Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Novice Questions

Posts

Novice Questions

#1

Novice Questions

Robert Rothman

>First, I'd like to thank all who responded to my inquiry a few weeks ago about left-eyed, right-handed, sawing. I've still got a lot of practicing to do, but the suggestions I received were very useful.

I'm now about to cross a major milestone: I'm actually going to try to build something! I've decided to try my hand at a pipe rack (for tobacco pipes, not plumbing pipes). The design I have in mind is about as simple as can be: There would be a base, with shallow depressions carved in it in which the bowls of my pipes would sit. A second board, parallel to the base, would have slots to hold the stems. The base and the top board would be connected by a single vertical board. Thus, when viewed from the end, the shape would basically be that of a capital letter "I" (with the top cross-bar a little narrower than the bottom).

My first question relates to the joinery. I'm thinking of mortising the vertical member into the top and bottom pieces. However, unlike conventional tenons, which are cut on the end of the board, the tenons on the vertical piece would run along its edge (like the tongue in a tongue-and-groove joint). Thus, the grain on all three boards would run in the same direction (the length of the piece). My question is whether this is a good or a bad idea?

My second question (which may be a bit premature) is whether anybody can suggest an apropriate finish for the rack. My major concern is that whatever I use must not risk any damage to the pipes with which it comes in contact. Most pipes are stained and waxed, but do not have any varnish, shellac, lacquer or other similar material on them. (I do own one which is bare unfinished briar.) The stems are generally either hard rubber (vulcanite) or lucite. Would shellac be a safe finish to use on the rack?

Thanks for any suggestions.

Re: Novice Questions

#2

Re: Novice Questions

Dan Donaldson

>If I am reading you right, You would not need any kind of a joint at all unless you just want to try something. If the grain is all going the same way, you are gluing long grain to long grain and it would be plenty strong just with the glue. For a project like this, I would assume that you would have the pieces fairly thin (3/8-1/2) so that the scale of the pieces matches the size of the project.

Re: Novice Questions

#3

I agree with Dan. Long grain to long grain ROCKS!!

Larry_Wyatt(Cole's Dad)

>

Re: Novice Questions

#4

Re: I agree with ...

ThomD

>I don't really get the grain orientation you have in mind. It is something of an oversimplification to say that side grain to side grain is great, it bonds to the full strength of the surrounding material, but crossgrain strength of the materials is low to start with. It isn't any more that the joint is so strong as that the material is so weak. Endgrain joints are perfectly strong in certain loading, and crossgrain joints like dovetails and mortise and tenons are the lifblood of casework.

Re: Novice Questions

#5

Re: I agree with ...

Robert Rothman

>Sorry if I wasn't clear. What I have in mind is this: In the face of the base, I would cut a mortise in the middle, through the entire thickness of the board, about 1/4" inch wide in the cross-grain direction and a few inches in the direction along the grain. I would then take a second board, shorter than the base but a little longer than the mortise. I would cut a "tongue" along one edge of the second board. I would then trim off the "tongue" at the ends of the second board, leaving a piece protruding from the edge of that board in the middle, with a length equal to the length of the mortise in the base. Then I would place the edge of the second board onto the face of the base, with the shortened tongue acting as a tenon and inserted into the mortise. Thus, the two boards would be oriented perpendicular to one another, but their grain would run in the same direction. I would then join the top the same way.

This design was not for the specific purpose of trying to attain maximum strength. (It will hold smoking pipes with a total combined weight of a few ounces, not a few hundred pounds of plumbing pipes.) Rather, I just wanted to be sure that running the grain this way will not cause the piece to self-destruct.

As for just butting the edge of one board against the face of the other and gluing, even if that would give adequate strength I'd like to try my hand at a slightly more elaborate joint. Plus, the mortise should avoid the risk that the pieces would slip out of alignment during glue-up and clamping. My question is not whether what I have in mind is necessary for adequate strength, but whether it would cause a problem.

