Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

English field gate *LINK*

Posts

English field gate *LINK*

#1

English field gate *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi All,

I recently had the good fortune to receive a Christmas gift from an acquaintance in England. The gift is a book entitled 'The Village Carpenter', by Walter Rose. I think I recall Bugbear referring to this book at some point in the past. The book is an account by Mr. Rose of his family's history in the woodworking business, with particular focus on his recall of the way things were done, the way they were made, the attitudes which were held--in late 19th century village England. I recommend it heartily for the sentimental and history-minded.

Down to cases....In one passage, Walter Rose is describing the English field gate in considerable detail. And he is lamenting the modern simplifications of the 'real deal' gate as his family and workmen made them. There is a link below to a photo from 'The Village Carpenter', showing such a gate.

Mr. Rose calls particular attention to the top rail; and how the top rail is made heavier at the hinge end; and how the beefed-up top rail is detailed with a 'jowl'. The jowl is essentially a quirked ogee, and is set off by chamferring of the top rail.

Walter Rose rightly considers this jowl to be a beautiful detail, and he refers to the modern practice of simply tapering the top rail. Question: Is this older English gate detail still seen anywhere? In England? In the US? Australia? Canada? I did a google-image search, and sure enough, there were tapered-rail field gates, but no jowly ones being offered currently. Seems like a beautiful detail to me.

Wiley


English field gate; from 'The Village Carpenter'

Re: English field gate *LINK*

#2

Re: English field gate

Frank Mutchler

>Hi Wiley. It would be nice to see a close-up showing the detail of the hinge end of the top rail.

Re: English field gate *LINK*

#3

Re: English field gate

Michael Stadulis in Southern NJ------WebKitFormBou

>Wiley, this company has been around for a long while and I bet you know some companies that use their hardware . They used to have gate plans on the website. Nice stuff.

www.snugcottage hadware

Mike

Re: English field gate *LINK*

#4

Re: English field gate

Hank Knight

>Wiley,

LOML and I rented a farm house just outside the town limit of Hawkshead in Cambria (Lakes District) for a couple of weeks several years ago. We walked into town often for dinner at one of the local pubs. There were a number of gates along the way, and I remeber remarking at the detail on several of them. It seemed odd and nice to find such detail on a simple wooden utility gate. It added to to charm of the place. I don't recall, now, how the detail looked, but I do recall that the top rail wasn't simply tapered as you described - there were some plain tapered ones too and some metal ones. My guess is that the fancy ones were similar or perhaps identical to the old ones mentioned in your book. That country is sheep country and there are fences, stone walls and gates everywhere. I'll bet there are a lot of the old ones around if you took the time to look.

Hank

Re: English field gate *LINK*

#5

Re: English field gate--here is detail *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Frank,

Here is best I can get of the hinge-side detail. Note the quirk ogee on the jowl. Does look like a hog jowl.

Wiley


English field gate/upper rail detail (hinge side)

Re: English field gate *LINK*

#6

Re: English field gate--here is detail

Frank Mutchler

>Thanks, Wiley. Yes, indeed it does look like a pig's jowl! Picture really set me straight!

Re: English field gate *LINK*

#7

Re: English field gate

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I have got to get a copy of that book.

Somewhere in my stuff I have several photographs of a half a dozen gates from Old Sturbridge Village. The attention to detail is amazing.

Stephen

Re: English field gate *LINK*

#8

Here you go. *LINK*

Phil Joines in Krum, Tx

>Most of them are in the UK. Shipping is about $11. There's only one in the USA at $38.19


The book on Abebooks

Re: English field gate *LINK*

#9

Looks like a saw nib

CJ

>Could it be for aiming the gate closed? ;)

CJ

Re: English field gate *LINK*

#10

The nature of ornament

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>CJ and all,

I think it is an interesting thing how particular ornamental features come to be. Not that we can ever find out for sure, since it's all lost to antiquity. But that hog jowl may have started out as a drip edge. Bear in mind that the modern version, which is simply to taper the top rail, has the functional effect of conducting rainwater along the bottom of the rail, straight back to the post, and down the post--right to the foundation of the whole gate. The jowl is both a barrier and a drip edge, and tends to protect the post. Looks cool, too. Sometimes there is synergy in ornament.

Wiley

Re: English field gate *LINK*

#11

Let's be REALLY careful here

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>the saw nib controversy has kind of settled down of late - best to let sleeping dragons lie, eh?

Bill, tempted but resisting

Re: English field gate *LINK*

#12

St. Roy...

Greg B�tit, Crown Point, NY.

>Has an interesting and entertaining discussion of saw nibs in his latest book.

Actually, the whole book promises to be interesting and entertaining. I don't know how many discussions on dovetailing I've read, but his was one I'm glad I didn't miss.

greg -who has only browsed a few sections of the book, maybe the rest of them are dull as... Uh... Well, you know, *dull*.