Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Next Tool?

Posts

Next Tool?

#1

Next Tool?

JDubbs

>I'm just getting started and am trying to figure out what to buy next. Currently I have the following:

Dovetail Saw

Dovetail Marker

Wheel Marking Gauge

Jointer Plane

Smooth Plane

Jack Plane

Set of chisels

Spokeshave

Water Stones

Honing Jig

I figure I need an all-purpose saw for dimensioning purposes. After that, what would you recommend? I realize that a lot of this will depend on the projects I plan to build. At this time, I hope to start off building smaller pieces of furniture in order to learn the craft. I want to make sure that I'm aquiring not only the right tools, but also the tools that I will use the most. I apologize for such a general question. Thanks in advance.

Re: Next Tool?

#2

Re: Next Tool?

Alan DuBoff

>low angle block plane or low angle rabbet plane.

Re: Next Tool?

#3

Re: Next Tool?

ThomD

>Started at what? That isn't much of a list for chairmaking. If one assumes small cabinets, etc...

-Bench

-Scraper and attendant tools

-Measuring tools: 6" square, I like the machinist ones and wood ones. I don't like the half and half ones; Rule, accurate enough to prove stuff; I like marking gages with a blade. I have all kinds the Japanese ones are by far the ost useful, more fence and a blade; tape; caliper in thous.

- Files for sharpening and breaking edges on wood.

- A sellection of viable saws. I would recomend Japanese saws for secondary saws you can get way more saw for the dollar. They get expensive for no difference in the outcome in dovetail sized saws, but at the cheaper end they are way more affordable than the western panel saws. Even if money is no object sooner or later you have a rendevous with a stapple, and when it rips all your teeth off, far better they cost 20 bucks. Toshiros (still around?) had a range of cheap interchangeable saws that were pretty serviceable. Bow saws are another choice, as are antique western saws, though those aren't much fun to blow up either. I bought some Record pull saws on sale, they work great for all kinds of crosscuts. The saw steel in the 200 dollar western saws is just shim stock, so it's an expensive way to get a comodity quality cut.

If you aren't going the bandsaw and planer/jointer route, then you absolutely need a good bench (good not fancy), and will need some wooden roughing planes, and a bowsaw, or you will wear yourself out.

Re: Next Tool?

#4

Re: Next Tool?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>In thinking of a minimalist tool kit, I see two big deficiencies: sawing and mortise and tenon work.

For mortising you need a square, a knife, a mallet and a mortise chisel. If only one I would get 5/16 chisel. For sawing, I recommend an 8 point panel saw and a 12 point tenon saw, both filed rip. These will fit into a larger kit as you gain skill.

I could name a thousand tools (please don't ask me to) which would increase your working capacity, but a block plane would not be one of them.

Re: Next Tool?

#5

Small pieces of furniture? Check this out.. *LINK*

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Mr. JDubbs,

How small is small?

You might try finding a woodworking course or class near where you live. You will not only learn how to, but will learn what tools you need. Approach the world of woodworking gradually.

Also, if you go on Utube and or My Space online, you can see lots of videos that you can learn from.

Do some Googling and do some searches using various words that are woodworking related.

Go on Amazon.com and find a book or two that covers the type work you want to do.

Have fun and good luck,

Marv


Small Pieces of Furniture

Re: Next Tool?

#6

turn you approach around

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Step one is to decide if you want to collect tools, support a life's philosophy and/or build stuff. If you are going to build stuff, get on with it. What you need will soon be apparent.

Most of the tools in my shop that are unused are things I bought thinking I would need them some day. Not only what you build will alter what tools you need but how you decide to build it will change the needs. For example, I have 6 tools to use for assembling face frames. They are a product of the evolution of how I decided to assemble frames that changed with the size of the project as well as my skills and interests. (Anyone need a good hardly used doweling jig or biscuit joiner? ) I would have earnestly recommended each of these at some time yet none of this advice might have been of any value to you.

