Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Workbench leg glue up question

Posts

Workbench leg glue up question

#1

Workbench leg glue up question

wilbur

>So I was thinking about working on the legs for my workbench, and realized that I had made a tactical error. This bench is going to be a Roubo, and I was planning on using 4x4s for the legs, which would wind up being slightly less than 3-1/2" sqaure. Problem is, the plans I'm working from call for legs that are 5" square. At first I thought, "Who cares if the leg is 5" or 3-1/2 inches square?" and so I would just use the 4x4s as they were.

Except that I then realized last night that for this bench design, in addition to providing support, the legs also make up clamping surfaces, and I'd go from a leg vice that's 5 inches in width to a leg vice that's 3 1/2" or less in width. I don't think that the leg thickness matters that much for the sturdiness of the bench, but I can see how clamping would benefit from a wider surface.

The cheap and easy way out of this is to just glue a wider board on the front of the 4x4s, sort of like a T shape, but it's my bench, and I'll have to look at it. So 5" legs it is.

I've come up with a variety of ways to do the glue up, which are in the picture. They all seem to have some pros and cons.

A would result in the neatest appearing leg, but I don't know if I have to worry about the leg splitting over time with movement if I encase the 4x4 on all sides.

B allows me to use the 4x4 stock that I have on hand without having to go buy wider boards. It's also the ugliest.

C would be a little easier than A, and still has a relatively neat appearance. I'd have to go buy additional wider 8/4 material to do this.

D is the easiest to do, but I'd have to go buy even more additional wider 8/4 material than in option C to do this.

My question is, which would you choose? Myself, I'm leaning towards A. I know I won't mind the extra gluing steps, and as I said, it will be the neatest appearing out of them all.


img

Re: Workbench leg glue up question

#2

Re: Workbench leg glue up question

Ray Binnicker

>Hey Wilbur,

I've been reading your progress with your bench, with interest. I agree with "A" as the best looking choice. And, since you are concerned about "looks" (as I would be), perhaps consider mitering the boards you are going to wrap the 4x4's with. And, will this additional size give any additional strength to the legs? If not, and you are concerned about movement, would it be possible to not actually attach the boards to the 4x4's but attach them to themselves and allow them to "float" around the 4x4's? Just food for thought.

Ray Binnicker

Re: Workbench leg glue up question

#3

Re: Workbench leg glue up question

Paul in NJ

>Hi Wilbur,

I would use option E or F!

E. Buy some 6x6 stock from your local bandsaw mill sawyer. They might take a long time to dry. Find some salvage timbers?

F. Laminate (4) 2x6 DF boards. Borrow as many bar clamps as you can. Buy 12 footers and cut them in half lengthwise, that would make 2 legs per lamination. If you need clamps, I have 2 dozen you can borrow. I can bring them to the next CJWA meeting.

Paul Dzioba

Re: Workbench leg glue up question

#4

I Agree With Paul

Hank Knight

>Wilbur,

I would worry about expansion and contraction issues with your DF 4X4 core if you wrap it to get a 5" square leg. I think Paul's sugestion to laminate two pieces of 8/4 X 6" DF to get the width you need is the way to go. No worry about expansion and contraction issues. I laminated my 4" X 4" bench legs from two pieces of 8/4 oak and they have been just fine. Also, while I'm not familiar with your design details, it seems to me you could use three of your 4" X 4" legs and laminate a fourth wide one for your leg vise leg. I don't think it would look odd to have the leg vise leg wider than the others. If you forget about symmetry, you could make your leg vise as wide as you wanted it.

My $.02.

Hank

Re: Workbench leg glue up question

#5

Re: Workbench leg glue up question

Dave Anderson NH

>hi Wilbur,

How about option H, going with the original plan for the nominal 4x4s. Even with a leg vise, the main clamping area you are going to use is at the edge of the benchtop. This surface is the thickness of the top and the length of your bench. Once you get below the top thickness you still have 3.5" of clamping width which I figure is plenty.

Re: Workbench leg glue up question

#6

Re: Workbench leg glue up question

Charles

>The leg to which the leg vice is 'attached' needs to be tenoned into the workbench top. You need leg thickness in order to do that (but not every leg has to be this thick) and you need a three inch thick top, minimum in my judgment.

Re: Workbench leg glue up question

#7

Re: Workbench leg glue up question

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Wilbur,

How do you intend to join the legs to the top? As I recall, the original Roubo bench had thick legs that were both through-tenoned and through-dovetailed into the top--each leg post had a tenon projection and a dovetail projection. As Charles says, for this to be effective, you need the fat legs.

Is there a wrecking salvage place anywhere near you? If so, it would be worth a call or visit to see if they have some salvaged timbers that would be suitable. Short of that, I like Paul's idea. If you do go with Paul's idea, and if you do use the original tenon-and-dovetail join, then each leg's two projections could be solid boards, not glue-ups (you might prefer the look of the solid board).

Wiley

Re: Workbench leg glue up question

#8

me too

roninkokomo

>This is too biog a deal to you to compromise now.

I am for Paul's or Wiley's idea

Re: Workbench leg glue up question

#9

Re: Workbench leg glue up question

chuckbeck in cent il

>I built a SYP Roubo this summer and I found some 2x10 x 20'!! at the local lumber yard that had been there forever. They were ready to go and I know you are not using such a light pine, but when I did my leg glue ups, the Schwarz laid plans for 4 glued up board with the middle two forming tenons and this really made leg building easy.

chuckbeck

Re: Workbench leg glue up question

#10

Further to Wiley's suggestion...

Ellis Walentine, Host

>.... look in Woodfinder under Salvaged lumber. There are a lot of outfits, all over the place but particularly in the Pacific Northwest, that sell salvaged timber. On the East Coast, many of these timbers are yellow pine and even heart pine. Out west, they have lots of cedar and fir. If you chat some of these guys up, I'll bet they'd rough out four legs for you and ship it to you UPS.

Just a thought.

Ellis

[Disclosure, in case you didn't know: Woodfinder helps subsidize WoodCentral.]

Re: Workbench leg glue up question

#11

Thanks, everyone!

wilbur

>Thanks for the input! After seeing the error of my ways, I stopped off at the borg on the way home, and found a couple of 2x12s that ought to do well for making these legs, once I have them cut down to size.

Re: Workbench leg glue up question

#12

Re: Thanks, everyone!

ThomD

>You do need to concern yourself with wood movement. The general rule with the scale of lam parts you are doing is no piece larger than 3/4" thickness. That is the truth. The other truth is that you can often get away with anything. I would rip pieces to smaller dimension and glue them up. You still run a risk with pieces 1.5" thick. But it will probably work, I have an 18' strongback glued up in that format for 30 years.

Re: Workbench leg glue up question

#13

I agree

Adam Cherubini

>

Re: Workbench leg glue up question

#14

I'll chime in here too. Wiley...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I thinks a majority vote forming here...