Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Bench on hiatus

Posts

Bench on hiatus

#1

Bench on hiatus

wilbur

>So I have some green Douglas fir 2x12's from the borg stickered in my workshop. It looks like progress on my bench is going to be on hiatus while I wait for this stuff to stabilize.

I know that the rule for drying is supposed to be 1 year per inch, but I probably won't wait that long. I plan to use drawbored mortise and tenon joints for joining the legs to the top and the stretchers to the legs, so if there is some shrinkage over the long haul, the pinned joints should help keep the joints tight.

Of course, if I run across a good source for some cheap 8/4 dry hardwood, I'll get going on this more quickly. I priced out some 8/4 ash to make the legs at one of the local places. It turned out to be $225 for the amount of wood I need, or 2.5 times the cost of the wood in my benchtop.

Re: Bench on hiatus

#2

Bummer!

Hank Knight

>I hate to get up a full head of steam and then have to stop and wait. You may decide it's worth it to spring for some hardwood rather than wait on the DF to acclimate. Good luck with it.

Re: Bench on hiatus

#3

Re: Bummer!

Christopher Schwarz

>Wilbur,

Did you cut the stock to approximate length? That will make it dry lots faster (most of the moisture migrates out the end grain).

Also, the legs don't have to be entirely dry. In chair construction, wet legs and dry stretchers are a good thing. I've built several benches with legs that were still shrinking. Usually everything is stabilized by the time you finish up.

Chris

Re: Bench on hiatus

#4

Re: Bench on hiatus

R.J. Whelan

>Wilbur ... I had a similar situation several years ago (I had a bunch of green Claro Walnut that was at about 20% MC and I had an order for a dresser). Rather than buy additional material I found a kiln that was willing to take my walnut and dry it with some walnut they were drying - I think it cost me about $20 to get my material to 8%.

Good luck ... rj

Re: Bench on hiatus

#5

Another possibility

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>wilbur,

You could go ahead and build your base out of green wood, it is a pleasure to work as opposed to dry wood. The legs and stretchers can be put together and the mortise and tenon on the stretchers will shrink about the same, so no worries. But don't make a mortise and tenon joint on the top of the legs to affix it to the top.

Instead use a loose tenon (out of dry wood) that fits into a mortise in the top of the leg [you can make an open mortise as well] and into a mortise on the underside of the bench. The leg will shrink around the loose {dry} tenon and be nice and tight.

You don't have an excuse now, get busy. And use hide glue on the green wood this time.

Stephen

Re: Bench on hiatus

#6

Re: Another possibility

wilbur

>Hi Stephen,

Thanks to you and Chris, I've been pondering the issue of green wood legs and dry wood stretchers, which is the situation I'm in now. Maybe I won't have to wait as long as I thought I would to use this green Douglas fir for the legs.

Just one issue I see with your loose tenon idea. The tenon, which would be drier than the leg, would be entering the leg through the endgrain. If the leg shrinks, wouldn't it be really prone to splitting around the dry tenon?

My current idea is to cut integral tenons in the green wood legs to go into the mortises in the bottom of the workbench. The worst thing that could happen is that the tenons shrink over time, which would loosen the joint, but since I plan to drawbore the M/T joint, the pin will still hold the joint together. The worst case scenario is that the tenons shrink so much that disassembling the joint is really easy, in which case I can just add shims to the shrunken tenon and put the joint back together again, in about 5 years, which is when I expect to face this situation. :@)

Unfortunately, I haven't picked up a Crockpot yet, so I think I'll have to keep on with the Titebond III instead of hide glue for the time being. I know I'm just a big disappointment to you. :@)

Re: Bench on hiatus

#7

Yea, what he said...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Bummer, I will wait to see..

Re: Bench on hiatus

#8

Here's an answer for you *LINK*

Ellis Walentine, Host

>Wilbur, I called one of our Woodfinder suppliers and he has old, close-grained, dry Doug fir in 10/4 x 5 1/2 dimension, mostly shorts. It's salvaged lumber, so there will be bolt holes here and there, but that shouldn't affect your workbench legs. If you pick up 24 running feet of this stuff, you'll be able to laminate your legs from two pieces each. He wants $3/bf, so your out-of-pocket will be about $125.

I haven't seen your 2x12s but I'll bet they're flatsawn and fast-growing lumber -- nowhere near the quality of old-growth salvaged fir.

There are other suppliers in Woodfinder, too. I still think it's worth looking for salvaged lumber for this project. I'm sure you can find dry fir 6x6s somewhere if you keep looking.

Ellis

Ellis


Hosensack Custom Sawmilling

Re: Bench on hiatus

#9

Re: Here's an answer for you

wilbur

>Thanks for the tip, Ellis! I'll be sure to look into it.

Re: Bench on hiatus

#10

For shame!

Greg B�tit, Vergennes VT

>"Also, the legs don't have to be entirely dry. In chair construction, wet legs and dry stretchers are a good thing."

Hey, I want him to hurry up and show us the finished project too. And I'm not one to put too much emphesis on achieving moisture equilibrium on work bench construction. But jeepers, Chris, I think you're misleading him on the chairmaking analogy.

In chairmaking it might be desirable for the posts' mortises to shrink down over the rung's tenons (as the tenons swell) in the moisture exchange. (This theory is still debated by the country's top chairmakers.) But the square mortise and tenons in a bench aren't likely to benefit in such an exchange. And if there is a through dovetail in the leg top-to-bench top construction, it's going to probably open up as the leg dries.

Having said that, no wilbur, please don't fuss around waiting for the planets to align and the wood to achieve Complete Equilibrium. You're not using freshly cut lumber here- any dimensional changes will not significantly affect joint soundness. Please press on, it's the right thing to do!

greg

Re: Bench on hiatus

#11

Re: Another possibility

Greg B�tit, Vergennes VT

>No excuse!

A hot plate and a pan of water works. I use a small cashews can for the water pan, and make up small batches of glue in small glass containers like artichoke and spice bottles. Put the lid on them at the end of the day and put them into the freezer, they keep for months.

greg

Re: Bench on hiatus

#12

No shame *LINK*

Christopher Schwarz

>Greg,

I won't dispute the top chairmakers because I ain't one. But I do this all the time in my benches and my chairs. It works.

As I've written before, I use the driest stuff for the stretchers. The slightly wetter stuff for the legs and top. It all evens out.

I first picked up this method from Owen Rein. Read about it again in Drew Langsner's book on post-and-rung. David Fleming showed me how he does it in a class I took (we dried the stretchers in a stove where his wife cooks lunch). I decided to try it myself. It worked great. So that's where I got the idea.

Chris


http://www.owenrein.com/

Re: Bench on hiatus

#13

Re: No shame

Greg B�tit, Crown Point, NY.

>I'm not saying that this concept is not useful in chair making. Green wood in posts, bone dry in the rungs or stretchers. But we are talking about maybe kiln dried parts that have been laying around in the shop Vs. recently purchased lumber that is in a questionable stage of dryness, and much larger joints. I say the two do cases not have much of a correlation, and in this application the comparison is not very pertinent.

greg