Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Please hold your applause, thank you *LINK*

Posts

Please hold your applause, thank you *LINK*

#1

Please hold your applause, thank you *LINK*

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>If'n ya cain't gloat, why do it?

What's that old saying about making a sow's ear from a silk purse? Do I have that backwards?

Marv


Sow's Ear?

Re: Please hold your applause, thank you *LINK*

#2

Niiiice...

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>Lemme know how you like that thing - I have (essentially) the same saw. Sharpened by Tom Law, but I've never gotten the hang of using it. Thinking it's just me.

Did you carve the wheat?

Re: Please hold your applause, thank you *LINK*

#3

Re: Niiiice...

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Scott,

What exactly didn't you get the hang of?

The teeth on the original saw had waaay too much set that caused the saw to cut about a 1/16 kerf. It now has only enough set to prevent it from binding in the cut. I don't know how anyone could have gotten the hang of a saw filed that badly.

Yes, I did the wheat carving. I like doing it to an ugly handle. Kinda puts a smile on it.

Marv

Re: Please hold your applause, thank you *LINK*

#4

Re: Niiiice...

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>Hi, Marv -

Not wanting to hijack your thread, but I always had trouble keeping that saw running straight. And it always felt grabby. I have a cheap dozuki that cuts much smoother than the Atkins. Never understood why. Probably (likely) the operator. I need to practice with it again (been a while); if I still can't get it, I'll post for some help.

The handle looks great. Makes me want to reshape mine. Nice work.

Scott

Re: Please hold your applause, thank you *LINK*

#5

Re: Niiiice...

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Scott,

It's mainly about how your Atkins saw was filed that makes it grabby and won't cut straight. If it's filed correctly, it will pretty much follow a line on it's own. My saw was like yours until I reshaped the teeth and filed out most of the over-set. It took three passes to get the set down to only a few thousands on each side of the blade. My saw is a 14 point pitch. You don't want bigger teeth than that for dovetailing in most situations.

Also, if your saw is a crosscut and you are sawing end grain, that could cause the saw to not want to follow a straight line. A DT saw should be filed "rip".

Keep in mind, a saw, any saw, no matter who the maker is, is merely a piece of sheetmetal with teeth with a handle attached. It's all about the filing and profile of the teeth and what you are using the saw for. Nothing magical about it.

Marv

Re: Please hold your applause, thank you *LINK*

#6

Re: Niiiice...

Dean J in MN

> Keep in mind, a saw, any saw, no matter who the maker is, is merely a piece of sheetmetal with teeth with a handle attached. It's all about the filing and profile of the teeth and what you are using the saw for. Nothing magical about it.

This is a *very* important fact which can stand to be repeated. I get a kick out of saw reviews: "Smooth cutting, fast cutting, etc" when any of the saws under review could be filed to cut the same way. They are reviewing the way the saw is filed.

Yes, hang angle and handle comfort is a consideration, but I don't see the hang angle reviewed and a wooden handle can be shaped by the user to fit their hand.

-Dean

Re: Please hold your applause, thank you *LINK*

#7

Silk purse!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Marv,

That's really high-quality and beautiful work! You've made a believer out of me; that saw is better in every way than when it left the factory. Really outstanding.

Wiley

Re: Please hold your applause, thank you *LINK*

#8

Geeeeeze, Marv!

Frank Mutchler

>Now you went and added another 'tuit' to my 'round' board. Wonderful effort and very inspirational!

Re: Please hold your applause, thank you *LINK*

#9

Gee...I'm Sorry...

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Frank,

It boggles my mind when I run across a saw such as that Atkins, in that someone in a responsible, decision making position of a company making saws would actually approve the sale of such a mess. Don't they realize that someone might buy that saw and attempt to make it function in the way it was supposed to? When I got that saw it was basically useless. It wouldn't saw jack, mainly due to the amount of set in the teeth. The teeth had obviously been machine set. I'm pretty sure that I am the first to sharpen it. It looked as if it was nearly impossible to start a cut without doing a lot of dragging the saw backward because the teeth here kind of bent in the wrong direction.

Anyway, it was fun to transform it into a very nice functioning saw. Thanks for the compliment.

It's on eBay and probably won't sell for much only because it's not a Disston or and LN..etc. A labor of love, right?

Marv

Re: Please hold your applause, thank you *LINK*

#10

Re: Please hold your applause, thank you

Tony Zaffuto

>Very nice job! I particularly like the fine wheat carving.

T.Z.

Re: Please hold your applause, thank you *LINK*

#11

Re: Niiiice...

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Dean,

Yes, most handles can be modified to some degree but I suppose when one spends those big bucks on a saw, one is not inclined to take a chance on messing it up. Ruins the authenticity, resale value, collectibility, etc. etc. However, on a saw such as these with a lousy handle to start with, I don't hesitate to have my way with it. I like to hack away at it until all the ugliness goes away.

Hang has to do with the angle of the grip in relation to the tooth line and the height of the grip in relation to the top or bottom of the saw. Can't easily alter that with a handle already drilled to fit the blade.

I've been thinking about an adjustable handle that can adjust the grip angle. Most of the major saw makers made larger non-backed saws that had adjustable handles.

Marv

Re: Please hold your applause, thank you *LINK*

#12

Ahh Marv, ya wanker...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>That's not a sow's ear to start with by any means. I have a old Crapsman that makes that look like Miss Universe! Never the less you've done yet again another fine job on bring a ol' relic back to like in a nip-tuck kind of way!

Nice carving as usually...

Re: Please hold your applause, thank you *LINK*

#13

Gorgoeus work Marv!

Stuart Hough

>

Re: Please hold your applause, thank you *LINK*

#14

Re: Please hold your applause, thank you

Stuart Hough

>Marv, I liked it so much I put a bid on it! Wish me luck!

Re: Please hold your applause, thank you *LINK*

#15

That's just pain wrong...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Find your own and then let Marvz do his majicz...

Might save you a few penny's...

Re: Please hold your applause, thank you *LINK*

#16

Thank you!

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Stuart,

Thanks for the bid, good luck, hope you win. I have lots of watchers so far.

I snooped around in your feedbacks....great buy on that push drill. I saw just a set of bits sell a couple weeks ago for more than you paid for the drill and all the extra bits.

I have a small collection of those push drills including some Millers Falls. The North Bros. are the best though. I found a brand new one still in the box at an estate sale once for only $3. I have 10 of them, all in their original box, some with labels on the handle. Then I have one that I've been using for about 30 years, plus about 12 really old ones.

Thanks again for the bid, I have the teeth set for dovetails, short cuts. Might need a little more if you'll be using it for tenons.

Marv

Re: Please hold your applause, thank you *LINK*

#17

Re: Thank you!

Stuart Hough

>That'll be fine, Marv. I don't have a good DT saw yet, but then again I've never done DT's yet. But I'm ready to learn!!!!!