Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Drawers for fine furniture

Posts

Drawers for fine furniture

#1

Drawers for fine furniture

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>Joyce councils that drawers for fine carcasses should be 5/16" or maybe 1/4" hard, good-wearing wood. Oak, teak and mahogany are preferable. Common pine, unless it be resinous, is not a good choice as it wears too fast. Is this common practice? I've used thick pine for utilitarian pieces in the past as well as basswood. I've heard others using poplar. I'm wanting to make a nicer piece and wondered what others have done.

Re: Drawers for fine furniture

#2

Re: Drawers for fine furniture

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>I've used red birch for drawer sides before, FWIW.

Aside: My truck's from Katy! Well, close, anyway - Crown Dodge... :-)

Re: Drawers for fine furniture

#3

Re: Drawers for fine furniture

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I think the choice of species of wood for the sides of drawers isn't as important as the grain orientation. While in most cases quartersawn wood is desirable for its stability, on drawer sides it is a draw back.

The grain is parallel to the wearing surface of the bottom of the drawer, and the groove for the bottom tends to weaken the sides of the drawers making them prone to splitting there.

Flat sawn wood presents hard and soft grain (spring wood/ summer wood) to the working surface against the wooden drawer guides. Many fine pieces of furniture are made with pine or poplar or sycamore or bass wood sides.

Heavy drawers made of hardwood will wear fast too, even when empty they are still heavy and how often do you use the drawers? I myself prefer pine and a couple of properly placed knots wear quite well.

Stephen

Re: Drawers for fine furniture

#4

Re: Drawers for fine furniture

ThomD

>Emphasis on the "fine". Fine furniture will not use fat drawer sides in any case. A more delicate look is sought. Sometimes the smallest drawers could be cut from a cigar box, and the dovetails can be chopped with one cut from each side. The best drawers don't run on the bottom edge of the wood anyway, if there is enough weight to cause significant wear. The lower edge of the sides is attached to wider pieces that significantly spread the wear, in which case the side could really be made of just about anything. Why one would choose pine is an open question, but there might be cases where it, or something aromatic (and soft), might be chosen. In such case proper construction is available to spread the wear.

I will use pine for rough furniture, not that it isn't nicely made and appropriate to it's use. A few years back I dovetailed a drawer for my kids craft table out of nice pine. It will long outlast that use.

The whole drawer thing is an interesting deal. I have lived with good furniture and bad for many years. About the only piece in our home that ever broke was a silver side that had the silver drawer machine dovetailed at the front and finger jointed at the back. The FGs were chosen since the narrow sides could not have been half blind machine DTd in the thin side and back material. The glue failed in that joint over years of opening and closing with the weight of silver. Pretty much everything else works file whether assembled with nails or better. There is wear on the bottoms of drawers in their cases, but it would normally take more than one lifetime to wear through.

Re: Drawers for fine furniture

#5

British practice?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Unless I'm badly mistaken, Ernest Joyce is reflecting British practice. It would be good to hear from Richard Jones or Bugbear or others familiar with the tradition on the sceptered isle. My impression from reading books is that they don't do pine (deal) for high-end drawer sides. Would be good to hear it from someone who knows for sure.

Wiley

Re: Drawers for fine furniture

#6

Good point Wiley, and just what I wondered.

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>

Re: Drawers for fine furniture

#7

Just to be clear

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>I've liked basswood in the past. It's stable, cheap, available in wide pieces and has few knots.

Re: Drawers for fine furniture

#8

Re: Drawers for fine furniture

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>A lot of the furniture I saw at Colonial Williamsburg had long leaf pine drawer sides, very pretty and stable.

Pam

Re: Drawers for fine furniture

#9

our stores are full of English furniture

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The antique store in Shelbyville KY typically has several dozen English chests of drawers, usually from the 1800's. One can typically find several more at Ruth's Antique store in Bristol, TN. Every piece I have seen has quartered oak drawer sides, very thin, and runners of various kinds on the bottom. And, in many cases these hard sides have milled substantial grooves into the soft mahogany drawer dividers.

Re: Drawers for fine furniture

#10

Re: Drawers for fine furniture

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>It is common in the US to find poplar or yellow pine (depending on region) , typically about 1/2" thick, for drawer sides in fine period pieces. When we toured the Philly museum with the SAPFM tour we saw drawers made of red cedar, white cedar (shingle stock), poplar, pine and maybe others. The room we were in had nothing but very fine furniture.

The drawer is relatively easy to repair if it becomes worn; the case it goes in is not. Hence, it follows that the drawer side is best made from a softer material and what ever the drawer rides on is to be made from something more durable.

I use maple for the interior runners, raised every so slightly above the drawer divider. The divider is what ever the primary wood happens to be- cherry, walnut, etc. It is this part that you do not want to become worn.

