Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

OCD much?

Posts

OCD much?

#1

OCD much?

James Watriss

>So, I was futzing yesterday with an old Stanley #4 that I tuned up years ago, and while I remember it performing flawlessly, I picked it up yesterday to note that the lateral adjust lever had the blade skating around at the bottom end. Workable, yes, but still, in my mind, I think it could be better.

Flash forward to today, when I found myself at the drill press with said #4, the appropriate bits, and taps, to install set screws, one on either side, to keep the business end of the blade centered in the plane, and to make the lateral adjust more predictable. I discovered one thing... I need shorter set screws, 1/4" turned out to be too long. 3/16", or 5/32" long would be better. And some thread-lock, too.

I know Lee Valley has done this with some of their BU planes, but I was surprised to see myself retrofitting this sort of thing on a plane that I used to consider a stand-up user.

No shop time for me tomorrow, I don't think. But come Monday morning, I think I'm taking the blade to the wet grinder, to get everything up to working speed, and see just how well this setup works out. If it's a hit, I think I may end up trying it on a few other planes, including an old Bedrock or two.

After that, I'm thinking two pairs of set screws for a dedicated serious smother... two for the front end, and two more higher up, to handle lateral adjust that way. Only for the dedicated finish smoother, though... lateral adjust is too valuable for anything that might one day end up truing an edge.

So, the question... have I gone off the deep end here? Or should I carry it to the next level, and do handles and paint or powdercoating* to bring old stanleys up to a crazy high level of precision, like Wiktor Kuc and his eggbeater drills?

*I know, old planes were japanned. I'm talking treatment to take old planes, and make them new. Hock blades and such, and paint or powdercoating seems like a good current-day technology that would be a good, durable coating. I'm not interested in restoration of priceless antiques, I'm talking more about bringing the antique plane to a modern day audience, and getting them to as good a condition as I can with what's available now.

Re: OCD much?

#2

So, the question... have I gone off the deep end h

Bob Demers

>Yup! :-)

Seriously, i really admire what Victor is doing to the venerable Millers Falls hand drill.

Never been a fan of over restauration, but these MF drills are still plentiful, and he does such a great job. Im tempted to send in my early No 1.

Lets face it, most of us here, accumulate tools not as an edge against the recession, but to put them back to work. Im sure Victor's work as well if not better as the day they left the factory.

And that my friend, is the end game isnt it?

We have high end planes, saws, chisels, and now hand drill. Life is good

Bob, who still think that the deep end is so near...:-)

Re: OCD much?

#3

With apologies to Wiktor Kuc, I misspell his name

Bob Demers

>

Re: OCD much?

#4

Re: OCD much?

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>It's just me, perhaps, but a question comes to mind:

Don't you have any real work to do? Like build a table, or a chair, or a jewelry box, or a bed frame or something?

Futzing around with old stuff, I suppose, is for folks not trying to start a business.

Of course, I could easily be wrong. Heck, it wouldn't even be the first time this evening. ;-)

Re: OCD much?

#5

Re: OCD much?

James Watriss

>Well, old stuff is part of the game, I do still have a use for hand tools. The original complaint was that I couldn't get the stupid thing to adjust in a predictable way that wouldn't leave plane tracks on the piece I was trying to smooth up before finishing. 20 minutes at lunchtime with a drill press and a tap handle and voila...

So, lunchtime diversions are, I think, fair game, even for someone who's trying to get going.

: )

Re: OCD much?

#6

Two planes with set screws...

James Watriss

>An old 4 1/2 and 5 1/2


img

Re: OCD much?

#7

Thanks

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I've been thinking lately that adding setscrews to my Stanley Nos. 78 and 289 might be a useful upgrade. It wouldn't make them Veritas tools by a long shot, but being able to register the correct whisper of iron past the body on the side, consistently, would be kinda cool. I could then concentrate on getting the setting at the sole right.

Re: OCD much?

#8

OK Bill...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>If you have both, I feel it's best to ditch the 78.

Not realy needed IMHO. But, I I really felt that way I'd ditch my 78, my 778 (never) and a few others.

Ahhh what am I talking about here anyway...

Re: OCD much?

#9

Get rid of a tool?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Wash you mouth out!

I think I'll hold onto the 78. I have used the bullnose function from time to time, and I like the adjustment for depth setting, even though it's primitive. Maybe after I've gotten to know the 289 better, I'll find the 78 redundant. We'll see.

Re: OCD much?

#10

Please, consider my mouth flushed!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>