Re: dogwood
ThomD
>"The bottom line is that you have to hit a chisel with a sledge hammer to adversely affect the handle"
I agree that for many things people don't wear out the handles. Hard to seem mushrooming handles cutitng dovetails. But it is also possibly a measure of not working them hard enough. Just about every wood shafted wood working tool from gluts to chisels is hooped, at least in some styles of manufacture. My observation is that a lot of times people are just babying them.
OIne tool that just devastated my wooden handles was one of those bronze carvers mallets. Hitting the ends of my chisels may have well been driving home a wedge, though apparently they work for some people. On the other hand, my rubber carver's mallet is very gentle.
Another thing is that not all hoops are there to eliminate devastation, they are there just to control the way the end of a chisel deforms. A rounded mushroom end, nice and tight, can take blows at angles that would possibly damage another handle. Allowing the end to upset, but controlling the split gives it a more rugged and less directional end. Enhances the characteristics of the wood, moreso than just a bandaid. It is basically the same idea as saying hoops reduce splits, I guess. Just looking at is as a way of enhansing wood's performance.