Workbench leg glue up question
wilbur
>So I was thinking about working on the legs for my workbench, and realized that I had made a tactical error. This bench is going to be a Roubo, and I was planning on using 4x4s for the legs, which would wind up being slightly less than 3-1/2" sqaure. Problem is, the plans I'm working from call for legs that are 5" square. At first I thought, "Who cares if the leg is 5" or 3-1/2 inches square?" and so I would just use the 4x4s as they were.
Except that I then realized last night that for this bench design, in addition to providing support, the legs also make up clamping surfaces, and I'd go from a leg vice that's 5 inches in width to a leg vice that's 3 1/2" or less in width. I don't think that the leg thickness matters that much for the sturdiness of the bench, but I can see how clamping would benefit from a wider surface.
The cheap and easy way out of this is to just glue a wider board on the front of the 4x4s, sort of like a T shape, but it's my bench, and I'll have to look at it. So 5" legs it is.
I've come up with a variety of ways to do the glue up, which are in the picture. They all seem to have some pros and cons.
A would result in the neatest appearing leg, but I don't know if I have to worry about the leg splitting over time with movement if I encase the 4x4 on all sides.
B allows me to use the 4x4 stock that I have on hand without having to go buy wider boards. It's also the ugliest.
C would be a little easier than A, and still has a relatively neat appearance. I'd have to go buy additional wider 8/4 material to do this.
D is the easiest to do, but I'd have to go buy even more additional wider 8/4 material than in option C to do this.
My question is, which would you choose? Myself, I'm leaning towards A. I know I won't mind the extra gluing steps, and as I said, it will be the neatest appearing out of them all.



