Re: In defense of the Cosman approach to dovetails
ThomD
>"The Klause approach of, "just eye ball them" and get on with it is not helpful to someone that has never held a dovetail saw."
Actually I believe it is ideal for beginners. It forces them to rely on their skill rather than trying to escape it. It is a bit like talking about sharpening with a jig or without. If a person wanted to learn the without method they need to get in touch with their hands. All the training wheels in the world will just slow them down. There are a few problems though:
1) Some people just won't try a free approach, as though wasting 25 cents of wood were a tragedy. This speaks to the idea that people have different ways of learning. Some people may be open to trying something that expands their abilities, some people won't do it because it hurts their feelings about who they are as a woodworker. And people come to learning in more or less physical ways. Overall a person may be better to practice their weaknesses, but people seem to prefer practicing what they can already do.
2) Most people don't want to learn how to make dovetails, they want to make dovetails in the context of a particular project, often with valuable wood at stake, whether because it is nice, or already has some work invested in it. So that requires a stilted and damage controlling approach to the problem. It would be as though one wanted to learn to ride a bicycle, but had to come up with an approach that would allow one to never spend a second in practice and start instantly one a tour across America. That would require something a little different in learning approach than just winging it on the driveway.
"Cosman's approach provides a road map to successfully get through the mechanics of layout and marking and on to the hard-to-learn part of sawing, chopping and fitting. In an hour I can have students worrying about these hand skill issues and practicing on a joint they have laid out."
Really layout and making are two completely separate things, as you know. Klauzs method does not come up with a harder method of laying out, it basically comes down to two things:
1)just make a messy layout. Fine for practice, bad for projects. So for anyone really just practicing, dividers or templates are of no practical use. K's method does not adapt to all situation where dovetails are cut. It is just a method of doing layout, layout free, where that is appropriate.
2) Does one need a pencil line to saw a straight enough line. At root here is the issue of whether pencil lines on wood straighten out sawing, and the whole sighting and aiming point theory in woodwork. I would say more often than not the answer is that lines are much help:
- Some saws are so tight that they don't steer, so getting back on line is not possible;
- Another important point is what are you aiming at when you follow the line. In general, if you want to hit something off in the distance (like the precise point you are trying to reach at the bottom of a cut), you are better off not looking at where the saw is cutting in relation to the line. There are two reasons for this. One is one is not projecting the cut in the right direction, as accurately as if one simply stared at the arrival point, even a rough idea of where that arrival point is. Also, the area one is looking at the distance between the line and the edge of the saw is very difficult to judge. one is far more likely to wiggle back and forth, and make a rough line. Another good place to focus on at times is the space between the blade and the kerf. Is the saw stock parallel to the kerf. Only works if one started well.
So to what extent is the line helpful? I think it is helpful once one has learned the behaviour that gets one on target. It can be a trap for the beginner though.
"There is simply no argument that tails first is easiest to learn to saw."
I would have thought there was ample argument on that point. I tend to fall into the camp that if there are two opposed warring camps that say only one way is possible, and both seem to manage, then I come to the conclusion that there is no right way. I do find the emergence of the tails first school odd. A number of people as natural contrarians, seem to have bristled at the idea one had to go pins first, and tails first is the route they pursued. Even if pins first were harder, and I see no reason why that would be the case, there is only one truly hard thing about dovetails an that is getting the saw cuts nice with the correct fudge factor so they come together as a joint. Everything else is a nothing in comparison. In one's woodworking career one is likely to have to make cuts that look like starting on the tails, and cuts that look like starting on the pins. I see no reason why anyone would fail at the task, once they got underway in the craft.
"So,by combining Cosman layout and marking and tails first sawing someone with no experience can produce a serviceable joint in 4 hours. And they can go home with enough knowledge, and confidence, to lay out and saw more practice joints if they have continued interest."
Four hours should be enough time for any method, but you are to be commended for teaching others. My only thing about that is that learning from a video is a different deal. If a person wants to learn from video, or books, there is something to be said for sticking to one method only rather than trying to invent some hybrid. Pick a demonstrated method and stick to it in every detail, because the method shown in the tape works. One thing about Cosman and Klauzs is that both, to my way of thinking are really demonstrators. I am not sure their methods are principally teaching methods. You, Bill, are at least addressing the issue of the best way to teach something.