We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I have built a corner base cabinet out of cherry with an edge glued 4/4's solid cherry top. I have used my new Veritas #4 Smoothing Plane to surface the top. I was hoping to finish the planed surface without sanding it in order to achieve the clearest and best appearance possible for the nice grain pattern on the cherry boards.
The planed surface contains about a dozen tiny ridges from the edges of the blade even after I rounded the corners of the plane blade as recommended in the Veritas documentation for planing wide surfaces. The shavings from the planing were fully across the width of the plane for the most part, and were between .001 and .002 inches thick. The surface is flat and smooth except for these darned ridges.
>Did you just knock the edges of the blade off, or put a slight camber on the blade?
I have my smoother set up so the edges of the iron, when sighting down the sole, "disappear" into plane body on each side. The amount of camber is slight, as you still want to take a wide shaving, just a shaving that is tapered to nothing on each side. This is how I have all of my non-joint making planes set up. The thicker the shaving the plane takes the greater the camber. So my fore plane has a good amount, my try less, and my smoother just a small amount.
If you just round off the edges, but leave the blade square you end up with little gutters -- you're feeling the blade tracks on your surface.
Dean has the answer--you want a little camber, even on a smooth plane.
However, there is one more thing to check. I believe your plane has an adjustable mouth, so that there is a gap in the sole of the plane, just in front of the mouth. Make sure that the planing marks are not being caused by something which has become trapped in the groove ahead of the mouth. Or by a burr on one of the metal edges. An easy way to test this is to retract the blade a bit (so it is no longer taking a shaving), and see if the plane is still leaving tracks on the wood. If it is, you need to fix, however, still do what Dean said.
>The guys are right, you do need to camber the blade a bit. Some people think this is a gentle curve across the whole of the blade, but I tend to think that it means curving the corners back enough that they can curve up into the sole of the plane, and leaving the blade straight. Probably not needed for me to say that, but I'll do it for the sake of making sure my description is well-understood.
Next thing, though, is to take a minute to pay some attention to the set screws on either side of the blade. Most planes these days have a lateral adjust, which allows you to pivot the blade in one direction or another. BUT, that doesn't necessarily say anything about where the blade will pivot. So what can happen is that the pivot point is a bit too high up, and the blade isn't really up high enough, and you end up retracting one corner just as you stick the other one out. But those two set screws will hold the very end of the blade still, and ensure that the pivoting action happens there, and it will be much more precise. You still need to be careful about your adjusting when you get down to fine smoothing, but those screws will help for just that reason.
Set the plane to take the finest shaving you can. Then try to take a thinner one. Once the shaving is only coming up through one part of the mouth of the plane, then you can really get good use out of the lateral adjustment mechanism, and try to get that blade really even.
Last but not least, and someone has to say these things...
-I'm assuming, with all of this, that your edge is actually straight, and not concave, from domed sharpening stones. If it's concave, there's almost no way to get a smooth shaving that doesn't have a corner sticking intot he wood.
-I'm also assuming that the wood is flat. If the wood is slightly concave, then again, one of the corners, at least, is foing to dig into the wood.
>Thank you all for the excellent feed back. In setting up the plane I have been very carefull to make an accurate lateral adjustment to the screws to prevent one edge of the blade from digging in. I also have checked the surface with an accurate straightedge and can detect no measurable concave shape to the surface.
I believe my problem lies in the fact that I do not have gradual cambered relief on the corners of the plane blade, but a more angular relief. I have been using a Veritas MK II jig for sharpening the blade on waterstones. I try to keep the waterstones flat. I am familiar with how to make a jig to grind a gradual cambered edge on the blade, but after grinding it, how can I get a good honeing on the primary and microbevel? Is it strictly by hand on a cambered edge?
Well, here's one thing to remember. Because the cambered bits come up and away, they don't have to be as pristine and super sharp as the rest of the blade. Their purpose is not to cut, but in fact to NOT cut.
Lee valley makes a cambering attachment for the mk II, I believe. And if you're happy with the amount of money you've spent so far, and see no need to spend more, I suggest you try holding the blade by hand, and see just how easy it is to gauge the angle by hand. Opinions vary, some folks like to simply bear down on one corner. Others, like myself, think that drawing the blade back, and lifting the other corner a bit, will be good enough to round those corners off. You may be able to do this in the jig, too, well enough to get the job done. Cambering is not a skill in itself... it doesn't have to be pretty. It's just a way to keep the corners out of the wood.
>I think that for a smoothing plane you want a much more subtle radius than you can get with a grinding jig. Not an 8 inch radius, but more like a 15 foot radius or something. We do this freehand by leaning to one side or the other on the stone. We judge the amount of curvature on the iron by how it cuts, not by direct measurement. You might be able to duplicate this uneven pressure with a honing jig.
The problem with just rounding the corners, as mentioned in many books, is twofold. One is that one rounded edge could be cutting deeper than the other and you might have trouble seeing it. With a more evenly rounded iron you can see if the angle is off by how well your shaving is centered in the plane. The other is that with an evenly rounded iron a slightly crooked iron simply results in a slightly off center cut, with no digging in. A slightly crooked iron that has only extreme corners rounded is not only harder to detect but does more damage as well.
>As others have said the amount of camber needed is tiny. You can get the camber with your honing guide, no grinding needed. Put your blade in your guide and put all your pressure on the right edge -- hone until you turn a burr. Feel the burr, it should only be turned near the edge you were putting pressure on. Repeat on the other side of the blade. Once you have burrs on both the left and the right apply pressure just to the right of center for a few strokes, repeat with a pressure just to the left of center. Finally just a few strokes in the center. You'll end up with a slight camber. If it isn't enough (check by planing as Warren said) concentrate on the left and right edges of the blade while honing again. There is enough play even with a honing guide to achieve this minute camber.
