Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Good on Don Weber

Posts

Good on Don Weber

#1

Good on Don Weber

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I was reading through the latest Pop WW, and there's an article by Don Weber. Two of the pictures struck me: in one, he's cleaning up a rabbet with a Record 778 on which the nosepiece has been broken off (unless that's the elusive Record 777 duplex rabbet/chisel plane); in the other, he's using a Stanley No. 10 with a huge braze flash where the cheek had been broken and repaired.

Here's someone who could surely write off on his taxes the purchase of tools in more pristine condition, but clearly perfectly comfortable with funky tools that get the job done.

Nice to see a rust hunter getting that kind of celebrity.

Re: Good on Don Weber

#2

common in professional shops

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>It always strikes me when I visit a professional shop that they typically have the least expensive tool to get the job done, and the fewest of them. I am sure it's us hobbyists that mainly buy new/expensive tools. The tool manufacturers probably try to suppress photos from these shops.

Re: Good on Don Weber

#3

Re: Good on Don Weber

MikeW

>It's a great table. I got to sit at it when visiting Don's shop following WIA.

Though my photo isn't that great of the table itself--I was trying to get the shaving horse in the picture too--but it is a lovely table.


I enjoyed this article emmensely and would like to see Don write some more.

Take care, Mike

Re: Good on Don Weber

#4

Re: Good on Don Weber

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>Can't speak for the table, but the stick settee is awfully nice...

Re: Good on Don Weber

#5

Not free

David Cockey

>"Here's someone who could surely write off on his taxes the purchase of tools in more pristine condition, but clearly perfectly comfortable with funky tools that get the job done."

Professionals can't recover the cost of their tools through a tax decduction. What they can do is (assuming they itemize) is deduct the cost of the tool from their income. This then reduces their taxes by an amount equal to the marginal tax rate multiplied by the amount of the deduction. So if a professional is in the 28% tax bracket and buys a $100 tool, they can take a $100 deduction and wind up paying $28 less in taxes. So net cost to them of the $100 tool is $72, not free.

I suspect most professionals don't make as much from woodworking as many amateur woodworkers make working elsewhere. So even though they can take a deduction for the price of the tools the dollars they have to pay can still be important to them.

Re: Good on Don Weber

#6

As long as it works...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Who gives a rat's arse!?! Now daze that counts more than ever IMO.

Re: Good on Don Weber

#7

Re: Not free

Victor Parisian

>I used to tell my clients (Doctors to mechanics) " Don't let the tax tail wag the dog." Nobody ever spent there way to being rich.

Victor - Not always practicing what I preach. :>)

Re: Good on Don Weber

#8

Good points

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>

Re: Good on Don Weber

#9

Re: Not free

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>How about if the pro operates as a sole proprietorship? Then in effect he could deduct the total paid. Right? Wrong?

Pam

Re: Good on Don Weber

#10

Re: Not free

Charlie

>You deduct the total paid but the tax savings on the purchase is the total paid multiplied by your marginal tax rate.

Re: Good on Don Weber

#11

It can be evern worse

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The tax deduction (aka, "tax write off") may have to be depreciated, which means the cost of the capital purchase must be spread over many years of deductions resulting in even less actual savings, plus tedious paperwork (been there, done that).

Which is why enabling small businesses to deduct smaller capital purchases the first year is indeed a stimulus to make these purchases.

Re: Good on Don Weber

#12

Re: Not free

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yes, I understand that's the normal case; but the assumptions David made were that the woodworker was taxed at 28% and that the deductions weren't pretax. I doubt that many woodworkers make enough to pay 28%, which would make the item more expensive.

Also, if you treat the business as a business, you take most deductions pretax. So, if you buy a $300 plane, you can probably expense the depreciation in the first year, thus reducing the business income by $300. Depending on Obama's plans for small business tax cuts, you may be able to expense much more expensive items immediately in the near future. This would probably be the wisest tax cut if one wants to induce spending.

The real problem is the lack of income to purchase a $300 plane, which is why it's important to get in good with good vendors, review their products, get free products, etc. It's also real important to be able to make most of what you need.

Pam

Re: Good on Don Weber

#13

Re: Good on Don Weber

ThomD

>The point is that this suits DW moreso than some others. If he was doing other aspects of the biz it wouldn't look so great to be making do. If he was producing 5 grand infils for a living, it might look odd if he was doing it with junk tools, as one most certainly could. But DW has moved to Kentucky, has a sorta make-do lifstyle. The woodword article on him when he was in Cali. had pics of his shop which was woven around a tree. On the other hand his, chairs are lovely, and he is a tallented smith who's tools don't seem to look like crap, so that is somewhat disonant. He made this gouge on the WWS, that was formed in a swage block, the near sister of which I saw on craigslist last night for 900 bucks. Appearances can be confusing.