I was in a class last fall with someone that showed up with every tool Lie-Nielsen sold. He was deluded into thinking that all he needed to make fine furniture was fine tools and a bit of instruction. He didn't come close to finishing the project in spite of heroic efforts by the instructors. He did get a start on the learning curve for some of these tools. I hope he also noticed the differences in the tool types in his tool box vs those that were used in the professional shop where the class was held.

A sobering reality will soon become apparent to you. It takes a lot more skill and experience to make stuff with 18th century techniques than it does with the aid of modern power tools. You may get more satisfaction assembling a hand planed panel but the person down the street with a power jointer and thickness planer will have built a room of furniture while you are learning how to make the the panel. This fact makes important knowing your objectives for woodworking.

Re: Next Tool?

#7

Bob ideas of a good tool set

Bob Demers

>Without telling us what kind of work you do, its very much an openned end question, but will assume we keep this list to be minimalist and cover a broad spectrum of work, IE no specialized tools here.

I didnt see any thing in your list or the others answer so far about making holes.

You will need a drill press, a cordless drill a brace and a hand drill. Either some or all depending on what you do and if you are going blended WW or strictly hand tools. Plus the bits of course : Forstner, split point, brad point, auger bits (center, jennings or Irwin etc)

A good workbench is essential (yes its a tool)

As for marking and layout tools

A good mortise gauge, such as a Stanley No 77, or 79, an antique English rosewood, or a new one such as LV 35N01.01

For try squares, forget the pretty rosewood handled ones, an get a good set of steel machinist ones, accurate, inexpensives and stay square, bonus

For 45 degrees get either or both, a Stanley No 16 and or a Japanese miter square LV 60N03.12

Saddle squares are a great inexpensive way to increase your layout accuracies

Veritas Miter saddle 05N56.15 , Veritas Saddle square 05N56.01

Bevel sliding squares, never enough  But stick to the ones that have a mechanism that enable them to lay flat on both sides

Stanley No 18 Eureka type or the modern equivalent LN 60N20.10

A good marking knife, kerf kadet standard, german chip knife No 8 LN 06D04.08 etc

Saws were well covered so far

maybe add a coping saw and small jeweller saw (modified for dovetail work, a la Rob Cosman)

Edge tools

LA fully adj block plane Stanley No 60 �

Bench plane Stanley No 4 (Type 11 or Bedrock)

Jointer plane Stanley No 7 or 8 (Type 11 or Bedrock)

LA wooden spokeshave, forget antique ones, they often are worned out, instead buy a kit and make your own

LV Wooden low angle, kit, large 05P33.30

Chisels

Besides the usual workhorses, bevel edges set, a few dedicated mortise chisels � and 5/16 (pigsticker style)

A good wacking tool such as LV Carpenter mallet 05E15.01, or the traditional beech ones

One or two (1/4, 1/2 in)cranked handle ones, ditto for paring chisels, and skew chisels, one small Japanese dovetail chisel ( 1/8 or 1/4 in)

Joinery planes

A shoulder plane, a router plane, a few Hollow and Rounds (add as the need arise)

If you have a few woodies which have their blades secured by a wedge, do them a favour and get a mallet/hammer dedicated for such

Card scraper set

Complete LN 05K33.20, or buy just the components as required

A few hand cut rasps, get hi quality ones such as Grammercy (tool for working wood)

Cabinet scraper Stanley No 80

Not neccessary but handy a scraper plane such as Stanley No 12, 212

Maintenance tools

Mill files, triangular files for saws, auger file

Your favorite sharpening system, but make sure to add a leather strop with LV green compound to finish the edge and to keep it sharp as you work

You listed waterstones, get a Nagura stone to use on your finish stone

And for honing jig, regardless of the one you have, highly reccomend the small Kell jig

Learning

Good books, magazine (Pop WW, WW magazine), follow blogs such as Chris Schwarz, take courses, get some good videos (Schwarz, Cossman, Klauz etc) and stick around Wood Central :-)

Disclaimer, I have no relationship to LV, albeit a very satisfied customer, and used their catalog numbers for illustration of hi quality tools such as I own and Stanley Nos refered to the antique ones not the new scrap they make.

