Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

What good is a #6?

Posts

What good is a #6?

#1

Joe McMahon

What good is a #6?

Joe McMahon

>Another thread mentions that there may be minimal interest in a #6 plane because it is between a smoother & a jointer and therefore not have a real place. I believe that Patrick Leach feels that the #6 is worthless.

What is a #6 used for? How do you use your #6? If you have a #6, do you also have a #5 & #7 or#8?

Re: What good is a #6?

#2

plenty

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Joe,

The No.6 is the plane that UK and Australian cabinetmakers are trained to use in a professional basis. Either the No.6 or the No.5 1/2. This is training based upon experience over the last couple of hundred years.

Continental (German) cabinetmakers that I've worked with also use the same planes - the smoother that they use if a 4 1/2, also the wider-bladed variety.

The width of the blade is a deciding factor, as is the extra weight over the No.5

Adding weight to this is that the traditional wooden plane is about 18" long, about the same as the No.6 You don't see too many planes about the same size as a No.5 in wood.

I'd contend that the large amount of No.5 planes available vs the smaller amount of No.6 planes second-hand from the turn of last century is due to the fact that there are a lot more builders than there are furniture makers. The No.5 plane is a lot lighter and easier to carry around, as you would if you were a builder. As well, the No.5 is all you need to ease a door in, etc...

As well, the plane sold as being a 'jack of all trades' would have had appeal to the handyman market in the 1920's/

Being honest, the only plane I've touched in the last year is a No.6. We're trained to use it from rough stock (ie: off the saw, not rough sawn,) through to smoothing. As a tradesman, you should be able to plane a piece of timber straight. If not, then you just drop a shaving onto the bench under the 'low' point of the timber, and then re-plane if you're on finish prep.

The No. 6 is used to:

cut chamfers

joint

smooth (skewed heavily if needed to reduce the apparent plane length)

plane flat.

remove wind.

any other planing job.

Trust that this makes sense. I use a small block plane (Veritas cast job that I picked up last year) to do the small arrises. Before this, I'd use the No.6 or a chisel/sandpaper depending on the size and length of the job.

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: What good is a #6?

#3

Re: What good is a #6?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Great answer by Andrew!

Couple more thoughts.....If one looks at a series of Stanley bench planes, 1 through 8, they're all straight-bladed, and you get the idea that the only differences among them relate to their length and width. Because that's what comes out of the Stanley box. And they give them names--a No. 5 plane is called a jack plane and a No. 6 plane is a fore plane, for example. We look at them, scratch our heads, and figure "I get it, a jack plane is a 14-15" plane, and a fore plane is an 18" plane".

Back in the days of wooden planes (and some of us still like them), jack planes and fore planes weren't just different lengths than smooth planes or jointers--they were set up differently as well. Jack planes and fore planes had cambered blades--sometimes heavily cambered. The cambered blade was, and is, very useful in the flattening of rough-sawn stock, back in the day when there were not machine jointers or planers in every shop.

Over time, the metal fore plane, the No. 6, has morphed into a short jointer or an all-around bench plane as Andrew describes. But at one time, particularly in the days of woodies, the fore plane was an 18-20" plane, had a cambered blade, and had a specific role in the preparation of rough-sawn stock. Jack planes had a similar setup, and indeed, the distinction between jack and fore plane has varied over time, and by country.

In any event...Even today, if one is of a mind to flatten stock by hand, rather than machine, a No. 6 with a cambered blade and mouth opened up is an excellent tool to use. It's long enough to flatten, heavy enough to plough through high spots, and can be cambered to take a moderate bite, or a deep bite, according to how one wishes to work.

Wilbur recently was describing his flattening of his new Doug fir bench top. He used a No. 5, and cambered the blade in the historic manner, so as to work more easily and efficiently. No. 6 is equally good for this task.

The notion that a No. 6 doesn't have a place because it is neither short nor long, comes about because some have forgotten (or never knew) the historic role played by the cambered-blade jack and fore plane.

Wiley

Re: What good is a #6?

#4

Thanx Andrew and Wiley!

Stuart Hough

>Both of your posts have brought forth really good info about the #6, so much so that I won't be selling mine, now. I finally have an understanding as to what it is used for and how to set it up. That ebay find might just turn out to be a jewel after all!

Re: What good is a #6?

#5

Re: What good is a #6?

ThomD

>"The notion that a No. 6 doesn't have a place because it is neither short nor long, comes about because some have forgotten (or never knew) the historic role played by the cambered-blade jack and fore plane."

Sounds good to me, you are probably right. I find that kind of thinking confusing in my world though, because the metal planes really function in a different world than the wooden ones, promising adjustability in mouth opening, for instance. Wooden planes traditionally were more specialized, while metal planes were sold on proportions and everything else could be adjusted to suit use. Also metal planes exist in the machinery age so they really don't function on the same premise of roughing etc... that the wooden ones did. I think we sorta operate in a fantasy world we discover new/old things about tools and then backdate the new revelations across the whole field.

