Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Chisel info, puh-leeze!

Posts

Chisel info, puh-leeze!

#1

Chisel info, puh-leeze!

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>Hi, all -

Ok, starting to learn to dovetail. Got my mallet made, getting my chisels ready. Several have cracked or missing handles; the question now is what to replace them with? To hoop, or not to hoop? Style?

I know hooped Japanese chisels are intended to be struck with a steel hammer. My mallet's mesquite, and I don't want to trash it immediately banging on metal hoops. At the same time, I don't think a paring-style handle (like what's on my AI bench chisels) is completely appropriate, either.

Anyone have ideas/sage advice to offer me?

Thanks for any help,

Scott

Re: Chisel info, puh-leeze!

#2

dogwood

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I have smacked the bejeepers out of my chisel handles. they are simply rounded dog wood, turned from dogwood limbs. I am sure there are equivalent woods. The bottom line is that you have to hit a chisel with a sledge hammer to adversely affect the handle. Maybe after 29 years you will begin to bruise them. Its not like it is hard to make a replacement.

Re: Chisel info, puh-leeze!

#3

and if you don't have dogwood there

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>(we don't here, but I imagine PA does - but in case), I think Lee Valley's still selling dogwood blanks for pretty cheap.

I've got an oak chisel handle on one of my construction chisels that I have on occasion beaten the [deleted] out of with a hammer, and it's still holding up. I think the necessity of the hoops may be overstated.

Re: Chisel info, puh-leeze!

#4

How 'bout... *LINK*

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>...mesquite? Have some still in smallish pieces. Harder'n sin.

Ok, in leiu of a hoop, how 'bout leather striking buttons, ala Smalser? I like the shape of the handles; is the striking button of leather all that necessary, though?


Bob Smalser's method

Re: Chisel info, puh-leeze!

#5

Re: Chisel info, puh-leeze!

Dean J in MN

>I am partial to tapered handles a la Seaton and others. The handle shown is maple, and I have a bunch made of birch -- both hold up very well.

-Dean


img

Re: Chisel info, puh-leeze!

#6

o.t. ; has anyone heard from Bob lately?

Victor Parisian

>

Re: Chisel info, puh-leeze!

#7

Re: dogwood

ThomD

>"The bottom line is that you have to hit a chisel with a sledge hammer to adversely affect the handle"

I agree that for many things people don't wear out the handles. Hard to seem mushrooming handles cutitng dovetails. But it is also possibly a measure of not working them hard enough. Just about every wood shafted wood working tool from gluts to chisels is hooped, at least in some styles of manufacture. My observation is that a lot of times people are just babying them.

OIne tool that just devastated my wooden handles was one of those bronze carvers mallets. Hitting the ends of my chisels may have well been driving home a wedge, though apparently they work for some people. On the other hand, my rubber carver's mallet is very gentle.

Another thing is that not all hoops are there to eliminate devastation, they are there just to control the way the end of a chisel deforms. A rounded mushroom end, nice and tight, can take blows at angles that would possibly damage another handle. Allowing the end to upset, but controlling the split gives it a more rugged and less directional end. Enhances the characteristics of the wood, moreso than just a bandaid. It is basically the same idea as saying hoops reduce splits, I guess. Just looking at is as a way of enhansing wood's performance.

Re: Chisel info, puh-leeze!

#8

Dean, how 'bout a brief explanation . . .

Tom Colligan

>on how you made the tapered handle on your carving chisel? Tia, Tom.

Re: Chisel info, puh-leeze!

#9

Re: dogwood

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Thom

I, too, have one of the brass carver's mallets. The one by Veritas. It is a beautifully balanced mallet with great heft for its size. I bought it several years ago, used it a few times, and it has since remained an ornament on the shelf. I love its looks and the way it works, but it will destroy my chisel handles in time if I continue using it.

Mallets are easy to make. I'd rather make a new mallet than have to make new chisel handles. So the mallets I make are softer than the chisel handles they wack.

My Japanese hooped chisels are designed to be hit by a steel genno, so that's what I use for them. I'd recommend something similar for all hooped chisels. However, for wooden, hoopless handles, I recommend a replaceable mallet.



The large mallet is a softish Jarrah (from a reclaimed 100 year old jetty), and the smaller one is Grey Gum. This I use if I need to give a paring chisel a light tap. The brass mallet just keeps them comapny.

Regards fropm Perth

Derek

Re: Chisel info, puh-leeze!

#10

Re: Dean, how 'bout a brief explanation . . .

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Top,

First, you have to make a special tool. *grin*

It's a great way to make a handle without the use of a lathe. It's like making a short tapered table leg.

Marv

Re: Chisel info, puh-leeze!

#11

agree

ron in kokomo

>you dont see hoops om the old English Mortise Chisels I have several of them with white oak handles

Re: Chisel info, puh-leeze!

#12

Re: Dean, how 'bout a brief explanation . . .

Dean J in MN

>Tom --

Yes that is a carving chisel -- but I use them as my everyday chisels as I can't find any other chisel thin as I would like. Until that time I have found single bevel carving chisels to be a nice stand in. (A bit shorter than I would like and still a bit thick but I digress)

The handles are really easy to make. The photo makes it appear square, but it is really a rectangle in cross section, with the corners beveled to make it a somewhat squashed octagon. The wider portion of the rectangle lines up with the bevel -- think of an oval handle mortise chisel handle, but turned 90 degrees to line the wide section with bevel rather than orthogonal as in the mortise chisel.

I lay the taper out on the stock, cut it with a rip saw, drill the hole for the tang and then knock off the bevels with a drawknife and round the but with a drawknife and rasp. As was mentioned, just like making a little tapered leg.

-Dean

Re: Chisel info, puh-leeze!

#13

handle hardness

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>I have always thought that you want your handles to be slightly harder than your mallet, since replacing a mallet would be easier than replacing all your handles. Okay, I have not ALWAYS thought this. It occurred to me AFTER making an osage mallet. So I made some handles from more osage and some from almost as hard persimmon. And guess what: no matter how hard I hit them, neither shows any sign of wear, except where I whacked some steel with the mallet. Your mesquite situation is similar to my osage one.

In other words, you can probably make nice handles from any hard wood. Hoops and/or leather washers are unnecessary IMO. I turned mine on a lathe - good practice - and put a small flat on the back of the smaller ones that might want to roll around. Shape 'em to suit YOU.

Re: Chisel info, puh-leeze!

#14

Puh-leeze, let me 'splain Lucy...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>On a Japanese chisel the hoop keeps the handle from splitting. It's seated below the top of the handle. As the chisel is struck the wood mushrooms around the hoop. So, your never hitting the hoop it's self.