Re: British practice? *LINK*
Sgian Dubh
>Warren, I tend to agree with you that Joyce's text is not the most accessible for readers, no matter whether they are British, American, Canadian, Australian or whatever. His written English is stilted and sometimes the sentence structure and content is convoluted.
In addition to the difficulty the reader has working his or her way through great wedges of hard to digest text, relevant illustrations to that text are sometimes in a far flung section of the book.
The book has plenty of faults of this nature, and there are additional ones of factual error that have never been corrected. Its descriptions of machinery and hand tools is looking rather dated now, although Alan Peters reworked it only partially successfully in the 1980s.
We furniture makers in the trade here in Great Britain all know that 'The Bible' is a reference to Ernest Joyce's The Technique of Furniture Making. For all its faults it still packs just about the biggest punch in its ability to concisely outline the essentials of more furniture making topics than any other book I can think of. Yes, there are smaller books that cover a more limited range of topics better, but none that I'm aware of that quite achieve what Joyce achieved.
Still, I wouldn't be without my 1980 print of the book. It is the second copy of it that I have owned; the first copy I purchased of the original 1970 print run in 1973 when I began my training as a furniture maker 'disappeared'. I foolishly lent it to someone and I never saw it again. I've never been fond of the Alan Peters version and I have no interest in owning one of the more modern paperback 'Dictionaries of Furniture Making'.
But, going back to drawer construction, I have never found the thick sided versions of drawers that north Americans in general favour particularly elegant. Some time ago I was involved in judging one of the Woodcentral contests and I recall giving the winning entry, one with with lots of drawers, high marks. I was very impressed with the overall look of the piece and the thought processes that had gone into it. Yet I had to mentally make allowances for the inelegant and clunky drawers that in my mind really needed a more delicate approach just because the piece was designed and made by an American. You will find pictures of the winning entry here. Have a look at the drawer construction. Do you think the dimensions of the dawer parts are 'right'? Slainte
Alternative link to jewellery box contest