Bob, ideas of a good tool set, subject no doubt to argumentation :-)

Re: Next Tool?

#8

Very wise advices Bill

Bob Demers

>

Re: Next Tool?

#9

Ditto

Hank Knight

>

Re: Next Tool?

#10

Re: turn you approach around

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I think the flip side to your approach, Bill, is that a lot of guys get to middle age or retirement age and hit a wall when trying to improve. They have worked a lot of wood and spent a lot of money, but are held back by their lack of hand skills and their power tool way of thinking. Working on hand skills is a lot easier when you are young, and you can avoid having to buy and learn to use all the technology designed to replace skill.

Re: Next Tool?

#11

Re: Next Tool?

JDubbs

>I really appreciate all of your responses. I have a number of powertools (table saw, router, drills, sanders, etc.) and have built a number of projects using primarily power tools. I have built paneling for our dining room and a workbench. Over time, I've begun to appreciate the use and feel hand tools give, along with the quietness and satisfaction. I have never built anything with hand tools alone, but that is where I want to end up. I have the patience and do not expect to turn out perfect projects as I start. I figured I would start with either a tool chest or tool cabinent, as it would be useful and give me a good start.

Thanks again for your responses; they were very helpful. Any other suggestions or wisdom would be appreciated.

Re: Next Tool?

#12

Re: Next Tool?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>I will break the question down by project stages. It matters whether you are starting with roughsawn lumber in 9-10' lengths, or whether you are starting out with S4S boards from the hardwood store. Makes a big difference. This assumes you're starting with roughsawn, but I will show where the starting point is if you're working from S4S. This assumes you're going to make a small cabinet.....I may forget some steps, but this is a general outline:

INITIAL STOCK SELECTION (you have a stack of roughsawn lumber)

1. Jack plane. So you can skin the surface of the boards here and there to check grain and color.

2. 12" combination square. To mark the rough crosscuts. You might want a piece of chalk to identify project parts in the rough at this point, so you know you've thought of everything.

3. Crosscut hand saw. To cut your project lumber to rough length. Saw length not very important; 26" typical, but a shorter saw would fit better into a small tool kit and would never be regretted (see Warren's saw comments). NOTE: Cutting to rough length right here will allow you to maintain as much thickness as your boards will yield. For example, if you were to flatten an entire 9-foot 4/4 roughsawn board, you'd end up with 25/32" thickness just like the hardwood store; but if you cut to length first, you can usually get 13/16" to 7/8" thickness if needed, and it sometimes is on rails and stiles (for instance).

STOCK PREPARATION

4. Cambered blade. To use in your jack plane to roughly flatten one side of the stock, prior to ripping to rough width. I like to do this right at this point, because it gives you a final check on grain and color of the different project pieces. If you've misjudged something, you want to know it right here. A belt sander upside down in a vise is a useful tool for roughing out the camber, starting from a straight-edged blade. About 1/16" to 3/32" of camber would be a good starting place, then adjust over time from there.

5. Rip saw. To rip project pieces to rough width, prior to continuing with flattening and thicknessing. You could do this on your table saw, or else get a 5-6 point rip saw. When I say rough width, I mean to within planing distance of final dimension. NOTE: At this point, or maybe after flattening the second side of the stock with the jack plane, I would let the project pieces acclimate for a few days before six-squaring them. Good place to stop for a weekend warrior.

6. Six square the stock to final thickness. You need a marking gauge--I like the knife type. Only new saw is a finer crosscut saw, 8 or 10-point. Jack plane and jointer are fine for planes. Do any resawing right here. You need a marking gauge. NOTE: This is a good place to stop, and let the stock acclimate one more time prior to commencing with the joinery.