>I've found that the best edge shape for my purposes falls between "rounded corners" and "cambered blade." I like the middle 80% or so of the edge to be dead straight so that even a VERY thin shaving will be almost full width. The edges of the shaving should taper to nothing in a gradual way so that the planed surface of the wood has only the most subtle tool marks.
Some years back I used a flatbed scanner to record and measure the shape of the corners of smoother blades. The image below is the guide I ended up with. It shows the corner of a blade that drops back by .005" over about 1/8" in width. This is enough that a shaving of .003" or less will have edges that taper to nothing. I'd recommend making the overall edge relief .010" as an added margin. I create this shape freehand using a grinder and it doesn't have to be precise. The guide is just a target shape to shoot for.
Doing the edge relief on waterstones took too long for me, but I'm working with blades 3/16" thick made of high-alloy steels. I judge the shape by eye with my eyeglasses removed (I'm nearsighted) which gives the effect of wearing reading glasses. I think you'll find this much easier than it sounds if you experiment a little, looking at the edge shape and then seeing how it works.
That is amazing if I understand you correctly. You have been able to create a camber/relief of .005" on a 1/8" length at the right and left ends of you iron, handheld using a grinder? That seems like it would be very difficult requiring much skill.
>That's right, the shape was created using a grinder and then the edge was honed a little to remove the wire edge.
I wasn't shooting for exactly .005" of relief, I just tried to shape the edge until it looked about right and both corners were about the same. I now do this on my smoothing plane and block plane blades but don't measure, just trust my eye. The real guidance comes from how the blade works in the plane.
My grinder is a Tormek and the corners are shaped using a tool rest that works just like the standard ones on most grinders. The grind angle is adjusted to about 25 degrees and the blade is moved by hand. I start by letting the straight middle part of the blade just touch the wheel, then gently pull back one side of the blade so that the opposite corner is being ground back slightly. With a light touch the shape of the corner is produced gradually and can be checked by just watching it after each few passes across the wheel.
>Steve, you may have forgotten how easily metal goes away on a Stanley plane iron compared to the tools steels.
The steels Steve is using are very abrasion resistant and it takes a significant amount of grinding to remove 0.005" of metal. With light touch passes across the wheel it takes several passes to remove this much metal even with a 3600 rpm grinder (that I use).
>I've been able to use the same technique on my Lie-Nielsen block plane blades (one A2 and the other O1 or W2), although their bevel-up geometry requires a significantly larger amount of edge relief.
I'd guess that whatever combination of grinding wheel and blade steel works well for general blade bevel grinding can work for grinding the edge relief too. The real secret as I see it is using a light touch.
>Roger on the light touch. This Veritas #4 smoothing plane has an A2 iron. I have the choice of an 8" grinder with an 80 grit wheel, or a 1" x 42" belt sander with a microfinishing belt ( 500 grit or 1200 grit).
Of these two, what would be the preferred tool for grinding the slight camber on the iron edge?
>This is an excellent idea, and one I plan to try out.
Paul, you ask, in choosing between two grinders, "...what would be the preferred tool for grinding the slight camber on the iron edge?" Keep in mind that five thousandths of an inch (0.005") is not far off the thickness of typing/printer paper. If you've got even a moderately coarse sharpening stone, you could probably get that in just a few strokes on the stone itself. If I were trying it out myself, I'd try that approach before trying to grind it into the iron - less risk of burning the iron.
Others have discussed putting pressure on one corner of the iron while honing to "tilt" the sharpening jig. I'd try this before getting the LV camber roller, which is designed for, and generates, serious camber across the width of the iron. Every tool has play, and you should be able to generate this minimal difference with the flat roller.
Of course, I say all this, having realized when I got the LV jig that I'm the proud owner of a lot of hollow stones.
>Since I haven't used the 1" belt sander I can't really comment on it, but the 8" grinder with an 80X wheel sounds very good. That's pretty much what I used before I got the Tormek.
After I wrote my previous post I realized that part of my technique depends on the extra-wide Tormek wheel to act as a guide to get the blade edge parallel to the face of the wheel. By just lightly touching the entire edge to the wheel I get a sense of where the starting position is before I draw one corner of the blade back a little to create the edge relief. A 1" wheel is probably wide enough to do this if the face of the wheel is straight. If the wheel has a convex surface (a good idea for other reasons) you might not be able to get this sense of where to start.
Before creating the corner relief I'd make sure the entire edge is straight by honing a slight microbevel using a flat stone. This will show you where the ground surface of the bevel is still too high. When the entire edge is straight you can start grinding back a little on the corners, which will start to remove the microbevel.
I'd like to repeat that my usual edge relief for bevel-down blades is .010" rather that the .005" shown in the scan. It gives a little more margin of error and allows the blade to be used for thicker shavings without leaving serious tracks. For bevel-up blades the amount of edge relief needs to be a lot more.
When the corners are ground back I hone them slightly on a waterstone by drawing them backwards so they won't dig in. These parts of the edge will hardly do any cutting so only the tiniest microbevel is enough.
I'd be interested in hearing how this technique works for others.
>Thanks, Bill! I believe I will "ease into it" by using a waterstone and applying the pressure on the corners to see what can be achieved. I have a course diamond stone that would probably make quick work of it.
>Paul, I have the same scraping plane. I wonder if you've tried using the thinner blade, and put a camber on it with the screw? Theoretically (and I haven't used it enough to know myself) the bowing of the blade will get rid of the ridge problem. Doesn't work with the thicker A2 blade.
I have the Veritas #4 smoothing plane with an A2 iron, not the scraper. I believe the only way to put a camber on this iron is with a grinding wheel, or with some aggressive stones.