Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Panama Clock Project--glue problems

Posts

Panama Clock Project--glue problems

#1

Jack Guzman from Maine

Panama Clock Project--glue problems

Jack Guzman from Maine

>A year or so ago I started this project.I'm building a replica of a particular clock designed by Seth Thomas co..I built a rough prototype out of pine with simulated(as in roughly executed) moldings and accessories.I posted pictures of the prototype back then.

I just got my shop cleaned up to the point where that project can be completed.The head piece is made up of a lot of small pieces.Most of these pieces will depend on the stickiness of hide glue to hold them together.Clamping isn't practical in most cases.This a picture of some of the pieces before gluing.


img

Re: Panama Clock Project--glue problems

#2

Jack Guzman from Maine

The problem

Jack Guzman from Maine

>I glued up the prototype with liquid hide glue.I had planned on using hot hide glue for the real thing.I got a rival hot pot,cut a hole in the top and inserted a glass jar.I mixed equal parts(by volume)of Behlens dry ground hide glue and water.I put a candy thermometer in the water and heated it up to 145 deg.Then noticing my glue wasn't hot yet I put the thermometer in the glue. Got it up to 145 and brushed out some glue,quickly spread it on both sides and rubbed them together and then held for a moment til it stuck. I let it cool abit and tested the pieces.They came easily apart and no glue had adhered to one side.Plus there was a skin on top of the glue in the jar. I decided that I don't have a clue and proceded to put all the apparatus away.I glued up the head piece using liquid hide glue and it worked nicely.

What I need is more information. Is there a hide glue guide for idiots? This is my third try at learning this myself using little bits and pieces of information I've picked up here.

This is a picture of my setup.---Jack


img

Re: Panama Clock Project--glue problems

#3

Re: The problem

Michael Holden

>I had a similar problem with the first hide glue granules I tried.

Bought a fresher batch,and the difference in consistency of the glue is amazing! The fresher stuff works just like all the how-to guides say it should. So - get some fresher stuff and try again.

FWIW, my first batch came in a plastic container, the second in a metal container - maybe the plastic let in air and it dryed out?

Oh, most have a packing date stamped on the container - packing, not expiration.

Mike

Re: Panama Clock Project--glue problems

#4

Jack Guzman from Maine

The head piece

Jack Guzman from Maine

>There's still one molding missing from the picture.It will be a small shelf on either side with an ovolo under it.

Re: Panama Clock Project--glue problems

#5

Jack Guzman from Maine

I forgot the picture... 

Jack Guzman from Maine

>


img

Re: Panama Clock Project--glue problems

#6

Re: The problem

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Jack,

The glue needs to be 145 degrees, the water in the jacket will be higher. Also the glue may have been too thick and it sounds like you didn't put the glue on both surfaces of the joint which is important.

If the joint chills before it gels (Hot Hide Glue), then the joint won't hold. So it is important that your pieces are warm so you don't shock or chill the glue as it is applied.

Just try making it thinner, keep it warm and wet both sides.

Stephen

Re: Panama Clock Project--glue problems

#7

Re: Panama Clock Project--glue problems

Paul in Nj

>Hi Jack,

I can only think of a couple of things. Your glue might have been a little thick. It needs to be thin enough to run off your brush in a continuous stream. Keep adding water a little at a time until it reaches that consistency. The other thing that I can think of is that it is pretty cold up there in Maine in the winter. You need to have a warm shop or at least warm up the wood. If it is too cold, the glue skins over or gels up before the second piece can be wet out by the hide glue.

Try a couple of test pieces on scrap wood and let them dry over night. In my experience, hide glue takes a longer time to build up its strength. Then break them apart to how strong the glue is. I don�t have a lot of experience with hot hide glue but I like it more and more and think it is worth learning how to use it.

Paul Dzioba

Re: Panama Clock Project--glue problems

#8

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: The problem

Jack Guzman from Maine

>Stephen,

I think thinner is the answer. I'll try that.---Jack

Re: Panama Clock Project--glue problems

#9

Jack Guzman from Maine

shop heat

Jack Guzman from Maine

>I keep my shop at 60 deg. in the winter. I'll try heating the wood up abit besides thinning the mix. I'd love to have this work. Thanks---Jack

Re: Panama Clock Project--glue problems

#10

Agree

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>with all that Paul said, and particularly about maintaining heat in the Maine winter.

Jack, can you get a portable electric heater, or else a heat gun, and direct the heat into your work area? Plus, as Paul and I think someone else said, the thicker the glue the faster the grab, but also the faster it will skin over. You want the glue stream to flow off the brush, but in a stream, where the stream does not break into droplets.

I have a Hold Heet heater, where small pieces can just be dipped in, brought out dripping, and joined straight out of the pot. Hide glue is an easy clean up, so neatness doesn't matter as much as getting on with it, and getting both surfaces wet (as Stephen keeps saying).

Wiley

Re: Panama Clock Project--glue problems

#11

shouldn't have been a problem

Robin Corellin Atascadro CA

>dry hide glue ganules do not go bad. You may have had two different gram strength products and this the difference in performance, particularly if you mixed both with the same abmount of water.

Robin

Re: Panama Clock Project--glue problems

#12

mix ratio

Robin Corellin Atascadro CA

>I use 192g hide glue and mix 1 cup dry gound glue with 1.5 cups water and then adjust it by adding a bit more water once it is hot and mixed. This is roughly a 1:1.75 ratio by weight. I will sometimes heat the glue to 155* when the shop is cold and I am doing a large glue up.

Robin

Re: Panama Clock Project--glue problems

#13

Re: Panama Clock Project--glue problems

ThomD

>I mix it this way: I prefer if the pot is of the correct size that the contents aren't too spread out. I actually got good results with baby foot containers and the baby warmers. I have the big heated pots but am not sure they are peferable. I put the granules in, say, the baby food bottle, about 1" worth, then I cover with enough water for the level to be 2". It sits overnight. I drain off any free water, and cook at moderate heat. mix well, add tiny amounts of water to adjust the consistency. Never failed to work for me. You can't buy anything too weak to bond the stuff you are doing. Guitar makers use the weaker stuff, and their loads are way up there compared to a clock.

Re: Panama Clock Project--glue problems

#14

Jack Guzman from Maine

Definitely a heat problem

Jack Guzman from Maine

>I went back into the shop and tested all the glue lore I just learned. Added some water and heated it back up.It takes a long time.I tried for a steady stream but the glue cools too quick. I put the lid on and the glue warms up quick.Take the lid off to check temperature--instant cooling,the top skins over. I have to either heat a small space(maybe my painting room) to do gluing or confine my hide glue working to the warm weather. I don't want to pay for the fuel to get the shop warm enough just to use glue.Thanks everyone for the help. Hey Stephen!How's the glue book coming?---Jack