Re: What good is a #6?
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Great answer by Andrew!
Couple more thoughts.....If one looks at a series of Stanley bench planes, 1 through 8, they're all straight-bladed, and you get the idea that the only differences among them relate to their length and width. Because that's what comes out of the Stanley box. And they give them names--a No. 5 plane is called a jack plane and a No. 6 plane is a fore plane, for example. We look at them, scratch our heads, and figure "I get it, a jack plane is a 14-15" plane, and a fore plane is an 18" plane".
Back in the days of wooden planes (and some of us still like them), jack planes and fore planes weren't just different lengths than smooth planes or jointers--they were set up differently as well. Jack planes and fore planes had cambered blades--sometimes heavily cambered. The cambered blade was, and is, very useful in the flattening of rough-sawn stock, back in the day when there were not machine jointers or planers in every shop.
Over time, the metal fore plane, the No. 6, has morphed into a short jointer or an all-around bench plane as Andrew describes. But at one time, particularly in the days of woodies, the fore plane was an 18-20" plane, had a cambered blade, and had a specific role in the preparation of rough-sawn stock. Jack planes had a similar setup, and indeed, the distinction between jack and fore plane has varied over time, and by country.
In any event...Even today, if one is of a mind to flatten stock by hand, rather than machine, a No. 6 with a cambered blade and mouth opened up is an excellent tool to use. It's long enough to flatten, heavy enough to plough through high spots, and can be cambered to take a moderate bite, or a deep bite, according to how one wishes to work.
Wilbur recently was describing his flattening of his new Doug fir bench top. He used a No. 5, and cambered the blade in the historic manner, so as to work more easily and efficiently. No. 6 is equally good for this task.
The notion that a No. 6 doesn't have a place because it is neither short nor long, comes about because some have forgotten (or never knew) the historic role played by the cambered-blade jack and fore plane.
Wiley