Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Mortice chisels, which ones?

Posts

Mortice chisels, which ones?

#1

Mortice chisels, which ones?

Hamish

>Hi there, I posted a question about mortice chisels a few days ago over on the message board but thought would try for more ideas on the hand tools section. So here goes...

My original question was;- Are mortice chisels a necessary part of a woodworkers kit? At the moment I have been making them with a router. Would mortice chisels help in the cleaning up process and if so, what size would be recommended. I have also seen swan neck ones advertised that are supposed to help clean up the bottoms. Are they effective?

From the two replies I received, it seems that mortice chisels, although not compulsory, would help to clean up mortices. Does this mean that one should have a whole array of different sized mortice chisels or would a small selection suffice? Should your chisel be the same width as the mortice you are cleaning up or could a smaller one do just as well?

It would be nice to be able to afford a chisel for every supposed future need but at the moment I would like to just get one or two to get started. Which sizes would you recommend for carcass construction for house furniture? Finally, are the swan necked ones worth buying too?

Thanks in advance for your input, Hamish

Re: Mortice chisels, which ones?

#2

Re: Mortice chisels, which ones?

wilbur

>Even though I might get crucified on this particular forum for saying this, I'll say that mortise chisels are not a critical part of a woodworker's arsenal. You can make perfectly good mortise and tenon joints with a router and powered saws. Frank Klausz, famous for the 3 minute hand cut dovetail and teacher of many hand tool techniques, including hand cut mortises, says that there is no reason ever to cut a mortise by hand when you can use machines in making a mortise and tenon joint.

Having said that, I like making mortise and tenon joints by hand, and to me there are some advantages to doing so over power tool methods, although I feel really weird going against Frank on this point. First of all, there is considerably less noise and dust using a mortise chisel. Second, using a mortise chisel can be a more convenient way of chopping a mortise than using power tools, if you need to make a mortise in a hard to reach spot, since the workholding will be simpler than if you are trying to balance a router on a small area.

You do have to think about mortises a bit differently with a mortise chisel than if you are using powered equipment. They typical advice for a router-made mortise is half the thickness of your stock. For mortise chisels, it's 1/3 the thickness. So for a 3/4" board, you'd grab a 3/8" router bit, but a 1/4" mortise chisel.

So to start, I'd get a good quality 1/4" mortise chisel for 3/4" stock. Some people like a 5/16" mortise chisel for the same task. Then, get wider mortise chisels as you need them for mortises in thicker stock, or make double mortises with your 1/4" chisel. They aren't as hard as you might think. In fact, that's what I have. I have a 1/4" (6 mm, actually) mortise chisel, and a 1" wide mortise chisel that Wiley talked me into getting a while back. I really haven't thought about getting another size so far.

As for cleaning up the bottom, I haven't found that to be a huge issue, as the tenon shouldn't really bottom out on the bottom of the mortise, and no one will see the bottom after the joint is made. There should be a little gap where the glue can go as you assemble the joint, and so the bottom just needs to be roughly level.

Re: Mortice chisels, which ones?

#3

Re: Mortice chisels, which ones?

Roy Anderson

>I've been chopping a lot of mortises (morti?) lately and I find it's a lot of fun. If you're trying to be time efficient, a router is probably the best way to go, assuming you have a volume of morti(?) to cut that justifies the set up time. The few times that I have used a router, I found that a mortise chisel was just the right tool for squaring up the rounded ends.

I have a 3/8" and a 1/4" and may get a 5/16" size. It's hard to imagine why I would need more for my work. I do have a 1" sash mortise which I use for odd jobs from time to time.

Advantages of hand chopping:

* For chopping a couple of mortises, hand chopping is quick and convenient. There is very little set up.

* There is a lot less thrashing of electrons and scattering of sawdust.

* I think I can argue that hand chopping is safer, though you can do a lot of damage with a sharp chisel if you work at it.

* You can do it in a very small shop. My shop is literally 10' by 10'.

* The equipment is smaller and cheaper.

* You don't need elaborate jigs.

* You don't need an elaborate dust control system.

