Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Finish for a mallet?

Posts

Finish for a mallet?

#1

Finish for a mallet?

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>Hi, all -

I'm making a mallet, with eyes on dovetailing. The mallet's turned, carver style, out of mesquite. I'm at the finishing stage now, and thought I'd solicit opinions on finish choices. I was originally thinking I'd oil it and finish with shellac and wax; I'm wondering now if shellac can take the abuse the mallet will be seeing.

Anyone have a suggestion? Oil and wax alone? Will shellac handle the pounding?

Thanks,

Scott


img

Re: Finish for a mallet?

#2

Re: Finish for a mallet?

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>What value are you seeking with the shellac?

Oil would darken the wood, and 'seal' a bit of the surface. The wax would help as well. I don't know that the shellac would add too much value. And I'm a shellac fan.

Unless this piece is something other than a heavy stick for whacking things... ;-)

Re: Finish for a mallet?

#3

Re: Finish for a mallet?

Dean J in MN

>I'd suggest a few years of hand oils from practicing your dovetails.

Re: Finish for a mallet?

#4

Shellac is...

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>...just part of my usual tool finishing regime - usually oil, shellac, rub out with wax. I've read pros and cons with this - stickiness causing blisters and such - but I like the feel it generally gives. My travisher and spokeshaves/devils are finished this way, as opposed to the handles on my scorp, which are nekkid. I don't like the feel of the raw wood nearly as much.

Scott

Re: Finish for a mallet?

#5

Re: Finish for a mallet?

Alex Yeilding

>Another shellac fan here, seconding Glenn's vote against it for this application. Too hard (brittle) and slick for a mallet. I'd vote for no finish, or a drying oil or oil-varnish mix. Or a couple of thin coats of Waterlox sealer/finish, applied like an oil finish, but not enough to build a surface film.

On second thought, I might be wrong on the brittleness comment. I have an old bench that I finished with shellac and wax. Great for glue-ups, since glue pops right off, but WAY too slick. But I haven't had any problems with the finish cracking with dents, and of course it is easy to repair if it does. Still, what's wrong with naked wood for a mallet?

Re: Finish for a mallet?

#6

Re: Finish for a mallet?

roninkokomo

>definitely oil and wax.

You do not want to pout shellac on it

Re: Finish for a mallet?

#7

Oil and wax it is!

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>Thanks for the input, everyone. I'm already on to finishing. I love the look of oiled mesquite. If you ever have the chance to work with the stuff, I highly recommend it. Beautiful wood.

Thanks again,

Scott

Re: Finish for a mallet?

#8

Re: Oil and wax it is!

ThomD

>I would vote for oil, and no wax, not that wax is so bad. If you go for varnish and want to avoid blisters, the key is to cut back the finish with about 320 grit. This somewhat eliminates the gloss advantage one might get with varnish, but it works. I use that finish on paddle shafts. The lower hand is on varnish cut back and the upper hand is on oiled wood.

Part of the decision would be based on whether the mallet hits on the end grain. If it is the round carving type then you want something that will survive a certain amount of denting, like oil. If one where making a hammer type mallet then the endgrain will hold up, and the rest can be whatever you like.

Re: Finish for a mallet?

#9

Yea it is, and I should know...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>The spoke shaves I made from the piece you sent me are great. I'd opt for no finish myself, but if your going for it just use oil. Wax will make it glance off the chisel when DT'ling. Not that you need a mallet to make DT's anyway. To each his own...

Re: Finish for a mallet?

#10

Two Scotts...

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>Here are the chisel handle and mallet, both of mesquite, both waxed within an inch of their lives. I know, I know, but it's a compulsion.

If you ever have a chance to work mesquite, two Scotts highly recommend it!


img

Re: Finish for a mallet?

#11

Re: Two Scotts...

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Scott,

I think it needs just one more coat of wax.

Marv

Re: Finish for a mallet?

#12

Nice looking handle there...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>What did you pattern it after?

Is it comfy?

Re: Finish for a mallet?

#13

Well...

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>...I'd like to say I patterned it after the one in the Smalser article, but really, it's kind of free-form, wing it as you go styling. It's really comfortable, if not a little goofy looking.

BTW, never saw the mesquite spokeshaves. Got a pic?

Re: Finish for a mallet?

#14

Sure do, here ya go...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>It's the one on the bottom.


img

Re: Finish for a mallet?

#15

Nuther one, bottom view 

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>


img

Re: Finish for a mallet?

#16

Very impressive, Scott

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>

Re: Finish for a mallet?

#17

Thanks!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>