Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

*** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

Posts

*** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

#1

*** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

Ellis Walentine, Host

>Well folks, things have been pretty hectic around here the past couple weeks as I attempt to break in a new computer without breaking everything else. In the shuffle, my Ides of January question never materialized, so we don't have much time to log our answers. My deadline is in about 10 days. Once again, we'll be excerpting your answers for our bi-monthly column in Woodwork Magazine.

This time, the topic is all about change:

1. Are you using hand tools more these days than you were, say, five years ago? If so, can you say why?

2. Have you changed other aspects of your woodworking routines, habits, interests or preferences, and, if so, why? You might have noticed a change in the types of projects you do, or the source of your ideas or supplies or plans. You may have changed the amount of time you spend in the shop or the complexity of the techniques and projects that interest you. I want to know how your woodworking is evolving, or isn't.

There are no right answers here. Thanks to all for participating!

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

#2

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

wilbur

>1. Hand tool use: Yes, I am using hand tools more than I was five years ago, which was none. Mainly because I had not started into this woodworking thing yet. :@)

2. Changing aspects of my woodworking routines, etc.: I find that I have been trying to just get into working on a project sooner instead of doing a lot of over-analysis of my plan. Although when I do that, I often find that I wish that I had done more analysis up front than I did. :@)

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

#3

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

roninkokomo

>Yes More Hand Tools for two reasons. One the physical set up of my shop and the lack of dust control makes hand tool use much healthier for my family. Two I really feel much more intimately involved with the project when I use handtools instead of shoving boards through machines. That is very personal to me. Others have different views. There is also the added element of safety. It really is hard to cut off more than one digit at a time with a hand tool.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

#4

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

Ted

>I also have an exclusively hand tool shop. I don't have room for any machines and don't like the dust and noise of them anyway. I've taken about a year sabbatical from woodworking, but I am just now getting back into it as I have to finish a chest of drawers for my older son before he graduates from college this spring. I just assembled the case last weekend but still need to build the drawers and finish it.

Regards,

Ted

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

#5

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

Larry_Wyatt(Cole's Dad)

>I am definitely using more hand tools than I did five years ago. In fact, I've amassed quite a nice collection of hand tools, both new and antique.

Why have I used them more? Because I practice with them and I feel more 'in touch' with the wood I'm working with them. The sounds, the smells and the tacticle sensations are much better with hand tools and they make the process more exjoyable. For example, I now read grain direction changes much better, I can tell when to scrape versus when to plane verus when to sand. Although it may sound a bit esoteric, using hand tools has taught me to imagine, in my mind's eye, what is happening to the wood when I use the tool.

As a side benefit of using hand tools, and to answer your second question, I have slowed down and I enjoy the process of fitting joints much more now. Slowing down has also made the projects better. The hand tools and slow speed allow me to tweak a project to just the right dimension, while before I found myself 'forcing' things into position.

I'm finding that the longer I work wood, the more I enjoy the intimacy of working with hand tools. Mind you, I still use power tools for gross cuts, but the details come almost exclusively from hand tool work.

Larry Wyatt(Cole's Dad)

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

#6

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

ThomD

>I always use hand tools a lot, but the proportion has increased. I have something like 25 stationary power tools. It is like the triple parking outside a cop shop. So one reason I do more hand work is because I can't get to the power tools. I have pretty much changed over to metal working as far as power tool access is concerned.

I think if you look at the popular topics here it is sometimes projects or techniques but new tools consistently are the most popular. I have moved in that direction with more metal work coming out of the shop. The pay off to my pocket is better if I make myself a bike or a chisel than another bowl. Most woodworkers buy themselves more metal than they do wooden objects, not counting timber. Most of my machine time is spent making myself tools these days, or stuff unrelated to wood.

I also use hand tools more because my time is more divided between the country and the city these days, and I do almost exclusively hand work in the country. Mostly green woodworking.