PREPARE FOR JOINERY [This is where you would be if you bought everything S4S]

7. Glue up panels. Use your jointer. Match plane, or go one-board-at-a-time. Need clamps. For the edge joining, a 4-foot level (milled edge) is useful, as is a small engineer's square (like 3").

8. Flatten any panels. Switch to lighter camber or straight-blade on your jack plane. Then follow with jointer and smoother.

9. Plane boards to final width. Jack w/straight blade and jointer.

10. Crosscut/plane boards and panels to final length, if not already done.

JOINERY

11. For M&T's. See Warren's recommendations. Although I think you need a fairly fine-toothed crosscut saw to saw the shoulders. Once sawn, you will probably need to adjust your tenons when first learning--they won't be perfect off the saw for a while, although it is best to go for the money cut, rather than cut fat and pare, even when first learning. Some people like a shoulder plane or other fine-adjust rabbet plane for this operation; others use a chisel; others use a rasp. Rasp is a good thing to have on hand--like a Nicholson 50 for example.

12. For dovetails. You have the saw. And the chisels also I believe. And the dovetail marker. You again need the marking gauge. Get a video on how to do dovetails. Or else a book. I really like Ian Kirby's books on dovetails and other topics; some recommend Cosman's video on dovetails.

CLEANUP AND ORNAMENT; DETAILING

13. This is where everybody recommends a block plane. I'm with Warren on this--just never use one. i do think a smallish smooth plane is very useful. You can do a lot with your chisels, one cabinetmaker's rasp, and some half-round files in various grades. Files are underrated in my opinion/experience. You can use them to detail pin ends in dovetail joints for example.

A spokeshave (flat-bottom to start with) is very useful for a whole range of shaping operations. You can make your own pulls and handles (see Krenov on this, or Greene & Greene type) with shave, rasp, files, chisels, and scrapers.

Scrapers. Get good at preparing and using scrapers. Mixed set from LV is good. These are good for everything from glue removal to detailing carvings and other ornaments. You can prepare them with your files and water stones.

Wiley

Re: Next Tool?

#13

Nicely put Wiley...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Great thread and I really like your final (finishing) touch.

Re: Next Tool?

#14

Next Tool?!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Buy some wood and make something, then you'll know.

Re: Next Tool?

#15

Re: turn you approach around

ThomD

>There is wisdom there, but it also depends on where you are coming from. If a guy is adding tools per paycheck or so he should probably follow something like the advice given. On the other hand we do have folks who are rich and can buy whatever they want, and house it in a massive shop. Assuming they aren't getting carried away with collecting, there really isn't any reason why they shouldn't just mirror everything Franz Klauzs has behind his bench (not all that much anyway) and get on with it. The College of the Redwoods has a list of tools they expect the beginer to bring (actually judging by their app process the folks going there aren't beginers...), and it is a short list indeed. Add to that the bench and power tools they supply and you are good to go.

Every summer I move the shop east, all of it I can carry in a wooden box, and a few crates. I lot of it is stuff I might need for plumbing drywall etc... The woodworking stuff I take is usually, a block plane, a rough plane, a finish plane. I don't take a jointer. A square, a chalk line, gage, measuring tape. A sellection of chisels, rubber maller. Toshiro saw, a joinery saw. It all has to fit into something the size of a milk crate - The carpenter's box Roy built. I can make pretty much anything that comes up, along with some stuff my dad has of a basic nature. I also take a basic greewood kit. Axes, drawknife, spoke shave roll, brace, froe, drills, etc... But the two sellections don't overlap that much.

I'm not sure there is that much advantage to not having the stuff. However, it does take a project to create the urgency I require to learn a tool, much of the time.

