Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Pitted chisel - worth the effort?

Posts

Pitted chisel - worth the effort?

#1

Pitted chisel - worth the effort?

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>Hi, all -

I bought an old Greenlee chisel for a couple bucks a while back. Advertised as having "a little surface rust". I doused it in phosphoric acid, and saw that the extent of the rust was much worse. There it has sat until now.

So, I had at it with some 120 grit drywall screen. After a couple minutes, I had what you see below. I'm wondering now if I (a) should continue lapping, trying to eliminate all the pitting, (b) sharpen it and use it as-is, 'cause the pitting is inconsequential (or is it?), or (c) use it for opening paint cans.

Any advice?

Scott


img

Re: Pitted chisel - worth the effort?

#2

Oh, Scott - you're as bad as I am

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>That's pretty pitiful.

There's another alternative, if you're short of lathe scrapers. Mind, I haven't actually tried this, but the principle seems sound, which is why I've saved three or four grungy firmers for future experiments: grind a scraping edge on it with a strong back bevel, so your sharp edge is not at the back but between back and (front? what do you call the face opposite the back of a chisel?).

If not that, then I think you should mail it to a blacksmith.

Re: Pitted chisel - worth the effort?

#3

Re: Oh, Scott - you're as bad as I am

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>Scott, I obtained a Pexto like your Greenlee about three years ago. Couldn't tell on ebay pictures how bad it was til I got it. Wasn't worth the return postage to send it back so I kept it. I flattened out all the pits at the edge and maybe 3/8" back. That way the edge was just fine. Everytime I sharpen it it seems to get better further back. The pits will keep you from getting the best edge that chisel could possibly have. So get it mirror flat at least right at the edge. Pits even a quarter of an inch back don't matter.

Re: Pitted chisel - worth the effort?

#4

I'll say the answer is "C"...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Although a certain talk show host could provide some assistance...

Re: Pitted chisel - worth the effort?

#5

Re: I'll say the answer is "C"...

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>Uh, yeah.

Anyway, The edge is pitted worse than the back. Think it's a lost cause...

Re: Pitted chisel - worth the effort?

#6

Re: Pitted chisel - worth the effort?

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>Pits? That's not pitted. It's Damascus!

The best apporach would be to anneal that chisel, grind the pits out, then reheat treat it. That's really not a big deal, especially if it's currently handleless. I think I have flattened chisels as bad as or worse than that. But I spent many hours doing it and burned many electrons such that the process was not economically, or ecologically sensible. If you aren't going to anneal it, I wouldn't proceed.

So if you can't use it, the smart thing to do is put it on ebay with a description that suggests you can see the Blessed Mother's face in the pits, or a likeness of Elvis if you prefer.

Adam

Re: Pitted chisel - worth the effort?

#7

Hmm...

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>Hi, Adam -

Lemme get this straight - anneal the chisel (yes, handleless) so the pits grind out easier, 'cause the steel would be softer, right? Then treat it to get back the hardness? I'm off for one more week before school starts - that might be a fun distraction!

Thanks for starting me down yet another slope...

Scott

Re: Pitted chisel - worth the effort?

#8

Or you could list it as

Stuart Hough

>an 18th century beer keg opener!

Re: Pitted chisel - worth the effort?

#9

Re: Pitted chisel - worth the effort?

Todd Hughes

>If it was the last chisel in the world..yeah OK fool with it. Instead it's an extreamly common tool that you can find an excellent example with a handle to replace it for $5 - $10 so why wast time messing with a piece of junk?...I'd open up the window and toss it in the scrap pile

Do you wash out paper coffee cups and save them ?......Todd

Re: Pitted chisel - worth the effort?

#10

Looks like an excellent loaner to me. :>)

Victor Parisian

>

Re: Pitted chisel - worth the effort?

#11

Re: Pitted chisel - worth the effort?

Charles

>Not worth it IMO.