* It's very therapeutic. There's nothing more fun than banging away with a mallet.

Some disadvantages of hand chopping:

* There is a learning curve. Your first ones won't be that pretty.

* For volume mortising, it does take longer.

* If you have joint or muscle problems, the banging with a mallet can be stressful. Ask me how I know this. But a little technique improvement and a little Aleve will solve this.

I was using a pig sticker mortise chisel and it worked fine, but I think it is overkill. Undoubtedly these were intended for heavy structural carpentry. I just bought a mortise chisel from Lie Nielsen that looks to be more useful for furniture making. I haven't tried it out yet. It's sitting on my kitchen table as this is written, calling to me.

I am following the traditional advice to use a 1/4" mortise for a 3/4" board, but this makes for a very thin tenon. I have a few secret floating tenons hiding in some of my work where I had to repair a broken off tenon. Part of the problem there was laziness, for not fitting them up carefully and trying to force fit the two parts together. The reason for the thin mortise is that with a 3/8" mortise, it is not impossible to blow out the sides while chopping. I will probably go to the 5/16" eventually.

I have used the swan neck chisels and I find that they crush the ends of the mortise as you lever out the waste. I use a straight chisel for any levering out of scrap nowadays and leave a little waste at each end of the mortise to be pared out at the last to minimize damage to the ends of the mortise. I think the swan neck chisels were, like the pig sticker chisels, originally intended for structural carpentry. And as I get better, I find that the bottoms of my mortises get more regular and need less dressing out.

Re: Mortice chisels, which ones?

#4

Kinda depends

James Watriss

>If you're having good luck with the router jig mortise thing, then I say stick with it. Mortise chisels are made beefier, I think, for doing the whole damn mortise. I think bench chisels would be fine for just cleaning up the ends... they always worked fine for me for that issue.

That said, there's a wide variety, from big handled pig stickers to regular handled but long Lie-nielsens, to Japanese mortise chisels that are about the proportions of regular chisels, but made beefy. For me, if I had to do it all over again, I think I'd probably get bench or paring chisels for anything over 1/2", and mortise chisels for anything less, since I usually use 3/8 and 1/4 for chopping only, sometimes 1/2, and I only pare and shape with the bigger stuff... and I sharpen accordingly.

But that's if I were going to do it again. At this point, I have something close to a gallon of chisels of all different makes and models... it's pretty retarded.

Oh, and re: the comment above that the bottoms of mortises don't have to look pretty... they don't. But if you want a chisel that will make them so, there's a japanese chisel that was designed for this task.

Re: Mortice chisels, which ones?

#5

OT: "...a gallon of chisels..."

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Is that how quantities of chisels are measured? I always thought some numeric term, like "herd," would be more appropriate.

And, for those not in the U.S. and England, what's the metric conversion for a gallon of chisels?

Re: Mortice chisels, which ones?

#6

Re: Mortice chisels, which ones?

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>I have a different take on this question. I hate using power tools. If you want to use them less then you need mortise chisels. If you don't mind then you won't need the chisel. You can get away with using one chisel. Once the joint is glued up, no one will know what size the tenon was. I have 1/4" and 3/8" chisels and a 1/8" mortise chisel I just acquired and have not used. I have registered mortise chisels, the Two Cherries clones, Lie-Nielsen and an Isles English-style chisel. The Isles bolstered English-style is the best. The large handle fits the hand well and cuts down on muscle pain and CTS. The process is very quick. The chisel needs to be the mortise size you want, not smaller. The Isles chisels are Imperial measurement and not metric equivalents. This is best, unless your other tools are metric. For shallow mortises where the depth needs to be consistent for a number of them I used a small router plane to flatten the bottoms of the mortises. If all you need to do is square the edges of a routed mortise, a bench chisel will do the work.

Re: Mortice chisels, which ones?

#8

Re: Mortice chisels, which ones?