Thanks.

Re: Novice Questions

#6

Re: I agree with ...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Robert,

I think Thom understood you. The question is whether the vertical piece in the middle has its fibers running vertically and its end grain aimed north and south, or whether you propose to crosscut that piece from the end of a board, so that it has end grain along two vertical sides, and it has face grain aimed north and south at the ends.

Taking the two cases:

1. Vertical piece has end grain aimed north and south....This is a cross-grain joint, and it will do just fine. It's cross grain because the fibers of the joined sticks are running at right angles to each other (crossing each other). It will do just fine because, as Thom said, it would be just like every other cross-grain M&T joint. And, as you are planning, you will have long grain to long grain glue (even though they're crossing) over a relatively short distance.

2. Vertical piece is an end cutoff, and has end grain along two long sides..... As Thom indicated, this is the weakest presentation of the material, even though the grain orientation in the joints would be optimized. The pipes wouldn't snap it, but if it got knocked to the floor by some haphazard event, such as what happens around my house, it could snap in two anywhere along the short grain of the vertical piece. Also, you would have those two end-grain faces to work very hard on so that they would not end up duller and darker than the rest of the appearance wood.

I think you are proposing to use method (1) above, and I would strongly agree.

Wiley

Re: Novice Questions

#7

Re: I agree with ...

Robert Rothman

>Thanks. Actually, what I had in mind was yet a third alternative -- the end grain of the vertical member would be on the short dimension of the rack (i.e., looking directly at the end of the rack you'd see a capital "I" formed by the end grain of all three pieces).

Re: Novice Questions

#8

Re: I agree with ...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Robert,

That was my option (2)--I assumed you would put the end grain on the thin sides rather than the face side, in that option. And in that option, as you say, all the grain in the joints will be moving together, in the same direction and at the same rate.

You will have short grain in the vertical piece to mull over. It will only cause trouble if the rack has some kind of an accident.

Wiley

Re: Novice Questions

#9

Re: I agree with ...

Jack F

>Robert,

Orienting the grain of the vertical piece horizontally would be easy, but as Thom said wood does not have much strength parallel to the grain. With a single vertical member there will be a lot of stress on it from a small amount of downward pressure on the edge of the top piece and it could split along the grain. It would be much stronger to orient the vertical piece with the grain vertically. Single tenons could still be used to secure it to the bottom and top.

Jack

Re: Novice Questions

#10

Re: I agree with ...

ThomD

>Here is a little rack held together with glue only, and no joints, really. Designed to hang pictures. Copied the design from a woodworking mag. It is supprisingly strong. One can increase the strength considerablly, with bamboo nails.


img

Re: Novice Questions

#11

Re: I agree with ...

Dan Donaldson

>Shouldn't cause a problem, but the tenon would have the grain running the wrong way for strength and would be no stronger than a glue joint. (maybe not as strong.)

Re: Novice Questions

#12

Re: Novice Questions

Robert Rothman

>Thanks to all. It sounds like I should scrap my original idea and run the grain vertically on the vertical piece.

Re: Novice Questions

#13

That would be my advice, Robert

Ellis Walentine, Host

>Weighing in a bit late here...

Mortise and tenon joints are almost always used for perpendicular-grain joints. This is a classic situation, where you are interested in a strong vertical piece in your design. Besides the improved structural integrity inherent in running the grain of the middle piece vertically, the appearance will seem more natural to the eye, as we are conditioned to see these things in the way they are typically built. If you want to embellish a bit, you might try a piercing or a carved motif in your vertical piece. Or not. Once you have decided on the function and the construction, you can start to play with the details � beads, molded edges, decorative elements, inlays � you're limited only by your own creativity and the aesthetic demands.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Novice Questions

#14

Hey Guys and Gals...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I could be totally wrong here but, isn't this how Krevkonf (SP) made his cabinets?