Sharpening "memory" from ~40 years ago...
John Aniano in Central NJ...
>Scott et. al.,
Your thread posted on Sunday about sharpening IS a good one! So are your wonderful projects - the spokeshave you made is amazing!
No matter how folks are ganging up on you, sharpening is still important. For many who don't have to work fast (and make $$ from the hobby) the sharpening method and results you describe are just fine. Others have ideas and opinions that might differ, that's all.
I remember my own sharpening "epiphany" at about age 15. Have just gotten back from a local flea market with my "find" - a ~3" square Belgian honing stone, I proceeded to flatten it and sharpen a chisel. I had probably read about Belgian honing stones in Woodcraft catalogs, but WOW! Nothing in my prior experience, ie. coarse and fine India stones, prepared me for what really sharp was. I was amazed and then sharpened a plane blade and that old Stanley "Handyman" plane actually took shavings from end grain in pine and oak! I was hooked!!
We do woodworking for many reasons, some of us for the sheer joy of playing with the tools. And sharpening.
John



