Re: Woodwork magazine - reading the tea leaves
ThomD
>Good to see you are looking ahead Bill.
Every skill level doesn't have to mean banal junk. There is lots of very beautiful stuff that is easy to make, and there is horendous kitch that is difficult to make. Case in point NYW had an episode (I watch the intros) in our broadcast area today of a side table with a clover leaf top and a triangular shelf. My wife and I each looked at each other and it sent memories of dead grandparents basements up and down our spines. Yet quite a lot more difficult to make than say a tressle coffee table, or any table George Nakashima ever built.
None the less I share your apprehension. I'm pretty much against projects on priciple. I prefer to design my own stuff, and even where I copy I don't need monthly magazines full of projects that I will never build and have no space for. FWW used to be project free, and was far more interesting at that time. Most magazines are designed like Bride magazine - They don't expect most people to last as subscribers more than a year or two, and just cycle the same pap over and over. That didn't used to be FWW, and some others I can think of. The only magazine that has stuck it out in any of the fields I am interested in, is Wooden Boat. Still written with the idea of long term subscribers in mind, though a little rot did creap in, but not much.
It is certainly plausible that Woodwork will remain a good magazine (and it was uneven at best), but it's over either way. It's just a vessel to carry forward a subscription and advertiser list with a new team. It may work out wonderfully, just takes one guy who gets it, like CS, JL, or our own EW.