Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Finally getting off my butt

Posts

Finally getting off my butt

#1

Finally getting off my butt

wilbur

>After my run of New Year's nap taking, I finally made some movement towards building my "real" workbench. I jointed and squared up eight 8' Douglas fir 4x4s that I've accumulated from a local borg over a 12 month period. When I'm done gluing this up, I expect to have a benchtop that's essentially clear quartersawn Douglas fir with pretty tight grain (21-38 rings per inch, if I counted correctly).

That poplar beam that I had been using since May still works great. I've been able to plane, chop mortises, do chisel work, and saw using it without issues. I think that the reason it's taken me so long to get around to building my "real" workbench is that the poplar beam has worked out so much better than I thought it would. And actually, the main benefit that I think I will get from this bench is extra counter space. I think this benchtop will wind up being about 7' x 22". Over the past several months, I've needed the extra counter space much more than I've needed a leg vise.


img

Re: Finally getting off my butt

#2

Re: Finally getting off my butt

Ray Binnicker

>Hey Wilbur,

I don't post much on this forum but I do read all of them. Your choice of the Douglas Fir sure got me envious, though. That stuff here in the deep south would be tough to come by; our choice being good ole southern yellow pine. The old addage of; "Location, Location, Location" sure rings true. That will be a great looking bench. I'm sure you'll post some pictures of the finished product.

Ray Binnicker

Re: Finally getting off my butt

#3

Re: Finally getting off my butt

wilbur

>Hi Ray,

Ironically, I got this Douglas fir mainly because southern yellow pine isn't available here in NJ, or in much of the northeast, from what I can tell. But it certainly shares many of the qualities that Chris Schwarz says is useful in a workbench: stiff, dense, and cheap.

One difference that I can see between Douglas fir and southern yellow pine is that southern yellow pine seems to be more knot free than Douglas fir. It really took a LOT of picking before I came up with these 4x4s. 2x material around here is predominantly Douglas fir, and it's not really useable for workbench material because of all the knots, even if you use the "take a 2x12 and rip it down to get clear wood" trick.

Re: Finally getting off my butt

#4

I suspect that the doug fir traveled farther

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>to get to Wilbur's shop than Southern yellow pine would have - the commercial stands are predominantly on the West Coast, kind of petering out by the time they get to Utah.

But the Northeast doesn't seem to have a good equivalent of Douglas fir OR yellow pine (you poor folks back there have to suffer with hard maple, cherry, and eastern white pine, and trash wood like that), so, for whatever reason, the New Jersey retailers decided that shipping Douglas fir east was cheaper than shipping yellow pine north.

I think this must somehow be related to the logic that air fares to the Southeast have always seemed disproportionately expensive in relation to the distance. Or something. Or maybe the yellow pine cartel just doesn't like to ship north of the Mason-Dixon line, but I think I'll stop now before I get in real trouble.

By the way, Wilbur, my trained-as-a-patternmaker grandfather's bench was made of Douglas fir 2x12's laid flat - so you're well within a longstanding tradition in using that material, although he'd have been very envious of the stoutness of your bench.

Re: Finally getting off my butt

#5

Re: I suspect that the doug fir traveled farther

Ray Binnicker

>I live in the middle of SYP land and it is virtually impossible to find/get/buy SYP, anywhere, in any size other than 2x12 and 2x10. It seems all the SYP cut is immediately shipped out to become "Treated" wood for the deck and dock industry. Our local Borgs have what they call "whitewood" in the 2x4, 2x6, 2x8 category. If you get out into the small mills you can find some othe sizes but it may not be as dry as you like.

If we didn't have something to worry and fuss about, it would become a boring world, I guess.

GBA

Ray Binnicker

Re: Finally getting off my butt

#6

Re: Finally getting off my butt

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Wilbur,

Doug fir is a great choice for a bench, for the reasons you say--strong and cheap--and in addition it is not slippery. Not slippery, meaning that no amount of planing will make it really smooth--it always has tack.

One thing to think about is grain runout and splinters on the edges. A doug fir splinter is just as bad as a white oak splinter--will go right through your hand. It may be that the quartered cut will take care of that. If not, maybe soften the edge arris and put some shellac on it to glue prospective splinters down.

Wiley

Re: Finally getting off my butt

#7

Welcome back, Bill

Larry Williams

>I hope all went well and you're as comfortable as you can be.

Re: Finally getting off my butt

#8

Re: Welcome back, Bill

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Larry,

So far, but I haven't had my surgery yet - I had the pleasure of meeting some more nice folks as part of my surgery prep earlier this week, and seem to have passed their pre-op tests.

I go off to surgery-land on Tuesday, Jan. 20.

Bill

Re: Finally getting off my butt

#9

Re: Finally getting off my butt

wilbur

>Thanks for the tip, Wiley. I've already learned about Douglas fir splinters the hard way.

For the shellac coat, would you suggest a heavier or lighter cut of shellac?

Re: Finally getting off my butt

#10

If I were you...

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I would replace those cheap saw horses with some nice hand made, fancy jointed saw horses, for a bench base.

Stephen

Re: Finally getting off my butt

#11

What I do

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>I always have a rubbermaid quart container of blond shellac around, at somewhere between 1/2 lb and 1 lb (who knows exactly), for all kinds of stuff. If one coat ain't enough, add another one. Big advantage of a light cut is that it's easy to wipe on and get uniform cover, dries fast and hard, and doesn't make a fat edge from surface tension.

Just swipe a light coat along the edge. Then another. Using the shellac like glue to embed the loose fiber ends along the edge. If no splinters, you're done. Get a splinter, do more.

Shellac is basic, like rocks and sticks.

Wiley

Re: Finally getting off my butt

#12

John from NM will disagre here.

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Splinters in DG only come from some areas. The DG fir I got to build my bench are perfect. 4" X 6" X 12' sections to be cut in half completely smooth and knot free. It didn't take me a year to buy them, but on sale at my loco supplier the price was right mostly. My only problem is now a 6' bench seems small, too small for my likes. No worries, it will make a rock solid base depending on witch way I go.