ThomD

>You don't need mortise chisels to clean up mortises. Router mortices should not need any cleaning up. if you prefer to square the ends, that is not a heavy cut and could normally be done with a bench chisel. I have several sets of mortise chisels and they see very little use. But I am glad I have them because they are very stout and work well for certian activities. I never buy/make delicate looking ones, I want something one could hang a car from. I have some Japanese ones, pig stickers I still need to handle, and a few mutant ones. Not a complicated type, make sure they are square.

I used to rout mortices, but I really hate it. It is clearly out of the true capacity of any router I have ever used, and is a tense, noisy and dusty business. I have a couple of milling machines and always imagined they would be wonderful for mortising, but I have never tried them on a full out frame project. I have two power mortising machines and I feel they are required in a low production setting. Some of these are fairly cheap these days, cheaper than a set of good chisels in some cases. Often when one ads up a project it wil contain a lot of mortises. One I did recently had 32. I find hand cutting the tenons is no big deal, but the mortises take a lot of time when multiplied by 32. A well set up shop should probably have CNC with a very stout router with massive bearings.

The advantage to knowing hand chisel work is that it can get into places that machines have a hard time with. This includes extra deep mortises, and mortises, as on chairs, at all kinds of crazy angles. Far faster to just cut these than fritz around with a different jig for each mortice, unless one is making many pieces at a time. Also hand cut mortises are a good exercise and will greatly improve one's abilities in general hand work. Ultimately it can be useful to evolve one's hand work to the point where one becomes like a NC machine, available to get any material out of the way, that can't be handled otherwise. I made this guitar once where I radically overstiffened the composite blace, and had to remove a large donut shaped area of composites to free up the soundboard. I was well into the poject and not anxious to start over, and I was able to dredge out all the material with some careful chisel work. Another case I had to remove some floorboards out of reach of any power tools, and make a neat patch. All pretty simple stuff once one has the basics of cutting to a line and wasting wood with chisels. Making planes are another example.

"* There is a lot less thrashing of electrons and scattering of sawdust."

Very true, but not where hollow chisels mortising machines are concerned. They have their failings also, but seem fairly safe.

* I think I can argue that hand chopping is safer, though you can do a lot of damage with a sharp chisel if you work at it.

I don't know about that. There are not too many ways to hurt yourself with router operations that involved having both hands on the router while it is running, router tables are a whole other thing. As long as one avoids the emasculating lap dance, it is pretty foolproof. A long chisels is just a razor sharp killing knife. drop it on the foot, or stumble on it and bad things happen. I love the somewhat similar situational about two bow hunters who where out for a walk. One was wearing the traditional back quiver. He tripped, took two stubbling steps forward, and walked into an arrow that had fallen from the quiver landing point up (once saw a dog take out his laryx like that chasing a stick). He experienced gushing arterial bleeding, and was probably only saved from bleeding out on the spot by the fact he was with a doctor at the time. It is worth always considering the geometry of tools. Chisels have a wonton capcity to reach the deapest organs, they are like bandsaws, mild manered, but lots of potential.

I would also point out one thing about eyes. Sure you can get a piece of wood in your eye operating a router, but it is easy to protect against it. On the other hand, if you grind chisels or otherwise throw any metal around, you are in for corneal xrays if you ever need a catscan. All hand sharpening would be the best.

Re: Mortice chisels, which ones?

#9

Or 4.55L (makes the MPG sound better)

Andrew F in Australia

>

Re: Mortice chisels, which ones?

#10

Re: Mortice chisels, which ones?  *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hamish

Some of this is a repeat from a week or so ago when similar issues were raised.

I could not imagine not having and using mortice chisels. That is not to say that they are absolutely necessary - you do not need them. But I find so many reasons to use them outside of cutting standard M&T joints, such as clearing waste in half-blind dovetails, a mortice in an out-of-reach position, and general work where others may use a heavy duty chisel.

If I have a lot of mortices to make, and especially in hardwood, I probably will set up a router. But I do tend to avoid this as the noise and dust are my worst. Even when wacking away with a mallet I am able to listen to music in the background.

I tend to use a mortice chisel to finish the ends of chopped or routed mortices. The square (actually trapazoid) end is eaier to keep square. However I was re-watching (re-re-re ...) Jim Kingshott's M&T DVD and noted that he squared the ends with a Japanese paring chisel.