This is probably a poor story to raise here, but it impacted me. I have some 1937 metal lathes. To me they are better than current (non-CNC lathes) in every way. In some ways more up to date for the 21st Century home shop. In one online discussion someone mentioned that my lathes with the screw on chucks (as on woodworking lathes for the most part), could never make a buck after 19xx with the advent of a cam on chuck. I don't like cam chucks, but it was the voice of someone who has been running machine shops for decades, and it is the reality vs. fantasy. Likewise in a lot of cabinet shops the Beismeyer fence is prized not because it makes much sense on a design basis, but because the half fingerless workforce that drives up on choppers with a skin full every morning, can't break the dang things. That is the kind of reality that pushes tool purchases at times.

I think if one is imagining the curved plane blade world, a world that is mostly a rediscovery of recent years, we should be asking why it disappeared, not what it tells us about big-iron age plane choices.

None of this should get anyone to buy or sell a 6 today. I am reminded that Krenov calls planes of that length jointers. Jointing is mostly a mater of how the plane is used not it's size, or at least the size could vary depending on the pieces being jointed. I have a plane designed and set up to joint pieces of wood 22 inches by 8 inches. Both length and width are factors in jointer format.

Also, on weight alone a variety of sizes are useful. Back 25 years when I was flattening tables with a Record No 7, a 6 would have been a pick me up, if I didn't have the sense to use something even smaller.

Anyway that is just how it looks to me. I don't want to be guilty of reinterpreting history through my history either.

Re: What good is a #6?

#6

Re: What good is a #6?

Marc in sunny Luxembourg

>So, metal handplanes are an anachronism in your eyes, especially those for the coarse task as is the scrub and the fore plane? Do I understand that right, Thom?

Marc

Re: What good is a #6?

#7

Re: What good is a #6?

Dean J in MN

>Others have done the old #6 justice! I'd just toss in -- I think a #6 makes a fantastic try plane. Prior to switching to woodies my #6 was my goto try plane. A little short by wooden try plane standards, but easier to use for long periods than a #7.

I think the #6 is a great plane in a blended shop. Set up with a gentle camber (i.e. as a try plane) you can work wonders with it. I really can't see the place of a #5 in a blended shop for example -- too short to make a decent try plane, and one really doesn't need a roughing plane in a blended shop. Of course most #5 planes I see are set up like "panel smoothers" not at all like a jack, so that may explain their popularity.

My advise -- snap up all the #6's you can before others realize how useful they are!

-Dean

Re: What good is a #6?

#8

Re: What good is a #6?

Bob Demers

>What is a #6 used for? How do you use your #6? If you have a #6, do you also have a #5 & #7 or#8?

Well yah! I have a 2, 3, 4, 4 1/2, 5, 5 1/4, 5 1/2, 6, 7, 8 and a 'few' more :-) Yah, I know, I suck :-)

Do I uses them all ? well uhhh...of course (disclaimer, in case my wife read this :-)

All the serious points raised so far were good, but lets not forget that first and foremost, Stanley (the Microsoft of its days) were in the business of selling tools. In order to keep selling tools, they had to constantly come up with new ones and modify existing designs.

Does that means that every ones they produces were usefull or purposeful? Of course not. I honestly cannot foresee a uses for my complete collection of Stanley bench planes (missing the No 1,I know)

Nonetheless, I have truly uses them all at one point or another, because they are there..

Some I prefer for the width, their weight, their lenght, the size of their totes. But no one really 'need' all of them. But having such a variety of sizes, is bound to accomodate all users, regardless of hands sizes and method of work.

Therefore in the end, using a No 5 or 6 as a 'scrub' be-fore other planes, or a No 6, 7 or 8 as a jointer is mostly a matter of personal preferences, not much more in MHO

Bob, who can't honestly justify owning a No 1

Older pic, No 5 1/2 missing from line up, that shortcomming has long been rectified :-) They are all fettled, sharpened and in use


img

Re: What good is a #6?

#9

I love mine...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I have mine (a 606 actually) set up as a panel plane (i.e. a big smoother). Works wonders on large panels. My 505.5 is set up like Dean's as a try plane.

Re: What good is a #6?

#10

current practise

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi All,

Just to add to Thom's post, we were trained to grind all blades flat, except for smoother blades, where the corners are relieved to remove the track.

To remove half of the width of a piece of timber that you're working on, run the plane over that half only.

Must rush, busy morning here today.

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: What good is a #6?

#11

My head loves the 18

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>I have a Stanley 6 and a Millers Falls 18 (the same thing) and have them fettled for different jobs. I have three MF 14s (Stanley 5 clone) and haven't even fettled them yet after six or seven years. I very rarely use the 14s. But I'm gonna. Yes siree, I'm gonna. Some day. Soon. You wait and see. Don't call me wierd just because I like my MF 18. Like I said. I've got 14s too. I'm not strange. Not me.

Re: What good is a #6?

