Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Gramercy kit saws

Posts

Gramercy kit saws

#1

Gramercy kit saws

David in Indy

>I finished my second kit from Gramercy. The carcass (crosscut) saw joins the dovetail saw I made with a kit from last xmas. A picture of both is atached. The process is pretty simple and a pattern for the handle is provided. I made both handles from some walnut wiht heavy figuring (almost a burl). The only time I got concerned was when I had to bash the blade into the brass back. You build a bat (looks like a cricket bat) for this purpose. The wood that impacts the saw is the face of the 2x4 or whatever you make the bat from. Doesn't appear to have bent or broken any teeth. Both saws cut very well. Just not sure I'll be able to go cold turkey on my Japanese saws.


img

Re: Gramercy kit saws

#2

Re: Gramercy kit saws

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>Beautiful work. Can you say how the Gramercy cuts compared with other saw makes?

Scott, pondering

Re: Gramercy kit saws

#3

Re: Gramercy kit saws

ThomD

>Nice job. The handle seems at a very high angle on these saws and kits, how do you like that? Japanese saws are like driving to the grocery store in a ferrari.

Re: Gramercy kit saws

#4

Re: Gramercy kit saws

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi David,

Just a few questions....for each saw separately, please.

First...do you have a micrometer?

Plate thickness?

Points per inch?

How much set?

Can you determine the rake angle?

Is the DT saw filed rip?

Were the plates already filed or just punched?

Was the price for each the same?

Are the backs bent or milled slots?

When you made the handles, did you use a template included in the kit?

Thanks,

Marv

Re: Gramercy kit saws

#5

Re: Gramercy kit saws

David in Indy

>I can't really say how the saws compare to Lie-Nielsen, Adria or others, but they are very comfortable to use and cut well. The kerf on the dovetail is wider than a japanese saw, but it's still very narrow. The saws have received positive reviews from Chris Schwarz in Popular Woordworking and I believe they both made PW's best new tools lists.

Re: Gramercy kit saws

#6

Re: Gramercy kit saws

David in Indy

>Thanks, as I said above, I do like the way they perform. The handle height seems fine to me.

Re: Gramercy kit saws

#7

Re: Gramercy kit saws *LINK*

David in Indy

>I don't use a micrometer. Almost all of your technical questions are answered on the Tools For Woodworking site, that's who creates and sells the Gramercy line of saws. I'm attaching a link to the description of the dovetail saw with the details and some better pictures. There's a description of the carcass saw there as well. TFWW is also a sponsor of Woodcentral. The dovetail saw is filed rip, both saw blades were hand hammered, filed and ready to go. The backs are bent, not milled slots. The price for the kits is about one-half the price of the finished saws. The dovetail kit is $70 versus $140 for the finished saw and the carcass saw kit is $100 versus $180. Again, you should check out TFWW's site for more information. Yes, I did use the patterns that came with the kits for both handles.


http://www.toolsforworkingwood.com/Merchant/merchant.mvc?Screen=PROD&Store_Code=toolshop&Product_Code=GT-DSAW9.XX&Category_Code=TMQ

Re: Gramercy kit saws

#8

Can't speak for the Gramercy saws on handle angle

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>but the angle on the larger saw does seem consistent, or at least not too far from, handle angles on older small Disston, Atkins, etc. backsaws. My impression is that shorter saws got higher handle angles; I presume this grew out of experience.

Re: Gramercy kit saws

#9

They look great Daivd...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Just 1 question. Why didn't you round over the edges of the handle more? Or are they comfy as they are?