We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I'm planning to build a set of #6 shaker side chairs hopefully to finish before summer. I have Kerry Pierce's new book that is great reference, but I am weighing options on stock. Should I go to the mill and get some kilned hard maple, get a hard maple log and mill and split it out with some air drying, or some other source I don't even know about? I would like to use sugar maple for its strength and to go with some b.e. maple slats, but since I am going to be turning and steaming the posts do I really want KD stock? Plus the yankee in me wants to spend the time, not the money on lumber. I appreciate any input.
>You don't want KD stock for any bending process. It can be pre-set so that it won't bend, or breakage will be higher. In many cases starting with wet wood is ideal for bending. Since the whole deal is getting enough water in there to heat up and plasticize the wood, what better than starting with moisture in place. Steaming is often a part of KD since steaming reduces moisture content by causing the water in the wood to offgas from the wood. So overall you want the water, and pre-KD wood is less bendable, and steaming will get it as dry as it can be even if it was first KD. On the other hand some parts are not made of wet wood or bent and KD wood is fine there.
Splitting is oversold. I think it is wonderful and do it with wood I cut myself. I would do it in certain instances where splitting offers a better yield. The main problem with splitting is that it requires wood of unbelievable quality. Very few trees are perfectly suited, from a mill one needs veneer grade lumber. Structurally it is overkill, because no chair part is designed to work in heavy flex, except a few parts that are not really load bearing. The only structure I know of that need 100% wood are arrows, bows, and fishing rods. Those carry loads under huge flex. Aircraft spars are not made to run-out specs required for splitting chair parts. Run out specs are in the 20-1 range. So a 20" leg would run out 1". Complete junk for a riven project. Riving is also really hard work. Nothing is easier at it's best, but minor imperfection can make for major struggles, and logs that would yield best grade lumber are often a wrestling match to split, and may be as much as 80% waste. The alternative is to match the technique to the wood, and split some of it and saw what doesn't want to split.
I think some of my experience is because the logs I have to work with are a little undersized, say 16" and less. But the larger stuff is a struggle of a different kind.
>Seems you can buy a log much cheaper than the sawed pieces from the retail yard. At least we can here.
We're building Windsors here, and the white ash logs we got were pretty much ours for the sawing costs. There's at least 30 chairs in the parts I've seen.
Now, lifting, cutting, stacking and moving that much wet ash is a challenge for old folks like us. Good thing there are a dozen of us.
>Thank you guys, you make the internet worthwhile. So far I think I'm going to check out the 8/4 stuff, and wait to see if I can find a tree in the mean time. I figure I 've got a month until I've got the time for this to really get going. I prefer to just get to work and fix my mistakes rather than worry about what ones I'm going to make. Thank you.
>Maple is not the best choice for riving or bending, but you probably know that.
If I were making a maple ladderback chair* that had bent back posts I would rive green maple and work it round on the shaving horse.
But Shaker posts are perfectly straight, as far as I know. If it were me making maple Shaker chairs I'd buy 8/4 stock and rip it up into turning blanks. It's hard to get anything perfectly straight when riving. Even the straightest tree will often have some bend over a 3'- 4' section when split out. A small bend will translate to a lot of waste when worked on the lathe. Even with trimming the riving before putting it on the lathe, running an oversized (to compensate, say, for full length bend in the workpiece), unbalanced piece that long on the lathe is more excitement than I would want on a regular basis. My experience is that you often end up with flat spots or undersized posts even when you think you've left enough extra diameter on the material and have juggled the centers to compensate for initial misjugement after making the initial cuts.
If it were me making maple shaker chairs I would try to rive the back slats and work them on the shaving horse. I've never done this with maple, but it is a cinch to make uniform 1/4" - 3/8" thick slats in ash, oak or hickory this way. Maple will likely be somewhat more difficult.
greg
*(Ash, oak or hickory is a much better choice for riving & bending. I have riven and bent cherry with middlin' results, but have only riven maple for chair leg turning blanks (24").)
>is much easier than bending KD as the kiln drying process heats up the wood and sets the lignin.
You can also have a problem if the wood is too green. If the wood has too much bound water (within the cells themselves) it can cause the cells to rupture when bent. The free water in the cell fibers needs to dissipate giving room for the bound water.
There needs to be some space in the wood fibers and cells as the water can not compress and that can cause problems.
>This chair is made by Haley-Daniels, Berea KY. (the seat was done by a neighbor and I did the finish) They told me they have made 1500 of them. They are made from KD commercial lumber. They boil the pieces to be bent. I was told they rarely have failures from bending. When they do, it seems to be from lumber with a particular grain which I surmised was reaction wood.
Conclusions: a commercial shop whose customers won't spend the money to have a chair made with traditional techniques has found that riving stock from green wood is unnecessary. They sell chairs for less than half of what Boggs sells them for. Boggs couldn't make a living in Berea and is trying trendy Asheville.
My butt doesn't care whether lumber is riven or sawed, only the quality of construction, appearance and comfort. These are very nice chairs, successfully made, as best I can tell.
>Yeah unless a real cheap log drops in my lap(driveway preferably) I think I'm going load up some 8/4 and work it. I am very thankful for the advice so far.
