Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Purple QSWO?

Posts

Purple QSWO?

#1

Joe McMahon

Purple QSWO?

Joe McMahon

>I asked this elsewhere and didn't get a response that answered the question.

I ordered some QSWO legs from one a vendords. They arrived three weeks ago and I left them wrapped up as my shop is 357 miles from my home. Well, I arrived at my shop last night and opened the bundle. I had 9 legs but two are discolored. They have purple stains on them.

I planed them and got nowhere. Apparently the stain or discoloration runs through the wood.

The bad legs kind of screwed up my project. What is this? I've worked with QSWO a lot and never before encountered this. Will stain cover it?

Re: Purple QSWO?

#2

Re: Purple QSWO?

wilbur

>My understanding is that it's usually the combination of metal, water, and the tannins in the oak that causes the stain.

Stain might help, if you are staining it a darker color. But my guess is that it still will be noticeable.

Have you tried contacting your vendor? You shouldn't have to accept such a piece of wood, especially for QSWO prices.

Re: Purple QSWO?

#3

Re: Purple QSWO?

tek,brunswick

>Try a solution of oxcalic acid. It should remove the stain. It is sold as wood bleach sometimes. It is not the same as the Kleen Strip two part wood bleach. Any good paint store should carry it. It is a powder mixed with water and really more of a stain remover than a bleach.

Re: Purple QSWO?

#4

Re: Purple QSWO?

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>Could it possibly be mineral streak? I know poplar is prone to it but I've net heard of white oak exhibiting such features. I'm curious to see if the oxalic acid helps.

Re: Purple QSWO?

#5

probably an iron stain, return legs

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The wood next to where there was metallic iron, which could have been anything from a nail in the tree to metal banding used to assemble bundles at the saw mill, will cause a stain that ranges from black to bluish black. I would send the legs back for replacement as this defect is not something you should accept.

Oxalic acid will, under some conditions, dissolve the iron from this stain and make it go away. I suppose that anything that will remove iron stains from fabric might work, but I have not tried it.

Re: Purple QSWO?

#6

Re: Purple QSWO?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I suggested oxalic acid on the other forum on Saturday. I'm sure you never tried it. I explained that your stain was iron tannate. I don't know why you say you didn't get a response.

Re: Purple QSWO?

#7

Joe McMahon

Re: Purple QSWO?

Joe McMahon

>When I( said that I didn't get a response that answered my question, I meant the question if I could cover it with stain. I certainly didn't mean to ignore your kind response.

While it probably is some type of reaction to metal, it is not localized like you might have if it were caused by a nail or by a metal band. Instead, it covers a rather large, irregularly shaped area and goes all through the wood. It appears as if it were caused by a liquid by the staining pattern which as I say, goes through the wood almost to the opposite side.

Thanks again for the reply.

Joe.

Re: Purple QSWO?

#8

Re: Purple QSWO?

wilbur

>As far as the stain goes, cut off a small piece of the stained oak and a piece of the unstained oak, use whatever finishing technique you want to try, and see how it works. That's really the only way to see how things will turn out.

The staining reaction from metal can diffuse quite a ways through the oak, leading to a stain that seems quite out of proportion to the amount of metal that caused it.

Re: Purple QSWO?

#9

A picture would help diagnose the problem

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>A piece of iron in the tree will stain for many inches from the nail itself. On the other hand I have seen extremely dark "white oak" generally in species that are included but not true white oak and usually cut from near the base of the tree. To answer your stain question, it is best answered by trying it. Who knows what will suit you. You sure won't make it go away by adding stain. But like a big pimple you might cover it up some with makeup.

Re: Purple QSWO?

#10

Re: Purple QSWO?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I once had a huge white oak beam where the stain was through the wood for 3 feet long at one end, 1 foot wide and at least 8 inches deep. Fortunately the sawyer did not hit iron and neither did I.

Re: Purple QSWO?

#11

Re: Purple QSWO?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>It could also be the iron in the water that caused the stain. If you are going to stain it anyway then you only need to deal with the difference in stain color.

You can try adding a little yellow pigment to your stain to counteract the purple color.

Stephen

Re: Purple QSWO?

#12

should not matter

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>It should not matter what caused the stain. You ordered a product that came to you flawed; the answer is obvious. Surely the vendor's production people are not blind. I cannot imagine they thought this was acceptable to deliver.

If the vendor will not replace the legs, then you might resort to some of the various coverup strategies mentioned, or order or make some replacements. I'd keep asking up the ladder until you talk to someone who cares about your experience.