I like the concept of the English drawer with its thin side and light weight. Addition of a replaceable runner (this part has some other name that escapes me) applied under the drawer side can be made of something softer like poplar. Directions for making this kind of drawer are in many books. There are fancy ways of incorporating this drawer wear strip but I have seen many fine pieces where it was simply nailed on the drawer bottom.

Re: Drawers for fine furniture

#11

Re: Just to be clear

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>the only thing I don't like about basswood is that it can be fuzzy. Typically poplar is cheaper(but maybe not now with the ceiling fan business at a standstill) and I think easier to work to a bright smooth surface .

We used to sell mountains of it for trim on birch plywood cabinets because it stained nicely. But who has seen a birch plywood cabinet in a kitchen of late. The only market for basswood now is ceiling fan blades and that market is dry and yards have stacks of unsold basswood. You should be able to get a good deal on it.

It is a miserable wood to saw because the bark is stringy like redwood and it fouls up the mill.

Re: Drawers for fine furniture

#12

Re: Drawers for fine furniture

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>Bill -

Which museum in Philly? The art museum?

Scott, NW of Philly

Re: Drawers for fine furniture

#13

It was big and they said Rocky ran up its steps

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>We got there on a bus and were herded into an auditorium for a presentation by the chief furniture conservator. That is when I woke up and realized this was going to be a fine day. We had a presentation on the details of the restoration of the museum's signature piece, a magnificently carved high boy which we would later partially disassemble to see how it was put together. We were told that the museum was there for furniture study and we were invited to return to study pieces of interest.

In the main furniture room I asked a question on the internals of a piece similar to what I was trying to make. A drawer was removed to attain access and we explored its insides. That lead to a discussion on drawer construction and one by one the drawers of the pieces in the room were taken out and examined. I was amazed at the variety of wood used for their internals and the variety of coonstruction techniques. The varieties of construction are described in detail in Greene's book "American Furniture", which I have found to be very helpful in answering design/construction questions.

I was once told by a furniture restorer that the best way to learn what works in furniture construction is to study antique furniture. I have pursued this advise.

Re: Drawers for fine furniture

#14

Re: Drawers for fine furniture

Charles

>Brits would have/do use thin quartersawn stuff and set the bottom into drawer slips oriented so that they provide an additional bearing surface. This results in a light, nicely proportioned but strong and stable drawer. Assuming the stock was resawn, this extends the available material without sacrificing, well, anything.

Re: Drawers for fine furniture

#15

1/2

roninkokomo

>I agree with the 1/2

I think for mast large chests. i.e. bedroom stiff or stuff that holds china, etc. 1/4 is too delicate.

ron

Re: Drawers for fine furniture

#16

Indeed

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>And I have seen huge drawers made with the same thin material as small drawers and 150 years later they are still sound. It is a testimony to the strength of the dovetail.

Re: Drawers for fine furniture

#17

Re: British practice?

Sgian Dubh

>Well, Wiley, seeing as you mentioned my name, I guess I'll give you an answer based on my background and training. To a large extent what I came to learn is customary in British traditions of the past 200 or 250 years and current work practices is already covered by posts from Bill Tindall and Charles Stanford.

Ernest Joyce does reflect and portray the traditional British 'style' of furniture making. For the most part drawer sides in high quality work are slender and a slip is an essential part of drawer construction. In city made work from about the late 18th century onwards it is quite normal to see drawer sides around 6-8 mm (7/32- 5/16") thick in cabinets, desks and so on-- very light drawers, such as those found in the upper portions of desks, frequently exhibit sides only 3 mm (1/8") thick. Even very wide, deep, and tall drawers in such things as chests of drawers are relatively delicate where drawer sides are between perhaps 8 mm (5/16") and 13 mm (1/2"+) thick. Again a slip is incorporated.

To my eyes, brought up on an extensive diet of British furniture that ranges through ancient, antique, merely old, twentieth century and contemporary, most American drawer side dimensions in furniture from the late 18th century onwards right up to contemporay furniture seem heavy; of course they have to be heavy to accomodate the groove, because they seldom incorporate a slip in which the drawer bottom groove is worked. Those American drawer side dimensions reflect the kind of dimensions most commonly seen in drawers produced during the mid-1700s and earlier in Great Britain. In the UK it was really in the 1700s and into the 1800s that drawer construction developed into a quite sophisticated and delicate form.

A concise and useful source of information on the evolution of British drawer making is Charles Hayward's (1983) Antique or Fake, Bell and Hyman, pp 154- 166 (Chapter 12, Furniture construction: Drawers.) There are other books on the subject that help round out the knowledge base, but Hayward's book is not a bad place to begin with. Slainte.

Re: Drawers for fine furniture

#18

Re: British practice?

