We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>So I'm over the halfway mark in my benchtop glue up, and I want to make a decision on where this workbench is going to wind up while I can still maneuver the top around.
I really only have two choices. Down the middle, or against one of the short walls in my shop. Rather than trying to describe it, I've made a diagram showing the layout of my shop.
The pros and cons as I see it:
Down the middle
Pro:
Can leave bench 8' long
Good access to all sides of bench
Excellent lighting
Con:
Makes getting around bandsaw to the utility panels and the drill press a bit tight
Makes it difficult to use jointer/planer combo if I need to plane a long board
Access to hand tools is less convenient
Against the short wall
Pro:
Leaves open space in the middle of the shop
Close to where I will wind up storing hand tools (on that short wall)
Con:
I will need to shorten the bench to 6-7' long
Limited access to ends of bench due to wall and utility panels
-Am I correct in assuming this is a basement shop?
I think, from first glance, that I would move the work table to the short wall, and put the bench where the work table is, I think it's good to have the bench in line with the space of the shop, and I think you could squeeze all 8 feet in there.
I don't like the down the middle idea, for a few reasons...
-there's going to be very little room between the bench and everything around it. Moving yourself, any work you have, or a broom... or any number of other things, would be hard.
-The bench is going to serve as crap catcher for every process you do. Drill bits, misc lathe stuff, parts, tools... everything will wind up on the bench but the work.
-It took me a while of collecting tools, and gathering furniture and books, and other things in my home to realize one very important thing. The most versatile, useful thing you can have anywhere you are, live, or work, is space. Placing the bench in the middle of the main open area will really clog up your fung shweeeee.
-I don't know what sorts of projects you work on, small or large. The big open area is a great place for unloading lumber before it's sorted or broken down.
I'm getting claustrophobic just looking at your shop man.... 20 by 10? Holy cow. keep it as open as possible...
I'm really getting spoiled by my new space... and it's starting to show.
>My bench is placed against an 11 foot wall - my shop's on the first floor of a square tankhouse (watertower - no longer in use as one, the city having run water to our street in the 1950s), so all walls are the same length - and I am periodically frustrated by bumping into the limits of the bench layout. I have "optimized" it - the door to the shop is off the right end of the bench, so I can theoretically run wood out the door - but it's still frustrating. There are times when I need to get a little beyond one end of the bench, for instance when planing a long piece, where I need to get behind the plane as I start, and there just isn't room. Now, granted, it may be because, in 121 square feet*, I've got four rollaway toolboxes**, one of those 3 foot by 18 inch shelf units, a table saw, a bandsaw, the bench, and a couple of miscellaneous small stationary tools that I really need to get around to moving (in one case) and selling (in the other). Still, I would droooool over more elbow room at the bench.
Also, my bench is five feet, and I could use another couple of feet, not often, but with delight when I need them - but in order to have that, I'd need a bigger shop.
Have you considered whether this is the occasion to rethink the shop? Perhaps some rearrangements, e.g., moving the lathe, would afford you a better layout altogether.
Safety question: you refer to middle-of-the-shop placement making it tight to get to some of the stationary tools. Would you have safe clearance from them? This could be a deciding issue - inconvenient's a lot better than hazardous.
The true answer, of course, is eat your Wheaties and then push really hard on the walls and see if you can make the shop bigger.
*You're getting claustrophobic looking at Wilbur's shop, James? Try a shop in which only one person can be at a time. When my boys were teenagers, if one of them came to work in the shop, I had to wait until they were done - we didn't both fit.
**Since I do my own house and car maintenance, I have automotive, general mechanical, plumbing, electrical, sheet metal, roofing and masonry, etc. tools to store as well as woodworking tools. It is improved, at least, over the period, early in our time here, when I had a 20 cubic foot upright freezer in the shop.
1. Clamping to the edge. One of the things you will want to do is clamp things to the front face of the bench. As I recall, the bench is a raft, with no apron. It would be very convenient to be able to throw a couple of those Wetzler clamps across the bench and clamp something to the front face. On the other hand, if the bench is against the wall, and has no apron, clamping to the edge gets a bit problematic--not impossible, just more complicated.
