many in excellent condition most still don't sell for much , Im always happy if I get $20- $25 for a real nice one because most times I can get them for around $5

Going from my experance buying tools for many years and in many places I just refuse to believe that common tools like these are anything but....well common in most parts of the country.....Todd

Re: Ol' Draw Knife....

#5

Survey says...

James Watriss

>I really have to disagree, Bill. There's a lot out there that's usable. I'm not a reseller like Todd is, so I'm not so into throwing things away, but given his context, I think the story of throwing away the rest of the plane makes sense... take what's valuable and don't fill your basement with muda.

But when it comes to worth-while tools, I think the market is pretty open. Sure, some tools take time, but the real thing to bear in mind is that a person who's trying to make things will go out of his way only when he has to, but you're right that it's very hard to find anything that's ready to go out of the box. Even L-N stuff needs a little sharpening when it arrives. Most of my chisels have little issues here and there... a corner I ground too much, and haven't gotten around to straightening out this time around, or something else... everything needs a little bit of attention every now and then. Pits on the back of a paring chisel? Pish-tosh. If you don't want to waste the time flattening, you grind past them when you go back to the grinder with the tool, if htey actually come to the edge. But really, it's not so hard to find serviceable tools. Maybe there's some pitting in the back, but they don't have to look pristine. They just have to work. Really, I've just had a hard time finding 720s and 750s that are still flat, and not rocker shaped on the back, but for bench chisels used for chopping and rough carpentry, this may not be such a big deal.

And decent #4 stanleys are a dime a dozen. They don't have to be immaculate. You flatten the bottom, (which isn't a waste of time) and take some time flattening and bedding the frog. After that, you either make sure the cap iron is in good shape (which isn't hard, it's not hardened steel) or you buy an aftermarket one. Most of my planes have aftermarket teeth in their mouth anyway, so this isn't such a big deal, but even decent SW blades are very, very common, and they're made of good laminated steel, too. Maybe there's some dust around the edges, or surface rust which takes a whopping 5 minutes to clean off. Maybe some of the japanning is gone. Maybe most of it's gone... who cares. The purpose of most of the plane is to hold the blade steady anyway, not to be shiny. Some of my favorites are definitely showing their age. Thing is, though, regular usage puts enough mild wear on any tool to keep rust from building up in all but the most humid conditions.

Good steel, and a sharp edge. The rest is secondary. So if you're having a hard time finding tools that are up to snuff... Maybe you have too much snuff.

Re: Ol' Draw Knife....

#6

Re: Todd's reality check.------WebKitFormBoundary2

kees------WebKitFormBoundary2v945VoJNv+YtMLQ

>you're right Bill, buy one good drawknife (Drew Langsner in USA and Svante Djarv in EU) and

you can drawknife the rest of you're life without worry about . Old tools is just a waste of time for a (hobby)woodworker. Learn to sharpen/maintain, that will give real drawknifepleasure. "Zen and the art of drawknife maintenance".

BTW: using a drawknife and a shavehorse will give a belly like a washboard :-)

Take a look at Brian Boggs :-)

------WebKitFormBoundary2v945VoJNv+YtMLQ

Re: Ol' Draw Knife....

#7

Things you learn

Todd Hughes

>on the computer...lets see so far today I have learned that even though I see plenty of them good old draw knives are really very rare tools and that you can spend two years looking for an elusive and also very rare nice number 4 Stanley plane which I also see bunches of. Old tools are a simply wast of time for a wood worker...and oh yes using a drawknife will give you a belly like a washbord!

Might be somthing to all this after all, I used to use a draw knife alot and my belly sort of looked like a washing machine...but then I used one of those non existant old draw knives.....Todd

Re: Ol' Draw Knife....