Hand tool skills are also growing and I think we all seem to be getting to a higher plane. So more time is spent there, and the there is the hand tool stuff. The bandsaw might speed up my sawing out, therefore by definition the un-automated part of the deal is the part that one spends the most time on.

The one thing I do say I will spend more time on every year but it continues to lag, is designing and making stuff. Still too much time spent improving the shop, or gaining new skills, etc... At an earlier stage I would say I couldn't focus on stuff the way some of the people I admire do because i didn't have the tools to do the kind of work I wanted to. But now that I do, I just keep on in the pattern that got me there. It is all fun, just have to keep updating the objective.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

#7

Darrell in Oakville

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

Darrell in Oakville

>1. Are you using hand tools more these days than you were, say, five years ago?

Nope. Same as always. Hand tools 95% of the time. Wood dust is very bad for your health. Many woodworkers try very hard to collect dust at the source, to minimize how much gets into the air. I try to *reduce* dust at source, simply by not generating it in the first place. Hand tools are a great way to accomplish this.

2. Have you changed other aspects of your woodworking routines, habits, interests or preferences, and, if so, why?

If anything, my projects have become simpler and less challenging in the last few years. Mostly due to lack of time. In another 5 years or so I will have more time to spare for woodworking, and then I will take on some more challenging projects.

Darrell

Cubs tonight, Beavers tomorrow, Scouts on Wed, winter camps the next two weekends... Woodworking? wassat?

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

#8

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

Stuart Hough

>Answer to first part is a yes. Why? because after being on Woodcentral fpr two years now, I finally have learned a bit pn how to set up the hand tools and keep them right.

Answer to second part is yes also, but only in that I am trying to DO more, more thoroughly, so I maximize the return-on-investment for the tools and materials I have and use.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

#9

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

Hank Knight

>I started in woodworking years ago watching my father. He was a power tool guy, but I have always been more drawn to hand tools than to power tools. My use of hand tools has increased through my life as I learn more about what they do, how to set them up and how to use them. In the last 5 or 6 years, my hand tool use has increased dramatically because of the internet and forums like Wood Central. Until I discovered the internet, my hobby was a pretty solitary one and my understanding of hand tools came from trial an error - mostly error. The Internet has introduced me to many of craftsmen who know lots about hand tools and my learning curve has become much shorter.

Apart from an increased use of hand tools, the biggest change in my work over the last 5 years has been my growing interest in Japanese tools, primarily chisels and saws. I find them more suited to my style of work and my intellectual interests and I can accomplish more precise work with them than with comparable Western tools.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

#10

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

Al

>1. I'm actually using hand tools slightly less. Thanks to good fortune, I've been able to take more of a blended approach to woodworking, having purchased a tailed apprentice or two to assist with stock prep. (bandsaw and lunchbox planer)

2. Habits have changed and complexity / scale of projects has increased.

Habits - I've adopted a kamikaze approach to project work, wherein I throw my self into the project with minimal planning. I found that, too often, I was stuck in analysis paralysis mode, unable to make real progress in the limited amount of shop time that I have available.

Scale and complexity of projects has increased, as most of my woodworking is done as part of the restoration of my 218 year old house. Historic restoration often necessitates incorporating construction methods of the time to repair architectural elements and execute sympathetic renovations to rooms. In the past year I've produced wide plank flooring, period style cabinets, period style doors, and all sorts of trim carpentry elements.

Al Rossi

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

#11

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

roninkokomo

>I have done so in the past, but I will nor do any thicknessing for a project of any size. I can either go to the planer in my garage, or pay 25 bucks for planer/ belt sander time at my local lumber yard.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

#12

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY +10 ***

Ted

>I am currently trying to summon the willpower to thickness the drawer sides and backs for this chest of drawers with my scrub and jack planes. It will likely take me a couple of 4 hour sessions. But, at least I will get some exercise. My wife will be out of town helping her sister this weekend, so I should have the opportunity to turn on the radio and work up a sweat.