Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Sharpening gouges

Posts

Sharpening gouges

#1

Sharpening gouges

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi All,

Scott's sharpening thread down below reminded me of something I've been wanting to discuss. And that is sharpening gouges.

I like to keep the cutting angle shallow on gouges, which translates into a long bevel. I find that keeping the cutting angle shallow is a challenge. I tend to gradually, bit by bit, round it a bit, so that if I start with a gouge that will pick up a shaving at, say, 25 degrees, after a few sharpenings, it'll be picking them up at 30 degrees. So I go back and 'reflatten' the bevel on a coarse stone, and get it back to 25 (I'm not actually measuring these bevels, but this is the ballpark).

I sharpen by working the gouge sideways on the stone, in a rolling fashion, and back off by pulling the incannel along the edge of a strop, which puts a few degrees back bevel on it.

What do you folks do?

Wiley

Re: Sharpening gouges

#2

Re: Sharpening gouges

ThomD

>I sharpen mostly turning gouges, and basically use my left hand as a rest, just like the tool rest on the lathe, and they I grind with my right. keeping an angle is easier on a hollow ground bevel, so it could help out that way.

When sharpening or honing by hand, and for carving chisels generally (mostly carbon steel in my shop while turning gouges are mostly HSS) I use a slip, or something like it I work along the edge, and rotate the gouge with my left hand and the stone with my right. I could do it with the gouge working on a stone also, but I tend to work gouges with a slip. This is like filing a rounded surface to produce a quarter round, and the "correct" way to do that is the opposite of what many do. One starts with the hand high and the file/slip horizontal, at the end of the stroke the file is vertical and the hand moving up. Working parallel to the edge makes it easy to keep the bevel, but the scratch pattern ends up parallel to the edge, and that may weaken it, so I sometimes finish by buffing away from the edge.

One trick I use to see when I have a chisel flat on a stone, is I start on the heel and rock it forward on the stone, until a jet of lube skirts out from the edge. This happens because the last degree or so of closing will eject some material almost from the heal. After a while the feel is automatic even if a gouge doesn't really work for this.

Re: Sharpening gouges

#3

Re: Sharpening gouges

wilbur

>For gouges, albeit turning gouges, I use a Tormek. It's pricey, but it does a really nice job.

Re: Sharpening gouges

#4

Re: Sharpening gouges

Robin in Atascadero CA

>I sharpen my out cannel gouges the same way as you. If you are starting at the edge of the gouge and making a straight line on the stone that would explain the rounding over, particularly if it is more pronounced in the middle of the gouge. I find it is easier to keep the bevel flat if I make a slightly curved pattern of marks on the stone. this is for a gouge with a square grind vs a fingernail grind which for carving I don't care for. If your gouge is not a square grind you may find it easier to sharpen and use if you regrind it.

For in cannel gouges I use cone shaped stones. I am much slower with these which is why I only use them when I have no other way to sharpen.

Robin

Re: Sharpening gouges

#5

Re: Sharpening gouges

MikeW

>Hi Wiley,

For hand sharpening or honing, whether in- or out-cannel, I tend to put the gouge in a vise and take the stone to it. And for that matter, I tend to use some diamond cones for moderate sharpening and slips for a slight secondary bevel in use.

Grinding in-cannel, I use shaped stones on a slow speed grinder. I have one that is about 3/8" thick and one 1/8" thick I have radiused edges on. Like someone mentioned, I plant my left hand holding the tool and roll the gouge. Out-cannel I use a 1" stone and use the same technique.

Take care, Mike

Re: Sharpening gouges

#6

Re: Sharpening gouges

Kevin Adams

>Hi Wiley--

I've been doing quite a bit of carving lately and one thing that helped me a lot was the Chris Pye DVD on sharpening (and much of this is also available for free on his website). The main thing he stresses is to present the tool (whether grinding or honing on stones) at the same angle that you use the tool. For grinding, he works the tool perpendicular to the wheel so as to maintain a flat (rather than hollow) bevel. When honing, the tool is held at the same (low) angle that you will carve at. He also shows how to use slip stones on the inside bevel to keep the "line of light" even until it fades to nothing. Certainly not rocket science, but kind of like Scott discovered, it's pretty neat when you figure it out and see the results.

Hope all is well and I'll try to catch up more off line.

Take care,

Kevin

Re: Sharpening gouges

#7

Re: Sharpening gouges

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Thanks Thom,

That's an intriguing notion, to get the gouge and the slip up in your eyes so you can really see what you're doing. I will try that--similar to sharpening a moulding plane iron.

Wiley

Re: Sharpening gouges

#8

Tormek seems like a

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>good investment, as I think about it looking back. It always drove me crazy that you had to double the outlay to buy the fixtures, but viewed as a long-term investment, it's probably a very good one.

Wiley

Re: Sharpening gouges

#9

Re: Sharpening gouges

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Robin,

Thanks a lot. What I do is hold the gouge in my left hand, and make an arc as I roll the gouge through its full sweep. Yes, these are square-shouldered, not nosed. I watch the stone, and am looking for a black swarf track that has some width to it--not just a line, which would indicate that I'm standing on the edge and putting on a steeper facet.

I have a feeling though, as we talk about it, that I'm not being patient enough, and probably do begin feeling for the edge, which would round it over.

I think I'll try it Thom's way, and watch what I'm doing.

Wiley

Re: Sharpening gouges

#10

Re: Sharpening gouges

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Mike,

Now that is another great idea! I will take a couple gouges, and do one as Thom suggested, and the other as you suggest, and see where that leads. Both ways are very direct and get the work up in your eyes, which seems good.

Wiley

Re: Sharpening gouges

#11

Re: Sharpening gouges

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Kevin,

Thanks for that. The 'line of light' is a good idea. I know a lot of people do the 'light extinction' thing with straight blades as well.

Doing OK here. Will drop you a line.

Wiley

Re: Sharpening gouges

#12

Re: Tormek seems like a

wilbur

>Hi Wiley,

Regarding the cost of the Tormek, maybe you'll appreciate this.

Tornek : sharpening :: Yataiki : saws

:@)

(Which may be overstating the case, but hopefully you get my drift.)

Re: Sharpening gouges

#13

I hear ya

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>and would never claim to be rational on the subject of tools.

Thought for the day: Only the best is a bargain.

Wiley

Re: Sharpening gouges

#14

Re: Tormek seems like a

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I have to disagree on this. Tormak is a good grinder with good accessories, but no better a grinder than any other with a similar wheel, say a Makita horizontal (for a lot less money). It's also s-l-o-w. Never the less, it does not in any way compare to Yataiki saws in any sort of comparison. It may make you feel good to spend $500-1000 on a grinder when you use it, just as it may make you feel good to spend $1500 or so on a Yataiki saw; but that's as far as it goes.

Pam

PS This is my personal opinion, based on brief usage of a Tormak, a Makita, and several other grinders, and long term usage of a couple of Yataiki saws.