I only use one type of mortice chisel, the Oval (or English) Bolstered type. They suit better than sash or Japanese types. I like the control and power you get from them. Once you get used to a certain type, then you will be able to use them for different tasks - what I am trying to say is that I do not use different types of mortice chisels for large and small mortices. I have a bunch of the OB in different sizes frpom 1/8" - 1/2".

The Ray Iles versions are wonderful. The D2 steel holds its edge a long time. Still, they feel no different to the vintage laminated steel types (I have both), and the latter hold their edge pretty well in hardwood. If you are trying to save money, then look for vintage OB chisels that need to be re-handled (and make your own. This is easier than you think. Link below). Just make sure that the blade is at least 5 1/2" long (longer is better - mine are 7") as the lamination does not run all the way up the blade.

Two Wards flanking a Ra Iles:



The bottom of the mortice does not need to be smooth or even flat. The tenon is supported by the sides of the mortice. However it is very useful to have something to clear chips and projections. I made the following bottom cleaning "chisel" out of a hex/allen key (the handle was just a spare knife handle lying around).



Regards from Perth

Derek


Rehandling An Oval Bolstered Mortice Chisel

Re: Mortice chisels, which ones?

#11

Re: OT: "...a gallon of chisels..."

James Watriss

>I think it's a metric flushload. Not sure.

Yeah... lot of chisels. :)

Re: Mortice chisels, which ones?

#12

Thanks guys...

Hamish

>Many thanks guys for the interesting input. I am soon to be building a built in wardrobe and wash hand basin base that will need various mortices. The face frame of the wardrobe will probably be made out of quite thick stock which will require thicker mortI, and the sink base will need to be scaled down. So once I have decided on the size and construction I will buy myself a couple of mortice chisels to suite and begin my collection.

A look on the lighter side of the above threads, I quite fancy for England, a "flock of chisels" or for the more ecclesiastically minded; "coro de chisi, - a choir of chisels"

Regards Hamish.

Re: Mortice chisels, which ones?

#13

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Or 4.55L (makes the MPG sound better)

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>Oh yeah, the Imperial gallon. Do the UK and OZ still use that, or are you buying your gas in Litres? Just curious.

Jim D.

Re: Mortice chisels, which ones?

#14

Re: Thanks guys...

Greg B�tit, Crown Point, NY.

>"Coro de chisi" would be for the fully sharpened matched set nicely racked together in proper order. The gallon of chisels are the ones stored in an empty paint can waiting for rehabilitation.

greg

Re: Mortice chisels, which ones?

#15

Re: Or 4.55L (makes the MPG sound better)

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Jim,

Our petrol price is still cheap by world standards. About $1.10 per litre at the moment (approx USD2.70 per US gallon)

Bought by the litre.

CHeers,

Andrew

Re: Mortice chisels, which ones?

#16

Re: Or 4.55L (makes the MPG sound better)

ThomD

>I still think in imperial gallons, when I think in gallons. We sell Gas in liters in Canada. According to WIKI imperials gallons are still used in places like Antigua, Belize, Burma (that name isn't current), etc...

Re: Mortice chisels, which ones?

#17

Coming in late, you don't need one.

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Hamish

You asked:

Are mortice chisels a necessary part of a woodworkers kit?

No, they're not. They're a specialty chisel used for cutting deep mortices where you can't get working space to allow you to twist out the chip. Mortice chisels are a prying chisel.

On a cross-grain application such as a mortice, chisels are driven into the job with a mallet and then the waste removed by twisting the chisel, so that one corner of the chisel stays still and the other corner moves and breaks the timber out.

This is the other reason for the octagonal handles on the old Sorby chisels. The octagon gives you better grip for the twisting.

Would mortice chisels help in the cleaning up process

Not really help in the cleaning up process, just using a mortising chisel is quicker than digging a mortice with bench chisels.

... and if so, what size would be recommended.

The exact size if the mortice you're cutting. A 1/4" mortice needs a 1/4" mortising chisel, etc...

I have also seen swan neck ones advertised that are supposed to help clean up the bottoms. Are they effective?