#12

edge vs. face

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Andrew,

I believe you are referring to edge jointing, based on your new thread up top.

Just by way of clarification, my reference to cambered blades in this thread has to do with using the No. 6 with cambered blade for flattening the face of roughsawn stock. Not for edge jointing.

I would add, though, that when starting with roughsawn stock, it is not unusual to also start with an edge that is not ready for the jointer, but rather the edge (just like the face) requires some initial stock removal (flattening) before using the jointer. Cambered blade is a good forerunner to the jointer in that situation also. IME.

Wiley

Re: What good is a #6?

#13

agree

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Wiley,

You pegged it - didn't want to derail things here.

I agree with your experience.

Andrew

Re: What good is a #6?

#14

Re: What good is a #6?

Greg B�tit, Crown Point, NY.

>Hello, my name is greg, and as you can see from the picture, I have a Millers Falls problem. The #6 is my favorite size. Or #18 I should say. That's the one with the curlie hanging off the front knob. Millers Falls numbering convention parallels the rough length of the plane. I have two #18s, one is hidden away from sight so that people don't think I'm wierd. One is set rank, the other is set fairly fluffy. Lately the fairly new-to-me #15 (5 1/2 size to you Stanley folks) has been taking the fluffy's spot in the lineup.

It's been too cold to get out in the shop, the stove is willing but the locust doesn't seem to be up to temperatures it's been up against. Had a few hunks of maple in it just before Christmas and mister man, it burned hot. I'm puzzeled, locust is a pretty dense wood- it lasts, but it doesn't burn very hot.

greg


img

Re: What good is a #6?

#15

Re: My head loves the 18

Greg B�tit, Crown Point, NY.

>Uh, Patrick... maybe there's a support group out there for us somewhere.

greg

Re: What good is a #6?

#16

Hey, At least here 18 is legal...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Now if you'all start talking that a 16 gets you 20 is another story...

A smoother won't get you a jointer so to speak...

Re: What good is a #6?

#17

Apple wood will give you the most BTUs

Bob Demers

>

Re: What good is a #6?

#18

Looking at your picture...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I say is pretty damn cold in your shop.

Re: What good is a #6?

#19

Re: What good is a #7 if you have a #8?

wilbur

>I've never understood the maligning of the #6. It seems like a perfectly nice plane.

I've seen many discussions of whether to get a #7 or a #8 as a jointer plane. Lots of discussion as to which one is better, but everyone seems to agree that they both have their place.

So why doesn't the same apply here? It seems to me that the #6 can work as a decent jointer if you don't have the arm strength for a #7, or as a super jack plane instead of a #5 if you've eaten your Wheaties, assuming that the blade has the appropriate camber for the respective role.

Re: What good is a #6?

#20

Agree, couldnt No 1 to 8 all get along?

Bob Demers

>

Re: What good is a #6?

#21

English tradition

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Joseph Moxon (1683) mentions Fore plane, strike block, jointer, and smoother. Richard Neve (1736) has fore, long, jointer, smoother. Peter Nicholson (1831) has Jack, trying, long, jointer, smoother. David Denning (1890) has jack, trying, jointer, smoother.

And now Andrew F (2009) has #6 plane for everything from rough stock to smoothing and wants us to think this is part of English tradition going back a "couple hundred years"? Perhaps fifty years is more likely.

Re: What good is a #6?

#22

Re: Looking at your picture...

Greg B�tit, Vergennes VT

>Hi Scott,

The thermometer doesn't give much resolution down there below the negative mid-teen range, so it would be hard to say exactly how cold is was in there when the shot was taken. Cold enough, anyhow.

greg

Re: What good is a #6?

#23

Re: Apple wood will give you the most BTUs

Greg B�tit, Vergennes VT

>I was thinking of that, what with the orchard down the road cutting all their big trees because they're too hard to harvest. (Yeah, that seems incredible to me too.) I'm going to have to see if I can get my mits on some of that. At least enough to make some mallets and totes and saw handles and...

greg

Re: What good is a #6?

#24

Re: Apple wood will give you the most BTUs

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I spent days with a friend some years back on the same mission - Sebastopol was famous for years for an apple variety that's one of the best in the world, during the 15 minutes between almost ripe and beginning to rot, but, in the modern world, durability during transport is a basic requirement, so many of the orchards came out during the 1970s and 80s, to be replaced primarily by wine grapes.

Don't be surprised if a lot of those trees are hollow, or punky except for a few inches near the cambium layer. Apple is not a durable wood in the weather.

It may differ in snow country - our winters are wet but also warm enough to be Rot's Riviera.

I hope your experience is better. It's a lovely wood.

Re: What good is a #6?

#25

Thanks for the summary, Warren.

Andrew F in Australia

>Appreciate the thoughts.

Agree with your comments. The difference is modern stock comes off machines (and what I'm referring to,) whereas the range of planes you describe are what's used for working rough sawn stock.

Thanks for the summary.

Best regards,

Andrew