2. Sawing joinery. This is really light sensitive. You want strong light on either side of the saw, so there is no shady side of the saw. So I suggest analyze your options for sawing, and try to pick the very best place, in terms of good light on both sides of the blade.
3. Tool access. You'll figure out where to put any additional tool storage you need. One thing I will mention--when I made my bench, I put drawers underneath. However, I instantly found out that I needed about a zillion shallow drawers--you'll need them too. Where are they going to be? Under the sharpening station comes to mind.
>Is it possible you can swap around your bandsaw and joiner/planer?
That would give you a bit more room to get around the bench, as the jointer/planer doesn't look as wide as the band saw.
In that scenario, down the middle would make the most sense and get you the longer bench. I have a 10x20 shed that I use for my office and hand tool work. Space would be tight with the bench in the middle, especially with space used on both sides.
If you use up 2' on each side, and the bench is 2' wide, you will only have 2' on each side of the bench.
My bench is 27" wide, and I have a 30" on the opposite wall. I can pull the bench to the middle of the room and work on both sides, and it is kinda tight as I only have about 4'-4.5' as-is, and that is not having anything else on one side, just the 30" bench. I am shorter than 10' in width, I think it is about 9'6" in reality as the thickness of the walls. It would still be tight with something on each side of the room as you have it pictured. :-/
Have you calculated how much space would be on each side?
>I would make several concessions to have access to both sides of my bench. Comes in handy so very often. Maybe look at the work that you do and see if there are other ways to arrange your tools that are more complementary to the way that you work and would allow access to the bench. In another shop I had I had a lot ob my tools/workstations at the same height and the heoght of my bench so that they could act as additional support/outfeed stations for each other..worked well
>I would find it inconvenient to not be able to work off one end of my bench.
I would consider a rework of the entire shop, starting with the bench. I spend vastly more time at the bench than any tool in the shop, so that is the place to start. The lathe seems to be occupying more acreage than a lathe typically occupies. The bench,work table and band saw and drill press are all compatible in terms of height (that is one won't interfere with another height wise. Consider putting the bench where the lathe is and as much or these other items as will fit without crowding one end of the bench.
For planing long stuff can you orient the machine to run it out one of the doors as necessary?
>I would think about putting the bench where the drill press and the band saw are. Make those two items mobile and live with moving them around as needed.
>Thanks for the thoughtful responses. Again, I find that I probably should have give more information. But to address some of the questions:
The doorways really can't be blocked. The one by the workbench connects to the rest of the basement and is how I get in and out. The one at the other end of the shop by the lathe is a Bilco door to the outside.
The lathe really is that long. It's a Conover lathe, and has a really long bed. That's why it takes up all that space.
My bandsaw is a 16" Walker Turner. It could be put on a mobile base, but it's so heavy that it would be kind of like putting a 20" bandsaw on a mobile base. I have it positioned in the midpoint of the wall to give me the most room to rip a long board.
The jointer/planer combo is mobile. Its location is where I put it when I'm not using it. When I do use it, I move it out to the middle of the room.
The dust collector is also mobile, and the location on my diagram is also where it is usually stored. I have it there because I don't really have to move it too much to use with the bandsaw, jointer/planer, or lathe.
The workbench is going to be about 28-29" high. (I'm pretty short.) At that height it won't interfere with passing things over the bandsaw table. It will interfere with the planer function, but if the workbench is in the middle of the room location, there will be enough room between the workbench and my worktable so that I can pass a board down that "alley".
I may have to just finish up my benchtop glue up and physically look at it.
But thanks for the suggestions so far! I'm open to any others as well, and I am mentally pushing everything around my shop, too.
Bench top acreage is a precious commodity. Don't build an 8' bench and cut 2' off of it. Try it in the middle of the floor first and move your machinery around until you find a comfortable configuration. It took me a couple of years of moving my stuff around before I found a configuration ath I like. If all else fails, cut the bench top down and put it against the short wall, but not before you work with it for a while.