Yes, they are effective, but not necessary for furniture work. They're a specialty tool where the bottom of the mortice has to be flat -> say, for a concealed lock such as the mortice lock used in drawers.

From the two replies I received, it seems that mortice chisels, although not compulsory, would help to clean up mortices.

When I was trained, the cabinetmakers used standard bench chisels for furniture mortices. They're just not as good at taking abuse as the mortising chisels, so they have to be used slowly. Mortising chisels were designed more for doors, etc... Where the mortice on the stile is 6" deep or so by 3/4" wide.

Does this mean that one should have a whole array of different sized mortice chisels or would a small selection suffice?

A small selection is fine - 8mm (5/16") or 6mm (1/4") is traditional on 3/4" stock. The 1/4" is how I was trained on 3/4" stock, but I can also see Richard Jones' point on using 8mm chisels.

Should your chisel be the same width as the mortice you are cleaning up or could a smaller one do just as well?

Yes.

The English tradition is to use the same width chisel as the width of the mortice. The European tradition is to hog out the waste with a smaller chisel while not touching the layout lines, leaving a ragged hole in the middle of the mortice. You then come back and pare down to the exact mortice width.

I was trained both ways. They both work. I'd venture to say that the German method gave a smooth mortice side which would give better adhesion with modern glues (poor gap filling ability), while the English tradition may have worked better with a glue that relied on mechanical keying as the side of the mortice was rough.

Which sizes would you recommend for carcass construction for house furniture? Finally, are the swan necked ones worth buying too?

If you had to buy one, buy the 1/4" or 5/16". No need for a swan neck chisel.

Just to reiterate, however, you don't need one. Standard bench chisels are fine for cutting furniture mortices, just you need to work slower and take smaller bites.

The mortising chisels are quicker, and in the age when time was money cutting mortices, they made perfect sense.

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: Mortice chisels, which ones?

#18

oops - to clear up an ambiguity.

Andrew F in Australia

>Oops, a minor correction.

Are mortice chisels a necessary part of a woodworkers kit?

No, they're not. They're a specialty chisel used for cutting deep mortices where you can't get working space to allow you to twist out the chip. Mortice chisels are a prying chisel.As such, they are not twisted as a standard bench chisel is when in use, and are a polite substitute for a sharpened crowbar, used as such.

On a cross-grain application such as a mortice, standard bench, chisels are driven into the job with a mallet and then the waste is removed by twisting the chisel, so that one corner of the chisel stays still and the other corner moves and breaks the timber out. To re-emphasise, the mortice chisel is not used in this fashion

This is the other reason for the octagonal handles on the old Sorby chisels. The octagon gives you better grip for the twisting.

Re: Mortice chisels, which ones?

#19

As well, a mortising board is useful (C. Schwarz?)

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Hamish.

A mortising board is useful when cutting mortices.

It's essentially a board that is just clamped upright in the vice, with another board under the mortice to save the bench if the chisel breaks through. A dedicated mortising board has these two boards housed together (US = dado joint)

You put the mortising board into the vice, press the board you are cutting the mortise into firmly on to the bench/sacrificial board underneath and then use a G-cramp/piece of scrap to hold the board onto the mortising board.

The scrap/G-cramp apply pressure directly where you're cutting the mortise to avoid blowing out the sides with a misdirected bit of effort.

The only reference to a mortising board that I can find is in one of Chris Schwarz's books. Perhaps Chris could be kind enough to post a photo?

Cheers (and thanks in advance,)

Andrew

Re: Mortice chisels, which ones?

#20

Half asleep - Don't cut the mortice in the vice.

Andrew F in Australia

>Sorry for the second double post.

Forgot to add a data point not to cut a mortice with the board in the vice. There's no support under the board so you may spall out the underside of the board when the chisel gets close enough.

Additionally, each mallet blow is trying to knock the vice off the underside of the bench. With enough blows, you may succeed.

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: Mortice chisels, which ones?

#21

Its a measurement specific to...

John in NM

>carpenters who have those five gallon bucket tool boxes.