On the tax treatment side, I'm not smart enough to figure out what you pay when you barter a chair made from a tree you found in the forest for a champion blower and pot that was rusting in someone's yard, from which you make a poker that you swap for a pile of rusty woodworking tools from the 40s. Hey, it's a living.

Re: Good on Don Weber

#14

Thanks, Thom - that was kind of what I was aiming

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>at saying, but didn't know enough to say right.

This is not a criticism of those who like the shiny tools - not even of Chris Schwarz, who sure does like 'em: but I think it's really easy to fall into what camera people used to call "chrome collecting" when a slightly funky tool, well sharpened and tuned, can do the job. I think I was responding to his make it work attitude as shown by the tools he uses.

Re: Good on Don Weber

#15

justifying expenses

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I find that it is a lot easier justifying expenses for entertainment or recreation than for business. If you want to justify a tool for business you are inclined to think in terms of how much money a purchase will return over the years in increased efficiency. For a professional shop a new tool's cost includes the time spent getting the tool in shape and the time spent learning to use the old tool as smoothly and as unconsciously as the old. All in all, new tools are considerably more expensive for the professional.

Re: Good on Don Weber

#16

Re: justifying expenses

ThomD

>Thanks Bill.

Warren, I agree with you. As we can see in the Studley chest even, part of the return can be from the look of the tools a person has. How consistent is that look with the other aspects of their professional persona. The look of tools took a beating when accounting thinking started to take aver, and beautiful old iron machines, for example, took on the look of filing cabinets in new versions. The tools had to embody the look of efficient accounting practices even if the molds already existed for the earlier designs and extra pieces of trim where require to complete the new look. But at least there was alignment in the overall look of the enterprise.

Re: Good on Don Weber

#17

Meeting and watching Don was one

Chuck Nickerson

>of the 17 highlites of the WIA conference. If I could get appropriate green wood here in Los Angeles, I'd take classes from Don.

Re: Good on Don Weber

#18

Re: Good on Don Weber

Dan Moening

>I had the same reaction when I saw those tools as well.

Popular Woodworking has a free slideshow in PDF format that includes more pictures than in the publication (right click for next, left click for previous):

http://blogs.popularwoodworking.com/editorsblog/content/binary/HayrakeTable.pdf

The last picture is worth the trip.

Re: Good on Don Weber

#19

Re: Green wood is no problem...

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I'm in the Bay Area, and we're by no means Kentucky, when it comes to hardwood. The oak for Don's table came from Napa, 45 minutes north of here. So did the acacia stacked in my driveway, a storm fall that whacked a law office, and crushed a desk vacated 5 minutes earlier by the fellow that went for coffee. The chair I started Friday was from a white ash felled in Contra Costa county 90 days ago. 48" minimum trunk size, it was larger than the chain saws could easily handle...

You need a woodworkers' club and a relationship with the arborists in the valley. Then, when they have wood to remove, which is every day, much of it gets used, rather than hauled off, and paid for to recycle. The range of species in SoCal is amazing, and these folks don't want it all turned into mulch.

There's more than we can use now...

Re: Good on Don Weber

#20

Re: Good on Don Weber

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I noticed the tools that he used were all of good quality, even if not all of the latest Made in Maine variety.

There was, however, a standout saw, looking very much as though it had been recently made by one of our regulars here, from the Pacific Northwest. Is it just that one cannot find an old MikeW saw? ;-)

Don's work is a reminder to me that I can get a little over the top in the tool box sometimes, and have to reign it in a bit. And focus on the results, not the bling.

Re: Good on Don Weber

#21

Re: Not free

Jack F

>Pam,

The deduction for the expense is pretax, but the $300 spent for the plane would otherwise be take home income. If you did not buy the plane, you would pay some extra tax on that $300. So your net loss of income is less than the $300, but not enough less in most cases. If you are in a 25% tax bracket, you lose 75% of the money spent from your income. That is why most small businesses often don't provide many benefits - the money spent comes straight out of the owners take home income. In a big business, it comes out of the shareholders income.

Jack

former small business owner

Re: Good on Don Weber

#22

Re: Not free

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Jack, if you incorporate your business, any size allowed, it's a whole different operation. The exception, Subchapter-S corps.

Pam, also a small business owner for 20+ years, we incorporated from day one