David Cockey

>"Those American drawer side dimensions reflect the kind of dimensions most commonly seen in drawers produced during the mid-1700s and earlier in Great Britain. In the UK it was really in the 1700s and into the 1800s that drawer construction developed into a quite sophisticated and delicate form."

That American practice is similar to British practice of the mid-1700s and earlier makes sense. My understanding is pre-1776 American culture, etc tended to lag behind the urban areas of England by a decade or two. After 1776 the Americans started going their own way.

Re: Drawers for fine furniture

#19

Agreed. I like poplar aslo.

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>

Re: Drawers for fine furniture

#20

Re: British practice?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I have to agree with you, David. I always saw the thin hardwood drawer sides as British practice rather than the "fine furniture" practice mentioned by Patrick. Frankly, I never saw Joyce and his mid 20th century text as particularly fine. In the same paragraph about the drawer sides he mentions using laminboard and plywood for drawer fronts. Particleboard was "unsuitable". Plywood bottoms are "usual" and "invariably used". If I recall, in this extensive text, there is only one sentence devoted to the smoothing plane, while sandpaper gets an entire chapter.

Re: Drawers for fine furniture

#21

Re: British practice? *LINK*

Sgian Dubh

>Warren, I tend to agree with you that Joyce's text is not the most accessible for readers, no matter whether they are British, American, Canadian, Australian or whatever. His written English is stilted and sometimes the sentence structure and content is convoluted.

In addition to the difficulty the reader has working his or her way through great wedges of hard to digest text, relevant illustrations to that text are sometimes in a far flung section of the book.

The book has plenty of faults of this nature, and there are additional ones of factual error that have never been corrected. Its descriptions of machinery and hand tools is looking rather dated now, although Alan Peters reworked it only partially successfully in the 1980s.

We furniture makers in the trade here in Great Britain all know that 'The Bible' is a reference to Ernest Joyce's The Technique of Furniture Making. For all its faults it still packs just about the biggest punch in its ability to concisely outline the essentials of more furniture making topics than any other book I can think of. Yes, there are smaller books that cover a more limited range of topics better, but none that I'm aware of that quite achieve what Joyce achieved.

Still, I wouldn't be without my 1980 print of the book. It is the second copy of it that I have owned; the first copy I purchased of the original 1970 print run in 1973 when I began my training as a furniture maker 'disappeared'. I foolishly lent it to someone and I never saw it again. I've never been fond of the Alan Peters version and I have no interest in owning one of the more modern paperback 'Dictionaries of Furniture Making'.

But, going back to drawer construction, I have never found the thick sided versions of drawers that north Americans in general favour particularly elegant. Some time ago I was involved in judging one of the Woodcentral contests and I recall giving the winning entry, one with with lots of drawers, high marks. I was very impressed with the overall look of the piece and the thought processes that had gone into it. Yet I had to mentally make allowances for the inelegant and clunky drawers that in my mind really needed a more delicate approach just because the piece was designed and made by an American. You will find pictures of the winning entry here. Have a look at the drawer construction. Do you think the dimensions of the dawer parts are 'right'? Slainte


Alternative link to jewellery box contest

Re: Drawers for fine furniture

#22

Re: British practice?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I agree with you completely. When I've seen thick sides, they seem to be poplar and/or basswood, so I thought that the thickness was needed. This is why I use oak when possible, so I can make fairly thin sides. The bottoms are thick since I central mount the "runner."

Pam

Re: Drawers for fine furniture

#23

Re: British practice?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Thanks for that essay, Richard!

As you've pointed out a number of times for us, it is the 'slip' which makes it possible to use the thin side, since the slip is grooved to receive the bottom and the drawer sides are not grooved.

What is a typical dimension for the slips, say, in a shallow writing table drawer, or a deeper full-width drawer in a chest of drawers? I'm aware that the top of the slips (which are visible along the insides of the drawer are given an ovolo or other molded shape, but what size stick do you start with to make the grooved and molded slip?

Thanks much! Ever thought about writing a book about drawers!?

Wiley

Re: Drawers for fine furniture

#24

Re: British practice?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Yes I agree, Richard, the drawer sides on the contest piece are too heavy and they turn me off. They are plenty heavy for the largest drawers and should be very much scaled down for the smaller drawers. I do not find 1/2 inch or 9/16 drawers too heavy for a large chest of drawers.

Re: Drawers for fine furniture

#25

Not all the American drawers in that contest.....

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>...were clunky.

I think fat drawer sides are mostly a matter of their maker never having been exposed to elegant ones. I still recall the epiphany of looking into the first English chest I ever saw in a Shelbyville antique shop. How are these made I wondered? They aren't much more difficult to make and they do look elegant. And they sure screw up the drawer runner if the slip fails or wasn't done right.

Any idea of how this design came to pass? Did the idea precede the wood used or did the availability of oak and the lack of some alternative lead to this style.