Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Cyclone dust collectors and plane shavings?

Posts

Cyclone dust collectors and plane shavings?

#1

Cyclone dust collectors and plane shavings?

wilbur

>As you might have seen, right now I have a lot of plane shavings on the floor of my shop. I'd like to clean them up a bit, but I know from experience that my single stage DC chokes on the long thin plane shavings. I was thinking about getting a mini cyclone separator, but I don't know if that will get choked up with plane shavings, either. All that I've read about cyclone dust collectors focus on their handling of fine dust.

Has anybody used a cyclone to collect plane shavings?

Re: Cyclone dust collectors and plane shavings?

#2

Dominic in Bucks County PA

I have

Dominic in Bucks County PA

>Wilbur,

I built a cyclone "head" that fits on top of a 40 gallon trashcan. This is in turn connected to my DC. Since I don't need the cyclone for ALL my tools (only for those that produce big chips), I have it set up so that I just close a gate and I'm connected to the Cyclone. For my planer, router table and jointer, it works well.

I recently installed a floor sweep pickup (not connected to the cyclone BTW) and have tried to use it in conjunction with my rather limited DC system. It didn't go exactly as planned. Rather than bore you with the details I will tell you that a 4" pipe will clog almost IMMEDIATELY when trying to pick up plane shavings! :>) Needless to say, I'm not using that floor sweep until I upgrade my DC system to a REAL cyclone system (my next project)

If you are going to use one of those trash can cyclone lids, just be aware that your DC will loose static pressure. But I don't see why you couldn't just use one of those at your bench. You just need a length of hose and you could "vacuum" up your area. When you need to pick up a lot of shavings just close a gate and your trash can cyclone can be used. That's pretty much the system I use now since the floor sweep idea went over like a lead balloon!

Re: Cyclone dust collectors and plane shavings?

#3

Oneida experience

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>My Oneida system packs them into the barrel nicely except.......In my system there is a coarse screen , I suppose to keep chunks from damaging the system, and the long stringy ones wrap around the bars and eventually clog it. These long stringy things are so easy to gather that I usually just gather them up and either burn in fire palce in the winter or mulch with them in the summer.

Re: Cyclone dust collectors and plane shavings?

#4

Re: Cyclone dust collectors and plane shavings?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Nope, sure haven't; but I have found that a broom and dust pan work great. Would take a couple of minutes and doesn't take up more valuable shop space.

Pam

Re: Cyclone dust collectors and plane shavings?

#5

Re: Cyclone dust collectors and plane shavings?

Paul Kierstead

>My experience did not go well. The shavings were not heavy enough for their surface area to sink in the cyclone; a better quality cyclone then my barrel + lid may work better.

Re: Cyclone dust collectors and plane shavings?

#6

Re: Cyclone dust collectors and plane shavings?

ThomD

>If you have a screen I would look into that. The screens have three purposes:

1) stop a dust esplosion if a bolt strikes a steel impeler blade. If your machine has plastic or Al blades this is less or maybe no concern. Over 20 years of use I generally stop the stuff I don't want from getting into my machine. But metal has struck metal and so far no big bang. But the main take-away is that new machines are supposed to have 0 spark blades. I removed the grate from my dad's.

2) Stop fingers from getting in there. My hose is permanently mounted so fingers are not going in there anyway.

3) Stop stuff from getting sucked into the turbine and requiring a time consuming disassembly. I guess they could come up with a more easily serviced one, but when free-handing, I don't really suck stuff up by accident any more. If I do, I ground the hole to the floor so it is sealed and then flip the switch. That stops anything from making it up my hose, which is fairly short.

Another option is a cloth bag below, if you have a plastic one. The problem with the plastic ones is that they don't allow the air to move down, and it all depends on gravity. Obviously cloth, even felt bags are not as wonderful as the other kinds, but if/when picking up only big chunks, it isn't the problem to have more open bags, and they will pack the material better. Mine will still move all shavings into the bag, or at least to the shelf above.

I use my dust collector only for dust, and shavings. I do not use it as a vac. I don't mean I don't pic up the floor, I just don't use it for dirt or toxics (other than wood dust). Just a hygene thing, but it also means the bag sellection doesn't have to be hepa, though may be that it currently is.

If you have a really small unit with sub 4" hose, the hose can be the problem.

I had the LV cyclone, and it probably worked fine. I found it too cumbersome for my situation where I need to move it around a 40 foot shop, or used to have to back when I has space.

Re: Cyclone dust collectors and plane shavings?

#7

Re: Cyclone dust collectors and plane shavings? *LINK*

Bob Demers

>Since I move around the country a lot, I need something more portable than a dedicated DC installation. So I make do with a shop vac equiped with a cleanstream filter that I bought at LV years ago. Its made of Goretex and seems to last and last. Has been washed umpteen times too.

Of course, that still overwhelm the shop vac quickly when picking up big shavings and such, so I also installed an LV cyclone cover on a big plastic aircraft soap barrel. I mounted that set up on wheels and just bring it close to the ahem machine in use (would you believe pedal powered? Insert red grin here) or to clean up fluffy shavings.

It does a great job, never jams, and the shop vac goes on forever without having to empty it very often.

Perhaps the secret is that I use it with a short run of hose to where it picks up??

Incidently that cleanstream filter is fantastic at cleaning up the air.

Bob, whose shop doesnt always look like he has dust collection :-)


img

Cleanstream filters