The biggest thing I would advise, except it's real hard with woodworking tools, in some parts of the continent: Never buy anything retail. These days I am so past anything new. There are a few tools that I don't want pre 1960, jointer, bandsaw, planer. A few tools that have been designed since that time, like biscuit joiners, and sander planers. Every other tool I buy second hand and old iron. I frankly find that hard with hand tools, there are lots of them out there, but many are not in great condition, and require a whole other set of skill to make right. If you have those skills you could as well make them from scratch. It is weird, but I am so old iron these days, yet I don't really see the value or opportunity to the same extent in woodworking tools. I mean if I could have a Noris or a Hotley I wouldn't feel that torn for the older tool. These days that kind of option does not exist in say shop sized milling machines, the old stuff is the only good stuff. I feel like it should be the right thing to buy all old hand tools, but it isn't what I did, or would probably do if i had to start from scratch. Still look carefully at old tools if you can. For instance I bought all old English mortising chisels recently for a fraction of the cost of new ones. That did work out.

Re: Next Tool?

#16

Experience

roninkokomo

>Take this from a guy who has way too many tools that he does not use. Let your work dictate your next tool. always. You'll know what you need.

Get the very best you can afford.

Re: Next Tool?

#17

In General

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>As you said, you are asking a general question. It can only be answered in general terms. Several posters attempted to answer your question in great detail, but there are still questions of a specific nature that you will need answers to. This thread could go on for many pages and you would still have unanswered questions.

I think Scott said it best "buy some wood and make something"

At the stage you are at, I would suggest that you decide what your skill level is at this time, find some published plans that include a list of tools you will need and the kind of wood required and go from there. There are ooodles of sources on the internet. Once you are started on something, you will encounter problems. When you need an answer to a specific problem, come in here and ask for solutions, methods and techniques. Someone here will have specific answers to specific questions.

Marv

Re: Next Tool?

#18

Bravo and Huzzah

Dave Anderson NH

>Hey Bill,

Your post was one of the best I've read on the subject of hand tools. Would you mind horribly if I copy it and on occasion quote it?

Re: Next Tool?

#19

I agree with everything you said, except

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>#13. I started working as a trim carpenter when I was 16, some years ago, and I couldn't imagine woodworking without a block plane. My wife and kids just gave me the new LV block plane as a birthday gift (one of the big ones - birthdays, that is) and it is truly superb. You can joint with it if you're careful.

Bruce, who grew up with a block plane in his pocket.

Re: Next Tool?

#20

Re: Experience

ThomD

>Makes, sense but it didn't work for me. Just look at all the Ooh Aah threads around here when something comes out. The post views are normally highest for the new tool threads, notwithstanding some really marginal stuff. Wants are unlimited for a lot of people in our culture, and despite having a strong streak that wants to find the simplest way, I also have a strong streak that then runs off in the complex direction, the Japanese, German, English directions, whatever. Reality is my occasionally simple solutions come from having tried all the options earlier in my career.

The real test comes when you get what you need. At that point you either keep on going, or stop buying. I am not sure the rate of initial consumption really maters. Of course there are some things that are relatively useless to the majority. But getting the full basic kit is a no-brainer.

I imagine the guy who bought everything that LN sold as per a post above, probably didn't actually think he was going to use it all. I mean come on, there are some real outliers in the selection: Material choices, nearly overlapping plane lengths. Chairmaking tools, molding plane tools. If you are a chairmaker would you run out and buy the floats? If you are a trim carpenter would you really buy the cane rod scraper and sole relieved block plane. Nope that guy just wanted that stuff.

Let's face it, lots of people do woodwork so they can collect the tools, not collect the tools so they can work wood. People who collect figurines don't even seem to have a conflict on the subject. I used to firmly believe I really wasn't a collector. And every now and again a job comes along that requires tools from all kinds of categories. I remember years back when I had to do the bottom paint on my trimaran, and in order to get access I hauled it into a tree. Used tree steps from bowhunting, and rigging details and gear from rock climbing, a comealong. My spinning wheel project is something like that it uses blacksmithing, machining, welding, brazing, woodwork, epoxy work, woodturning, CAD, etc... So there is the odd day I can look myself in the face...

Re: Next Tool?

#21

Re: Experience

roninkokomo

>Yes to all that, but this sounds like a young kid who wants to work wood.