Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Need some info on workbenches

Posts

Need some info on workbenches

#1

Need some info on workbenches

Stuart Hough

>I am in the process of assembling the raw materials to begin my workbench. A few questions come to mind. First..what size holes do I bore for the holdfasts? Second...what is the upper limit (as to bench thickness) that will still allow a holdfast to perform as designed?

the reason I ask is that, after looking at Wilbur's bench pics, I'm thinking of using 4x4's instead of 2-by lumber. It seems as though there would be a lot less hassle during the glueup process (if such a thing is possible!) Please let me know your thoughts on this matter. Thanx in advance for all your help.

Re: Need some info on workbenches

#2

Re: Need some info on workbenches

wilbur

>Hi Stuart,

I think all the readily available holdfasts work in a 3/4" hole. The depth of the hole depends on the particular holdfast. I remember reading one time that the TFWW Gramercy holdfast tops out at a benchtop thickness of about 3-1/2 to 4 inches or so. If you have a really thick benchtop, you can get around this by counterboring a larger diameter hole on the bottom of the bench so that the thickness around the hole is what you need for the holdfast to work.

As far as 4x4s vs. 2x material for the glue up, I needed 8 4x4's to make a benchtop that is about 22-1/2" wide. I would need at least 16 boards to make the same width top if I had used 2x material. One limitation to using 4x4s is that you only have a choice of a 3-1/4" thick benchtop. If you want a thicker top, you can get whatever width 2x material you need to make it. For me, I thought that 3-1/4" is plenty thick, even though the Roubo bench calls for a 6" thick top.

Re: Need some info on workbenches

#3

Thanx Wilbur

Stuart Hough

>3 1/4" thick seems to be plenty, especially since I won't have ANY help around if I need to move it! Thannx for the info about the holdfasts...I'm leaning toward the Grammercy units, because of the good reviews, oh, and that other reason...they're affordable. I might have a line on some non-PT 4x4's in my area, so I'm going out today to check on that. Once I get started, I'll post the progress like you did.

Re: Need some info on workbenches

#4

Re: Thanx Wilbur

Hank Knight

>Stuart,

My bench top is 3" thick maple. I initially had a hard time getting Gramercy hold fasts to hold fast, so I roughed up the shafts with coarse sandpaper, and that solved the problem. Now they hold with a modest tap of the mallet. I don't know that I'd go any thicker than 3" for your bench top if you plan to use Gramercys. If you want a thicker bench top, counter bore the holes like Wilbur suggested, or look at the Lee Valley Veritas hold fasts. They are more expensive than the Gramercys, but they have a serrated shank and will hold in any top.

Hank

Re: Need some info on workbenches

#5

Why go there?

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>4X4 stock you have to deal with all for sides so to speak.

Bear with me here.

If you chose 4X6,8 or larger you'll pay a little more but for the wood.

You'll find a lot, LOT less defects in the wood and trust me will be more square also depending on teh grade your looking at.

Re: Need some info on workbenches

#6

Re: Why go there?

Stuart Hough

>Scott, my original plan was to go with 2 by 10's because they seem to stay straighter and would give me some leeway to work around the inevitable knots that are always showing up in SYP.If I go with 14 footers (or longer) I can get 4 boards from each for the top (6.5 foot length) and it will only cost me around $60-70 for the top. After seeing Wilbur's pics, It seemed as though he had a lot less worry about twisting, cupping, etc. using the 4 by 4's. The only problem I'm having with that route is finding a local dealer that has non-PT 4 by 4's in or near Florence, SC. That is proving to be the un-clearable hurdle. No-one around sells them. So now it looks as though I'm back to Plan One. Won't be a problem, just more time involved in making sure it's done right. Thanx to all for your suggestions.

Re: Need some info on workbenches

#7

finding the best lumber

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>"Post lumber" (4 x 4's, 6 x 6's) in these parts is typically sawed from the center of the tree, ie they are the left overs from sawing framing lumber. As such they will twist and split as they dry. Big logs are going to have a better chance of yielding clear lumber than small logs. It takes a big tree to yield a 2 x 12 . So it is reasonable that one can find the best lumber for a bench by looking in the 2 x 12 or 2 x 10 framing lumber pile, especially now when lumber sales are down and better logs are available for sawing lumber rather than using the log for plywood.

The situation must be different for fir, but, I have never seen fir framing lumber sold where I live. However, hardwood is cheap here and one could build a bench of poplar or ash for about the price of softwood if the lumber came from the right source (not Woodcraft for sure). I have picked up hardwood 4' x 4 x 4's used in assembling lumber stacks just for the asking at sawmills and lumber yards.

Re: Need some info on workbenches

#8

Re: finding the best lumber

wilbur

>I think that the species used for framing lumber is highly dependent on where you live. Chris Schwarz extolls the virtues of using SYP framing lumber for making workbenches. As far as I can tell, all the framing lumber in NJ is Douglas fir. I once stopped into an orange borg in Delaware, just over the border. All their framing lumber is hemlock fir.

Hardwood is much more expensive in NJ than framing lumber, too.

Re: Need some info on workbenches

#9

Like I said, depends on the grade...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I bought 2, 12' long 4X6" DF beams. Clear (no knots at all, zero defects) and kiln dried as well. They weren't cheap but not over the top either about $100.00 ea.