Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

More thoughts on Wilbur's bench

Posts

More thoughts on Wilbur's bench

#1

More thoughts on Wilbur's bench

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I have been putting the hours in at the bench the last couple of days (dining table for porch) and my thoughts are with Wilbur's bench. My bench is 7' long. I nearly wrote earlier that I rarely use more than 4 or 5' of it, "used" being defined as where the wood is being worked. However, I realized these last couple of days that while I rarely "use" more than 4-5" of it, I have stuff sitting on the rest of it. This stuff are the tools and things I am using for what ever I am using to work on the wood. Bottom line, I would find useful whatever length of bench I had.

Even at 7' my bench doesn't hold all the tools needed at the time. There is a constant flux of tools from storage to bench and back. I came to realize that for my style of work that the most important factor in bench location is that it should be within arms reach of the tool storage. In my case my tool storage shelves are within reach behind the bench, as well as under it.

So I pass these observations on, for what ever they are worth.

Re: More thoughts on Wilbur's bench

#2

Re: More thoughts on Wilbur's bench

Dean J in MN

>Bill --

Do you make moldings with hand planes?

My 8 (+ a few inches) foot bench is *just* long enough to run a single piece of molding and have it be long enough to wrap a "typical" case. If you stick moldings you want your bench long.

If one never makes moldings by hands perhaps a 6 foot bench would work. But don't chop your benches short if you can fit a longer one in your shop!

-Dean

Re: More thoughts on Wilbur's bench

#3

Re: More thoughts on Wilbur's bench

ThomD

>I noticed you mention only using 4-5" of the bench. Had that been me it would have been a Freudian slip. My bench is always storing stuff, but I wish it weren't so, and I wish it weren't on the wall either. But as with you that is where I store tools, and it is all the space I have.

I think that 7 feet plus is a minimum length. I guess the exception being if one has several benches, as I do, when I can find them. I make boats, moreso in the past, though I wish I still did. There the full length of the wall bench, not just for storage, is great. My standard cabinet size is about a foot longer than the height of one's ceilings, and in posh, potential client or our own homes these days, that is a 9' ceiling as the new standard.

If I did lot of molding I would want a 20 foot bench minimum. It would be a plywood stress skin. To me the 8' piece of molding is a lumberyard thing. I haven't tried it, but I assume one could have a shorter bench and just work a molding over it with some clever fixtures.

The one problem with bench envy is that there are all these books and articles on benches and such. A bench is just a trestle holding a beam, with a table attached, and usually a vise. It is worth keeping in mind that these parts do not have to be combined and sometimes work a good deal better when broken out into more specialized pieces. There is a picture in one of Roy's books of a sash maker working out of doors on a purpose built bench that might at first be mistaken for a piece of pole fencing. Just beautiful.

Re: More thoughts on Wilbur's bench

#4

Re: More thoughts on Wilbur's bench

wilbur

>Hi Bill,

I'm quickly coming to the same conclusion. I was working on a cutting board and some other small projects over the past couple of days. I was surprised as to how quickly I used up all eight feet of my benchtop.

My inclination right now is to figure out a way to keep all eight feet of the length of my benchtop in my shop space. I think I might be able to do it.