I started with a small bench against the wall. After years of putting together a temporary bench in the middle of the floor to work on, I realized I liked being able to get to all sides of my work. So I built a big bench and put it in the middle of the floor. I couldn't be happier.
>I spend way more time at my bench than anywhere else in my shop. Therefore I would start there and make everything else subservient to that. For example If you only use your planes once a month It can be put on wheels and shoved into a corner
>Make a set of shorter beds for the Conover lathe. Keep the current long ones and prop them in the corner. How often do you expect to turn pieces that long? If/when you have occasion to turn something long enough toneed the longer beds you'll need to do shift stuff around for long enough to do the turning.
>I have a Conover lathe. I built a long bed for it and I have the same problem as Wilbur: it takes up way too much space in my shop. But I haven't been willing to give up the long bed capcity. You just solved my problem, and the solution is so obvious - except to me. Thanks!
>My shop is 24 X 14 so it's a little bigger but not by much. Put everything you can on wheels. The bandsaw is an 18 incher, the Performax, the planer, the jointer, drill press, Unisaw with extensions are all on wheels. My lathe is a longbed and it stays put. My wife has an entire corner for her scroll sawing equipment. We also have a cyclone and some shelves. My bench is only 6 foot long and it is up against the wall. I have access to one short and one long side.We both work in the shop at the same time. We leave the middle open unless the planer/Performax/jointer have to be used or unless I am cutting some long stock with the tablesaw. Have faith it can be done!! Finish your top but don't install your vises and just move everything around figuring on the majority of work you do. The idea about making shorter rails for the Conover is great, one of the beautiful things about those. Go through the motions of doing one of your projects and see where your bottlenecks are, that kind of thing. Doing it on paper is good but in real life gives a clearer picture. So for what its worth, wheels are your friends and no matter how big your shop is you will always need more room!
>That is a great idea. Of course, I'll need a workbench to make the short rails for the lathe, and I'll have to figure out where I can store the long rails that are on it now. :@)
>With the exception of porch posts you may never turn anything longer than 4' for three reasons, one less obvious.
There is no way I would turn a 6' bed post. Too limber for one (4' x 3" is plenty limber and requires tedious steadying and cutting) but more important...... While I turn a lot, I still do screw up. I once turned a spool bed post with about 50 cuts (operations) along its length. The stress of making the 49th was nearly unbearable, for a screw up on this cut ruined several hours of work and some valuable lumber. So on the next 3, I divided the post and turned it in two parts which I then doweled together- less stress, less limber, less need for long straight stock. Such assembly is always easy on a turned post as it will have an easy dividing part somewhere.
Finally, finding something straight for 6' is near impossible. To turn a 3" x 4' bed post I started with 16/4 lumber and just made it.
For the post pictured I divided the post just above the top mortise. There was no mechanical sacrifice and the advantages gained are listed above.
>So, there you go, Wilbur. Shorter lathe bed, put the lathe at the short wall. Dismantle the lathe for now, since it's unlikely that you'll use it while you're rearranging your shop space. And cut your bench to fit the new space.
Yes, I said cut to fit... an 8 footer is nice. But not always necessary... I find usually that the usable portion of an 8 footer is often comprised of the amount of space you can get from clearing off one end of it. And bear in mind that, right next to the door, it's going to be the de-facto place where you chuck things when you're in a hurry. If you leave it short, and make a corner bin/shelf system to be a crap catcher instead of your bench, you may find that your shorter bench has more room to do actual work.
>If you go with the short bed, don't forget to figure out where you're going to put the stuff you have stored on the part of the bed you never used. I know that would be a dilema for me.
Seriously, there would be two issues for me if I moved that lathe to the other end of the shop. First, I would need to relocate or install a new 220V outlet. Second, one major reason why I put the lathe where it is was so it could be close to the dust collector for sanding.