>As far as I know Boggs saws a lot of wood. And uses a planer, production jigs etc... He specifically decided at one point that in order to keep the prices of his chairs "lower", he would implement production techniques but only where there wasn't any difference in result, rather than be a guy who did it all ye-oldie style but could only sell to museums. But if a craftsman's rep grows enough he just can't keep the prices low enough to suit those who let their asses alone pick their chairs. When one takes a country craft that grew up around the woodpile, and moves into into a purpose built shop, one will find methods that are faster than traditional ones, even if there is zero change in the end result by any standard. On the other hand I have used some chairs that felt great but fell appart pretty quickly in our current air conditioned and heated homes. It does take a craftsman who cares to milk max strength and weight savings out of a chair, not to mention make it beautiful, and comfortable.
There is stuff that is impossible to split out reasonably speaking, like a 20 foot 1x2 spar cap for an aircraft. Stuff that splits real easy, like pie shaped pieces for a violin. There is stuff that splits really efficiently if you have the right stock but that could be sawn just as well. Horses for courses, but I guess we agree on the fact it isn't some magic technique.
It is also the case that riven poorly parts will run out. It is also the case that any wood that is a pure and easy to riv, at least in reasonable sections, will saw out just a straight sometimes with less waste, sometimes with more.
Some pieces of wood are safer to split, others are safer to saw.
>No, riving isn't magic, but a lot of people don't understand that you can to some extent direct splits in the direction you want.
The rule is to make your splits in the middle of the billet. But if the split heads towards one side or the other, you can bend the thicker "half" while cranking the froe to direct the split back towards the center. Think of it as pulling the split direction back to where it should be.
This is illustrated in basketmaking books, and it works on any piece thin enough that you can bend. For example an eigth of a 15" dia. 4' long log can have the splits influenced this way.
>Greg, That is exactly why it isn't "magic" (well it can be a ton of fun, and when it works it is also really fast). What you are so correctly describing is steering the split. The same thing with a bandsaw, one can steer the cut. So when it comes to splitting creating straight with the grain result (which are not as necessary as the chair fanatics believe) it is a mater of skill and choice, just as with the saw. Where the saw wins is if there is even mild grain trouble, all of a sudden it offers the more control and lower waste. I would far rather split when possible, but to read some green woodworking stuff it sounds as though:
a) extreme grain straightness is required for all chair parts, etc...
b) Only splitting delivers the goods.
What comes closer to being true is that if one wants to hand finish all the parts off tool edges, no sanding, then one needs high drain quality to eliminate tear-out, so back to the splitting as a quality control method (or sawing a piece that was split-worthy if one prefers). The other side of that is Bill's point about what his butt knows and doesn't know. If one wants to cut where possible but will fall back on either sandpaper, or in the Shaker case a lot of lathe work, then the wood quality requirement changes again, and lower quality wood can be used.
>So Brian Boggs wasn't successful in Berea before moving to Ashville. A very interesting interpertation. Perhaps it reveals some of the undercurrents in Berea.
>When I took one of his classes a couple of years back, I heard from a classmate that Brian used to offer internships, and stopped when his trained apprentices went out and used used the same techniques he'd taught them, and undersold him. If it's true, it's a damned shame, and I'm wondering if that's what happened here... surprise, surprise, that it happened in the same town. And moving headquarters to a more trendy area isn't neceessarily an indication that he couldn't make it in Berea. It may simply be good business sense. Go where the money is: Location, Location, Location.
In any event, his is still the name we know. After doing the work he does for... how long? 25 years, last I heard... that, while teaching at home and abroad, designing tools, writing articles, and passing on the craft... I'd say he's been pretty successful.
I went to a lecture Chris Schwartz gave at L-N in Maine, not long after that class. And at the time, L-N was just starting to turn out the Boggs shave horses, so it was natural that Mr Boggs would come up in conversation. And I can still remember what M. Schwartz and M. Lie-Nielsen had to say...
"Yeah, he [Brian Boggs] is pretty much the smartest guy we know."
I will admit a bias. His class was a whirlwind 2 weeks. I've had good teachers and bad teachers over the years. Brian was concise, knowledgeable, and watching him with a tool in his hands was art in motion. Once in a while, you see someone who clearly knows something, and clearly went to a lot of trouble to learn the things he knows. And he was clearly one of those people. Skilled, fast, intelligent, and consummately organized, to fit as much as he did into those two weeks. But very down to earth, open to ideas and questions, and he was clearly as motivated to be a good teacher as he was to be a good chair maker. All that, and he still takes time to go down to Honduras to teach furniture making using tools at hand to the locals, so that they have a means to make money, besides poaching trees... to encourage proper forest husbandry. A master craftsman, an experienced businessman, and a conscientious environmentalist... and an inspiring teacher.
Hard to picture that kind of person being run out of town by local knockoff artists.
>"This chair is made by Haley-Daniels, Berea KY....They are made from KD commercial lumber. They boil the pieces to be bent. I was told they rarely have failures from bending. When they do, it seems to be from lumber with a particular grain which I surmised was reaction wood.
Conclusions: a commercial shop whose customers won't spend the money to have a chair made with traditional techniques has found that riving stock from green wood is unnecessary."
Another possible interpretation: Riving stock from green wood self-selects out pieces that have reaction wood that would cause occasional failures like those experienced by Haley-Daniels.
And not to be too critical of your chair, but the grain pattern in the vertical piece that makes the right side (as you look at it) of the back of the chair could possibly be straighter. It looks like the grain is running diagonally across that piece. My bet is that rived stock from green wood also would have avoided that as well.