#8

Now that is a RARE one ! *LINK*

Todd Hughes

>Just did a search for that Drew Langsner fellow and his draw knives he sells....well at first it just looks like a rather avarage midling quality tool but I soon saw it is in fact one of those for sure very rare examples...hey had to be since it is priced at over $200 !....and for that it doesn't even have ferrules or end caps like a good Witherby you can buy all day long for $20

Only thing I wondered about how does anybody order those things while wearing a straight jacket?....Todd


http://countryworkshops.org/drawknife.html

Re: Ol' Draw Knife....

#9

Re: Now that is a RARE one !

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Todd,

In the fine print, they say you can get the ferrules for an added $150.00. Or just buy one for only $85.00. S&H extra.

Marv

Re: Ol' Draw Knife....

#10

Re: Simply Amazing

ThomD

>The best drawknife I ever bought was for about 25 canadian, and I guess I was just lucky, it was at an antiques sale in a mall. It was also my first. It has a weak point in it, so it always worried me as to how well it would hold up. I later bought a new one by Barr, their small carving knife. Best drawknife out there, short of the 25 dollar one. I think for a modern full time maker, or even a long term user like me, there is something to be said for a decently priced tool that can be replaced and won't break, run out etc... It's like the first and second hand car issue. A second hand car is always cheaper, but not necesarilly a better value, depends what you value.

Barr now seems to have a chairmaker's unit, but I would have to be very sure it was actually an improvement over their carver. Sounds like a hollow ground, planer blade type, in which case, yuck. The carver is really right.

http://barrtools.com/Merchant2/merchant.mvc?Screen=CTGY&Store_Code=BST&Category_Code=DK

I am at a doubtless sub Todd place, but I know where he is coming from. Once you get tunned in, stuff comes at you like a freight train. Manifesting like an SOB. I have the same problem with machine tools these days. I got offered a German double head mill, and a very nice lathe for about $200 C bucks each. That's stunning. But there is a cost to getting there that vastly exceeds the cost of a few 125 dollar drawknives.

Re: Ol' Draw Knife....

#11

Re: M-WTCA

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>If you think good old tools are rare, you need to go to a mid-west tool collector's meeting. I think good tools are getting a little bit harder to find as time wears on, because a lot of people are sitting on a lot of tools. I am thinking of the set of 6 750's I bought for $9 with the label still on the handles. A rare and unusual find, but the only reason I found them is because I learned how to look for tools. That particular find was at a local auction. To find tools you have to cover a lot of ground and only look where it counts, which takes some experience and is a learned ability. Something like fishing; you can waste a lot of time fishing over water that doesn't hold any fish, you need to find the fish first and then fish for them. Wearing jeans with holes in them helps more than you know.

P.S. Yes, I am feeling fine. The medication seems to be helping.

Re: Ol' Draw Knife....

#12

Re: Ol' Draw Knife....

John L. Blue

>Goodness gracious, keep'em outta the scrap pile, amazin' you'd

do such a thing, especially if they still work, like the one I

got, sometimes looks are deceiving. Blue

Re: Ol' Draw Knife....

#13

Re: M-WTCA

ThomD

>The experience part costs you. I had this need of a milling machine table to fixture stuff for welding. I eventually found one when I asked some friends to help out. The friends were some guys I had met while buying 3600 dollars worth of old iron over various purchases. Over about 5 years of looking and 1 year of getting on the inside. I now find stuff that is ridiculously cheap. But the experience part costs you. Admitedly the 3600 bought three of my earlier tools one of which would have cost me 2800 dollars to buy in a taiwanese substitute brand. So it didn't cost me much, but guys on the sidelines won't gain the experience or make the contacts. While anyone can scan the LV website.

Also old machine tools are in many instances better than new ones. That isn't really the case with hand tools. Some are superb, but tend not to be cheap. The cheap ones can be great workers, but often have something wrong with them. 20 years ago, even ten years ago, there wasn't a full complement of new tools of high quality available, but we have vast choice these days.

Re: Ol' Draw Knife....

#14

Glad to hear you're doing well, Moses

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I always appreciate your optimism and willingness to be openly emotional about your relationship with your dad; reminds me every time of the best times with mine.